> Clinton simply demonstrated her extreme ignorance
The first Crypto War over the Clipper Chip and years of key escrow debate was part of Bill Clinton's administration. There probability that Hillary Clinton being "extremely ignorant" about encryption is laughably small.
> calling for computer scientists to think about the issue
She knew what the computer scientist position was 15-20 years ago.
She understands that "Apple and Tech Experts" are angry about this issue, but she clearly doesn't understand why.
http://www.cbsnews.com/news/democratic-debate-transcript-cli...
> CLINTON: I would not want to go to that point. I would hope that, given the extraordinary capacities that the tech community has and the legitimate needs and questions from law enforcement, that there could be a Manhattan-like project, something that would bring the government and the tech communities together to see they're not adversaries, they've got to be partners.
> It doesn't do anybody any good if terrorists can move toward encrypted communication that no law enforcement agency can break into before or after. There must be some way. I don't know enough about the technology,Martha, to be able to say what it is, but I have a lot of confidence in our tech experts.
> And maybe the back door is the wrong door, and I understand what Apple and others are saying about that. But I also understand, when a law enforcement official charged with the responsibility of preventing attacks -- to go back to our early questions, how do we prevent attacks -- well, if we can't know what someone is planning, we are going to have to rely on the neighbor or, you know, the member of the mosque or the teacher, somebody to see something.
> CLINTON: I just think there's got to be a way, and I would hope that our tech companies would work with government to figure that out. Otherwise, law enforcement is blind -- blind before, blind during, and, unfortunately, in many instances, blind after.
> So we always have to balance liberty and security, privacy and safety, but I know that law enforcement needs the tools to keep us safe. And that's what i hope, there can be some understanding and cooperation to achieve.
----------
I would like it for my politicians to understand technical issues, alas I've resigned myself to the fact that politicians really don't know what they are talking about. And all Clinton has done here is prove once more, that she doesn't know what she's talking about.
Anyone who knows this issue (ie: You and Me) both know that there is a direct contradiction in Clinton's speech here. She's either playing dumb, or is dumb about this issue.
And the rest of the reporters (Vice, Intercept, etc. etc.) are going crazy as if this is some existential threat on the internet. No, in my opinion, this is simply another presidential candidate trying to be vague about an issue they don't fully understand.
I agree with this, which is why I don't plan on voting for her. But to call her a "threat" when her only threat is "being ignorant" is making mountains out of molehills.
But sure, hyperventilate about a made up issue if you like. There's actual issues in this country to care about, and you're welcome to misrepresent Clinton's words to self-manufacture an enemy if you want to.
I'm simply calling out the Vice article for doing so.
In case you don't see it, the politics of the situation are obvious. The defense hawks want us to do something about encryption because ISIS is now clearly using VPN, TOR, and other forms of readily-available encryption to communicate with each other.
In particular, the connection of the San Bernadina shooters to ISIS seems to have only been discovered through private communication. (not quite TOR, but they only could have discovered that fact using non-publicly available information if you know what I mean). The Paris Attack was coordinated entirely within encrypted communications.
And the fact of the matter is, the US has absolutely no power against such a space. Clinton wants to appeal to the defense hawks, by claiming she has a solution. But she's also balancing her talk by occasionally saying "Apple" and "I'm against Backdoors".
IE: She's being a politician, and she's ignorantly pretending to believe there's a solution here. The fact remains: any weakening of encryption is tantamount to a backdoor, and doing nothing is unacceptable to the defense hawks. So Clinton's best move is either to play dumb, or actually be dumb.
> You’re going to hear all of the usual complaints, you know, freedom of speech, et cetera. But if we truly are in a war against terrorism and we are truly looking for ways to shut off their funding, shut off the flow of foreign fighters, then we’ve got to shut off their means of communicating. It’s more complicated with some of what they do on encrypted apps, and I’m well aware of that, and that requires even more thinking about how to do it.
This quote (video: https://vimeo.com/148092658), shows a more perturbing side of the issue that goes beyond simply not understanding encryption. She might not understand the technology, but she does understand that freedom of speech and, arguably, one of the other bits of "et cetera" she's referring to would be privacy, shouldn't get in the way of "fighting terrorism".
Not to turn this into a purely political argument, since this is a problem on both sides of the ticket. (Trump has said equally egregious things, but I'm still hopeful that he won't sniff the White House). Just saying, _please_ don't be so naive as to dismiss the political rhetoric as simply technological ignorance.
We don't give freedom of life to foreign fighters (ie: we blow them up and kill them), why should we give them freedom of speech?
Enemies are enemies. And people need to realize what "war" really means. Its not nice, and its messy. We will trample on the rights we hold dear against our enemies. Guantanamo Bay remains open: a location where we secretly take prisoners of war, without a trial, without representation, and detain them for decades.
And its best for us to be informed of war so that we know not to do it unless necessary. But in any case, we remain at war in Iraq and Afghanistan, despite Obama's attempts to get us out of the region. The France Paris attacks are proof of that. They are our enemy. They want to kill us as much as we want to kill them, and neither we (nor them) seem interested in brokering peace.
Until we can enter serious peace talks with the Taliban (in Afghanistan), and with ISIS (in Iraq / Syria), this war will continue. But such talk is heresy in all aspects of politics.
In any case, giving freedom of speech and freedom of expression to ISIS fighters while we shoot missiles at them with remote controlled aircraft, and send special forces units to kill them in their sleep is ignorant bliss. There's a war to fight, and our fighters need every advantage they can get.
I listen to CSPAN every day, and heard Clinton say these words. Read the Washington Post criticism on this issue, which was more balanced.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2015/12/22...
Or even better, listen to Clinton so that you get the story straight from the horse's mouth. To see the game of "telephone" amplifying wtfs throughout the echochaimber bothers me severely. The technology exists to get your news directly from the source.
Why do you need a reporter from Vice to tell you what your opinion should be on something Clinton said? Why don't you just listen to what Clinton said herself, and then make an opinion?
At worst, Clinton simply demonstrated her extreme ignorance on this issue. She has no idea how encryption works, and was just saying words. She knows enough that she doesn't want to "break" encryption however, she's simply calling for computer scientists to think about the issue.