Also, I'm inclined to believe that the TSA is incompetent all the way up.
If you're tagging face when they get processed and running face recognition at the scanner, (which is either already possible or will be possible within a couple years) you don't even need to do that.
On a related note, I feel like people dont factor in the (exponential) progress of technology in their threat assessment. For example sites that tell people their password strength don't count Moore's law into password difficulty calculations. Nobody uses post quantum crypto. The NSA has played this by storing as much interesting encrypted data and then decrypting it when technology progresses Or vulnerabilities are discovered. Most of our encrypted data is plain text in some X number of years.
Anyway going back to scanners, you could just store data and wait until computer vision gets to the point where you can do it with computers. Anything a person can do a computer will eventually be able to do. If a person could watch a bunch of camera feeds and track each person from the point he presents ID to the point he is scanned a computer will eventually be able to too.
IMO they already can.
I agree with you, though, that your last point makes this moot. They're too bumbling for me to worry.
If they really wanted to use body scans to track people, they'd arrange the checkpoints so the body scanner is the first place you go after they scan your boarding pass and/or ID. And when questioned about why they rearranged the checkpoints that way they'd just say "TSA security evolves to counter ever changing security threats, and we can't speak specifically about what prompted this reconfiguration." End of story since security theater is not to be questioned.
Depending upon the airport, people can go from the ID checks to up to a dozen different lines with no ordering of people as they go through the scanners. Then on the swabbing side, there's no checking of ID once again.
If their intent was as nefarious as you claimed, the TSA would have changed the way you move through security in order to properly correlate the collected biometric information with ID.
That said, I'm not too sure how that would work. They only check your boarding pass at the initial security check before the scanners, and the order at which people have their IDs checked is not preserved once you get to the scanners, so you can't track identification that way. On top of that, as someone who's been swabbed multiple times (I'm assuming something to do with my camera equipment), I've never been asked for identification when swabbed. So you might get some DNA to sequence, but you won't really know who it actually is.
So, unless they are using face recognition to scan you when you get your boarding pass checked then re-compare it at the rapiscan, there's no PII gathering happening.
(Now, they could always make a policy change and say "now you must tag your boarding pass on the scanner before entering" but we're not there yet.)
Although not directly at the time of scanning video surveillance shouldn't make it too hard to match the records up.
They could pool results saying "these 10 scans are potentially from these 40 people" and cross reference against every airport visit, but are they that competent?
TSA does not store any personally identifiable information from AIT screening.Where did you get this information from?
After this holiday's eating season is over, my body shape will diverge even more!
I don't like it one bit, but every wacko that told you the government was listening on every phone call and reading every email turns out to be very right, and after Clapper, et al lied about it to Congress with no repercussions, well, maybe don't be so quick to dismiss further theories about the government spying on you.
They're biometrics. They take precise measurements of a person's shape, which is sufficient to detect if someone is traveling under a false name, and they're building a database of those biometrics to have available for use elsewhere. If the scan's result is ambiguous, they swab your hands and stick the swab in a machine, supposedly to detect residue from explosives but with the nice side-effect of producing a stored DNA sample for later use. They've proven pretty useless for controlling the flow of contraband, but they're quite useful for catching fugitives. While the people staffing the checkpoints aren't particularly smart, it's reasonable to assume that the people at the top are pretty clever, and their policies are consistent with this having been the real goal all along.
If they tried collecting fingerprints from travelers, they would get a very strong backlash. This way, they get a weaker backlash and some jokes about how stupid they are for using machines that can't reliably detect guns.