Re:Our obsession with elite colleges is making our kids feel...
by omonra on Monday December 21, 2015 @05:00AM
(#10770388)
I think the mismatch theory is catching on because
1) It simply makes intuitive sense 2) There is simply lack of hard data that would disprove it
Ie when you place a group of students whose SAT scores are 250 points below the average, in a competitive environment, they will struggle because there is no AA once inside the university. So this is the default 'makes sense' theory.
If it is actually not true - you have to bring data to bear.
This is off-topic from the original post, but I think the whole mismatch controversy has been kind of a scary illustration of how one determined academic can shape the narrative around an issue: because he's a professor, and because media outlets trust professors (and like controversy), he can easily find a platform to represent the debate in a way that's favorable to his side (e.g. [0]). I don't think it's a crazy hypothesis or anything, and it's definitely worth debating, but I'd be skeptical of claims coming from someone who's staked so much of his career on its validity.
</rant>
[0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/201...