This is off-topic from the original post, but I think the whole mismatch controversy has been kind of a scary illustration of how one determined academic can shape the narrative around an issue: because he's a professor, and because media outlets trust professors (and like controversy), he can easily find a platform to represent the debate in a way that's favorable to his side (e.g. [0]). I don't think it's a crazy hypothesis or anything, and it's definitely worth debating, but I'd be skeptical of claims coming from someone who's staked so much of his career on its validity.
</rant>
[0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/201...
1) It simply makes intuitive sense 2) There is simply lack of hard data that would disprove it
Ie when you place a group of students whose SAT scores are 250 points below the average, in a competitive environment, they will struggle because there is no AA once inside the university. So this is the default 'makes sense' theory.
If it is actually not true - you have to bring data to bear.
One site I found to 'debunk' mismatch theory focuses solely on graduation rate as a measure (ie students graduate more at more selective colleges). But that could be due these students transferring out to easier majors or simply graduating with lower grades (as discussed in the Atlantic article above).