Canada addresses the personal/corporate problem with an integrated tax system: To a first approximation, individuals who receive corporate dividends get a refund of the taxes which the dividend-paying corporations paid on that income. It never works out exactly equal, but as long as I've been running Tarsnap the difference between "pay a bonus" (employment income for me, deductible for the corporation) and "pay a dividend" (dividend income for me, paid by the corporation with after-tax dollars) has been less than 1%.
I really don't understand why other countries don't use the same system.
I understand what you're saying. If you make $50,000,000 per year, then at some point it's worth spending $500,000 on an accountant who will manage to avoid you paying $10,000,000 in taxes. The math clearly works out, and that's why people do it. I get it.
But man, does it really need to be that way? Is it really so bad to "only" gain $40,000,000 per year instead of $49,500,000? Can you really not get by without that $9.5MM? We've got crumbling infrastructure, cash-strapped schools, students loaded with debt, and the fallout from a housing bubble, but Mark Zuckerberg really needs that new yacht.
Anyway, I can't say I wouldn't do the same in his situation. I understand the motivations. I'm just griping.
* Numbers all fabricated to illustrate my point.
I am most certainly not opposed to the idea of taxes since society cannot function without the government providing some essential services. That said, I am opposed to paying a dime more than entirely necessary as it stands today because I see so much of my tax contributions being wasted.
* Medicare ineligibility to negotiate rates
* Military projects that are vastly over budget
* Government budgeting practices that promote blowing your entire budget at the end of the year so that it's not cut the next
* Excessive and abusive pension amounts for public employees
* Refusal to appropriately discipline public employees (police) for wrongful conduct
I can keep listing more, however before I am asked or required to send in another penny to be spent, I personally would expect at least some of these issues to be addressed, at least where spending is concerned. Until progress is made in these areas, then I will continue to be staunchly opposed to any tax increases and will do whatever I can to lower my own tax bill. If I feel my money is being wasted, then I may as well be the one wasting it rather than the government.
(To be ultra-clear, I know this is in the realm of fantasy-land and I understand why.)
It's interesting that you mention education and infrastructure as the big problems, because this is an article about federal taxation, while those are largely state and municipal areas of responsibility.
We spend more on education per capita than every developed country except Switzerland. And while our infrastructure is crumbling, it's because states and cities choose to pay for it through regressive means such as user fees instead of taxes. That's probably because they're in competition with other states and cities to attract residents and businesses.
They didn't get that wealthy by understanding the meaning of the word "enough".
Doubling or tripling tax revenue from the super wealthy would not provide the funds to solve any of these problems, if indeed they would be solvable with "more money". There just aren't that many super wealthy people.
If you assume they can make 10% annually on that wealth (probably optimistic), that's $200B/year.
It is totally implausible given the history of U.S. tax policy and compliance, but let's say you could capture a 50% effective rate of that.
That's $100B/year: Not even half the increase in U.S. tax revenue between 2013 and 2014 due to economic growth[1]. Did that extra $200B enable Congress and the President to solve significant problems last year?
[1] And whether you believe in the Laffer curve or not, it's hard to imagine that levying a massive tax on billionaires' investment income would have a positive effect on economic growth & thus tax revenue from the non-super-rich.
There was recently an op-ed in the New York Times about this very subject.+ I encourage you to read the comments. Every time the issue is raised you get the same predictable whines about how tough life is on two or three hundred thousand dollars a year. A typical complaint is about how expensive Manhattan apartments are, which is like complaining that it is hard to make ends meet after making the monthly Ferrari payment.
+ http://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/28/opinion/campaign-stops/250...
But isn't there an argument to be made that when these ultra-rich are stripped of their billions, they are less likely to spend money trying to do things to bend laws to their benefit?
If Koch brothers / Soros did not have the billions they do, they'd spend a lot less gaming the system, thereby the larger population of non-rich having greater power in the system, in essence ensuring better democracy, do you agree?
I think we have exactly the government one would expect from taking account of the demographics of voters. 2/3 of voters in midterm federal elections are 45+ and the median voter in municipal elections is pushing 60: https://www.minnpost.com/eric-black-ink/2015/07/tracking-tur....
Given the demographics, I have a hard time seeing what exactly would be different if the rich had less power. I mean, are we going to raise taxes to make health care free for younger people, when the median voter is going to be eligible for Medicare in a few years anyway? And is it really rich people lobbying for more surveillance and resisting decriminalization of drugs, or is it my mother?
While your mother may be voting for such policies, she is likely not lobbying for them (or writing them). The companies and high net worth individuals who have a financial stake in these policies are the ones doing that.
Every piece of legislation that exists benefits a rich person in some way.
[1] Which they do by a huge margin, with the sole exception of marijuana: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/04/17/drug-legalization-p....
The direct tax clause of the original constitution, even as modified by the sixteenth amendment, probably forbids such a thing at the federal level. So it'd likely take a constitutional amendment.
That said, I'm not quite as pessimistic as you. Between consumption taxes and estate taxes (which are about the only wealth tax we have) we could get at most money if we had the will to do so. The estate tax is filled with holes because Congress wants it to be, not because of any inherent complexity or definitional difficulties.
There is an ultimate tax avoidance strategy of renouncing citizenship and living and consuming abroad. I would impose a lifetime ban on entry on renouncers, but beyond that I think it is fair game. If you aren't an American we shouldn't be taxing you.
Also it is my understanding that if an American would like to move to another country, and become a citizen of that country (for any number of reasons), they have to renounce their American citizenship.
People moving to the United States, on the otherhand, may retain their citizenship of certain countries, such as Canada.
I'm not aware of a single American individual who gave up their citizenship for politics (and I work in this field).
Secondly, nobody has to give it up if they obtain another citizenship. US government actually makes it hard and expensive to go through this process.
>> I'm not aware of a single American individual who gave up their citizenship for politics (and I work in this field).
Firstly I'm not sure which 'both' are untrue, as I had 3 points, so your response is a little confusing.
Politics: There where some number of American men who where wanting dodge the American draft before it was abolished in 1973, particular in the 60 and 70s. I suspect some number of draft-dodgers renounced their American citizenship. Similarly, some number of American women did not want their children to be subject to the draft, and didn't agree with American wars, so they too moved away, and renounced their American Citizenship--I know some women for who this is absolutely the case. I also know some people who currently reside outside of the US who would renounce their American citizenship were Trump to be elected president. I would say all of these example falls under the board heading of "politics".
I would agree that it is currently the policy of the US Government not to make individuals renounce their citizenship where they to become a citizen of another country, but I do not know the history. It is that other countries do make new citizen renounce their other citizenship(s); Singapore, for example. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renunciation_of_citizenship
Similarly, if Singapore citizen was to obtain American Citizenship, s/he would have to renounce their Singaporean Citizenship.
Wealth has many of the same problems. Unless you're going to try to tax someone's global holdings (how?), it's much easier for a hedge fund billionaire to park (and enjoy) his money in Chilean wineries and Dubai-registered jets than it is for a mere millionaire. Sure, you can buy a little plot in the south of France or a condo in the Caribbean, but it will cost you a much larger fraction of your income to keep it up and travel to enjoy it.
And trusts can shield wealth just as well as they can shield income.
It's effectively impossible to make the top few hundred taxpayers pay an effective rate much higher than 15%. But other than some appeal to fairness, who cares? They're already paying thousands of times over what the median taxpayer is.
Redistribution doesn't have to mean taking cash from one person and handing it to another. Instead taxes pay for investments like national security, scientific research, infrastructure, education, health care, environmental health, etc. These raise the overall living standard, and if the rich pay a larger proportion of these costs, it is a form of redistribution.
So yes, it's destabilizing for ultra wealthy to keep trying to take all the marbles.
You mean justice? And other than an appeal to justice, what is wrong with any injustice?
>Taking as much as possible is what the wealthy do.
There's a difference between taking and earning. Some wealthy people take wealth (e.g. steal it), but most of them earn it. Bill Gates didn't take any of my money, but he earned some of it, because I decided that a product his company sold was worth the price.
Taxation, on the other hand, is not earned money; it's taken.
"""Consider the argument "How can we have a holiday celebrating Martin Luther King? After all, he was a criminal!"
Technically, Martin Luther King was a criminal, in that he broke some laws against public protests that the racist South had quickly enacted to get rid of him. It's why he famously spent time in Birmingham Jail.
And although "criminal" is a very negative-sounding and emotionally charged word, in this case we have to step back from our immediate emotional reaction and notice that the ways in which Martin Luther King was a criminal don't make him a worse person.
A philosopher might say we're equivocating between two meanings of "criminal", one meaning of "person who breaks the law", and another meaning of "horrible evil person." Just because King satisfies the first meaning (he broke the law) doesn't mean he has to satisfy the second (be horrible and evil).
Or consider the similar argument: "Ayn Rand fled the totalitarian Soviet Union to look for freedom in America. That makes her a traitor!" Should we go around shouting at Objectivists "How can you admire Ayn Rand when she was a dirty rotten traitor"?
No. Once again, although "traitor" normally has an automatic negative connotation, we should avoid instantly judging things by the words we can apply to them, and start looking at whether the negative feelings are deserved.
Or once again the philosopher would say we should avoid equivocating between "traitor" meaning "someone who switches sides from one country to an opposing country" and "horrible evil untrustworthy person."
Our language contains a lot of words like these which package a description with a moral judgment. For example, “murderer” (think of pacifists screaming it at soldiers, who do fit the technical definition “someone who kills someone else”), “greedy” (all corporations are “greedy” if you mean they would very much like to have more money, but politicians talking about “greedy corporations” manage to transform it into something else entirely) and of course that old stand-by “infidel”, which sounds like sufficient reason to hate a member of another religion, when in fact it simply means a member of another religion. It's a stupid, cheap trick unworthy of anyone interested in serious rational discussion.
And calling taxation “theft” is exactly the same sort of trick. What's theft? It's taking something without permission. So it's true that taxation is theft, but if you just mean it involves taking without permission, then everyone from Lew Rockwell up to the head of the IRS already accepts that as a given.
This only sounds like an argument because the person who uses it is hoping people will let their automatic negative reaction to theft override their emotions, hoping they will equivocate from theft as "taking without permission" to "theft as a terrible act worthy only of criminals".
Real arguments aren't about what words you can apply to things and how nasty they sound, real arguments about what good or bad consequences those things produce."""
The how - is what is in the wind - international cooperation.
https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-soi/12intop400.pdf
Life in the U.S. is good, but nobody is getting an "unfair" allocation of all the great benefits and opportunities the federal government provides if they're paying $56M for it.
$335 million!
The ultra-wealthy get a huge allocation of "benefits and opportunities" from the government, much more than anyone else. $56M seems like a fantastic deal, as it pays for the system that is set up pretty much entirely to ensure these top earners make gobs and gobs of money forever.
1: http://www.cbsnews.com/news/the-400-highest-earning-american...
Now, that's the limit of what's morally "fair." What's "optimal," taking into account competing developed countries, may be a lot lower. But taxing up to that limit is "fair."
I feel there is another "fair" - that of paying the same percentage of income or wealth as everyone else. This is easier to explain and appeals to a more monkey brain part of us.
As an example (from the cbsnews link)
While the tax rate on dividends has since jumped to 20
percent for people earning more than $400,000 annually,
that's still far below the tax imposed on wages for
America's highest earners.
20 percent on dividends !? That can't be right ? In the UK we get the same rate as all other income (40 rising to 45).Can I move ?
That's the difference between taxes on investments and on income. Investors are risking loss in a way that workers are not: If your boss stops paying you, you stop working.
And since Bangladesh's median per capita income is something like $600, it implies that tax rates capturing all but $600 of the median U.S. worker's $51,000 would be "morally fair". 98.8% effective rates!
I don't think a definition so constructed has any significant value.
The morally fair tax rate is more like 85%--the median U.S. individual income is around $30,000, while the median PPP-adjusted Bangladeshi income is $3,300. But yeah, that's absolutely fair. Just the simple fact of being born in the United States, keeping everything else equal, gives you a huge advantage in wealth.
What you're missing is that people who are in favor of these kinds of shenanigans tend also to be emphatically against this "equality" rubbish.
This is a problem that could be solved with sufficient political will. But, since our politicians are owned by these top few, and the government provides the framework under which these top few stay at the top, there is effectively zero chance that this political will could ever materialize.
I find it hard to hold a grudge against wealthy individuals who minimize tax liability. It's perfectly legal and it's in their best interest.
What if it was made legal because they bought politicians who made the laws in their favor?
Also, the law isn't moral. Lots of things are legal but completely immoral. Slavery comes to mind as an historical example.
I don't agree. Almost every nation, state, and locality in the developed world and a great many elsewhere have done it.
> Who determines what is the fair share?
We decide democratically. Most of those nations, states, ad localities have been doing that for a long time too.
And wealth managers often charge fees based on a percentage of assets (at least for $1/2+ million accounts). So there is precedent for such a system.
The political reality of expanding on this is a different matter. Any change would have to be gradual, because taxation is a huge intervention in market forces. i.e. to just suddenly stop taxing income, and tax wealth or tax consumption would very abruptly change the dynamics of the economy. But we don't have a political system that incentives 10, 20, 50 years down the road sorts of end goals. We have a system that favors the catch phrase of the week.
(Also, having it in addition to others, instead of making it the traditional Single Tax ruins the whole point.)
Ideally it'd be the single tax, but that doesn't preclude it from being useful in conjunction with other taxes. For example, we could start by simply replacing property taxes with LVT, and that alone would spur economic growth.
#ProblemSolved
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10457725
The fact is that this is going to happen because there just isn't a "one size fits all" tax code that would work.
If you tax income, then people will take their compensation in a corporation.
You tax corporations, then people will take their compensation in a deferred format, like options.
YOu tax that and people will just move their money making operations off shore.
You tax that and people will start to use charities, ala the famous Walton family charity tax shelter... http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-09-12/how-wal-ma...
And now it becomes very obvious why the tax code is so convoluted. If you make 8 figures year then it's worth your while to spend alot of money to structure your finances so you pay as little tax as legally required.
Someone like Mark Zuckerberg never needs to earn another dollar or get another option grant again. He can just let his capital gains appreciate and loan against it such that he doesn't have to ever pay income tax again.
As an accountant once told me unless you tax wealth then you can't fight this... and good luck getting an annual tax against wealth passed into law.