The problem is not one of just saturation but exploitation of cheap labor caused by artificially constraining the demand (in this case, tenured professorships). Would you say that the market for software developers after the first dotcom implosion was merely saturated and all the out of work devs had chosen careers poorly, joining a saturated market? The two phenomena are not dissimilar.
Yes, I sure would.
> all the out of work devs had chosen careers poorly, joining a saturated market?
I would, although obviously only of the devs who had decided on the job after the crash (given how short it was, this applies to very few). Tenured professorship, on the other hand, has been in decline for a long time and clearly not a good financial choice for close to a decade, if not longer.
I wonder if the same thing happened in academia. If you look at the fundamentals a decade ago and continuing even now (consumption rate growing faster than the consumption of medical services, tuition rates rising MUCH faster than inflation), it's reasonable to think that the industry is growing quickly.
Whether or not it ought to be, and whether or not that's sustainable, I can understand a counter argument that even if the field is saturated now, if the industry growth continues as implied by the fundamentals, it could still be a good choice.
Now, if my teenage offspring ask for advice, I'd tell them to pick something that's meaningful and interesting to them and then double-check that they can survive on the value they create. If so, don't go chasing further monetary value.
A lot of folks are in academia because they simply can't admit to themselves that they lost.
See also people employed as an actor/waiter or musician/barista. Living that lifestyle is a personal choice.
Academics can start businesses, but they don't have unique access to business opportunities.
The doctors will still have "insider" investment opportunities -- in my locale, they own the provider groups as shareholders.
I will admit that I favor a government provided health care system, where medical training is free (maybe even for nurses, dental assistants, etc.) and everybody works for the government on a decent professional salary.
Do note that there good numbers of those classified as Adjunct who are former retirees who purposefully work small loads and many in the humanities already knew their course of study had little to no bearing outside of academia which increased competition for what spots there were.
The only issue I have found that is truly actionable for people in this position is having to attend mandatory meetings and such without guarantee of pay which I cannot imagine is remotely legal.
If you are a parent or student and don't like the situation then ask the schools you plan to attend how they are performing in this area. It won't change unless students stop attending schools which rely on it.
Finally the costs of secondary educations are going to come down and this will put even more downward pressure on wages and have colleges and such refrain from tenure track employment. The reason it all came into being is that colleges felt price pressure and had no mean of cutting the tenure levels and worse bloated up non teaching jobs.
[1] http://mattbruenig.com/2013/12/04/what-does-the-national-dat...
Ideally college classes would be taught in small groups, but we have classes taught in groups of hundreds to thousands (particularly at large state universities).
This has certainly let the universities hire fewer faculty members, shove the lower-division courses off on underpaid adjuncts, etc., but somehow this economy of scale hasn't made it down to the tuition level. Tuition and fees continue to increase, while the number of instructor hours per student continues to decline. Why is that? All of the savings (and more) have been eaten by the administration monster.
If there was ever an area ripe for disintermediation higher education is it. As soon as someone figures out a good way around the accreditation roadblock universities as we know them are toast.
Most likely we'll wind up with a two-tiered system, with free or low-cost MOOCs (or MOOC-like things) on the low end, and a return to personalized instruction on the high end.
What we have now is McDonalds education at Michelin guide prices. That can't last.
I do not understand why people expect to be rewarded for making their career choice knowing full well the field is saturated. The ultimate goal is to get tenured which they should consider that the time invested is the payoff just as with any other career. You don't start in the upper half or top, you pay your dues.