News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by andreyf on Friday December 18, 2015 @11:52PM (#10762679)
Is organizing the violation of copyright laws political speech, or do you mean something else by "political reasons"?
Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by mindslight on Friday December 18, 2015 @11:57PM (#10762692)
I made no mention of "political speech". Preventing people from communicating amongst themselves is a political action.
Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by mbrutsch on Saturday December 19, 2015 @07:47AM (#10763425)
Many of us believe it is, yes.
Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by venomsnake on Saturday December 19, 2015 @01:20AM (#10762841)
Can you explain how giving a checksum of a file is violation of copyright?
Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by cperciva on Saturday December 19, 2015 @05:34AM (#10763217)
Intent matters.

Driving a taxi is legal, and telling people where to find a bank is legal, but if you start advertising a "bank robber target selection and getaway service" then you'll end up being thrown in jail for bank robbery, because you were knowingly assisting in the crime even though your actions taken in isolation were entirely legal.

Similarly, providing someone with a checksum of a file is not copyright infringement in itself, but it becomes illegal when you do it with the intent of assisting copyright infringement.

Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by pbhjpbhj on Saturday December 19, 2015 @08:49AM (#10763541)
To use your analogy TPB are literally only providing a taxi service though, they don't know or care if you're going to the bank and if you're making a deposit, recovering stolen property or robbing it.

In USA format shifting is allowed, downloading a format shifted copy of media is logically equivalent and morally probably slightly superior (less time/energy waste?). Don't know if that line of reasoning had been tested yet? There are countries where it is not a tort to download nor upload what would otherwise be considered copyright material.

In short TPB does nothing in terms of contributory infringement that other indexing sites (Google, Bing, etc) don't do.

There behaviour is the same no matter your intent; do you have a more convincing argument that accounts for common carrier protections and explains why of I get a work using a link from Google it's not infringing but getting one from TPB makes it tortuous?

Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by vinceguidry on Saturday December 19, 2015 @09:20AM (#10763614)
> In short TPB does nothing in terms of contributory infringement that other indexing sites (Google, Bing, etc) don't do.

That is an argument that you are making, not a foregone conclusion. First off, the branding matters when it comes to intent. The name, "The Pirate Bay" leaves it pretty clear what they're expecting you to do with the site.

Also, there's the fact that Google and other search engines are responsive to DMCA requests, TPB is not. Finally, there's the political positions of the organization running the site.

Their service is much closer to cperciva's analogy than it is to a normal search engine.

Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by yason on Saturday December 19, 2015 @11:27AM (#10763963)
Intent is where lawyers and engineers take a whole different paths. It's that "what color are your bits" question.

To a lawyer, the details don't matter much at all as long as there's enough evidence to prove the intent.

To an engineer, only the details do matter because otherwise the world as organised by engineering will become completely chaotic, i.e. why is this number illegal and another number not, and if X holds for this thing then X should hold for all similar things.

One thing that underlines this is that hackers don't see laws as an authority, they actually tend to question laws by default.

As far as I can see, the majority of hacker-type people see no legal/moral issue in copying music and films. Copying is just bits, bits are a convenient format to distribute and store content, and they'll surely buy a certain album or film not because they couldn't somehow get it for free but because it's so good that they want to own it themselves. This is completely in opposition how MAFIAA thinks people behave, and lawyers work for MAFIAA.

So, hackers and engineers are placed in the whole legal game by putting them in the position of the defendant. Instead of MAFIAA having to think why would they be allowed to sue someone for copying their own bits, the hackers are forced to come up with reasons why something of an ordinary activity (in their world) such as copying wouldn't be illegal. That's where the common outcry originates from: the kind of story how I was just driving taxi, took a guy to the bank, he asked to wait outside, and he came back in a hurry to the docklands, so I did as requested and he paid with a hundred dollar bill.

The events are unusual, mechanistic, machines connect and exchange bits, taxis take rides from the bank to the outskirts of the city, because it's mechanisms that engineers work with. Mechanisms can always be used for good or bad similar to science, and it's not the engineers' job to consider one method illegal and another legal, nor the scientists job to consider one field illegal and another legal. For an engineer, rights and wrongs are universal while legal opinions aren't.

Moreover, throw a libertarian mindset in the mix and you've got a hacker both working with these mechanisms and also living by the idea that his activities are innately private, bits can't be owned, and everybody should play by the rules spelled out by the objective truths and laws of physics rather than the arbitrary laws made up by the society made of non-experts.

Then bring in a lawyer telling them that not all file checksums come equal and they'll tell him he's full of bullshit. At the point where the two paths――the engineering path and the lawyer path――meet there is absolutely no conversation left because the paths come from completely different worlds.

Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by belorn on Saturday December 19, 2015 @09:27AM (#10763630)
While the question is interesting from a law theory perspective, the pirate bay was actually never charged for being in violation of copyright. The court decision referenced a rather obscure law which was intended to address organize crime.

The law basically says that if a service is primarily used for illegal purposes, then running that service is illegal under current assisting laws. The intention of the law makers was to give the police the ability to shut down biker bars that was used as headquarters, without the normal procedure of having to find tax crimes or some other excuse to shut it down.

The prosecutor in the pirate bay case provided a screenshot of the top 100 shared file list and said that this proved that the primary usage of the site was copyright infringement. The defense argued that you could not determine this, using the long tail argument. The court went with the prosecutors argument and so did the appeal court.

Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by hellbanner on Saturday December 19, 2015 @09:38AM (#10763661)
What is "the long tail argument"? That the service was provided for legitimate means but most people in the long tail use it for illegal means?
Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by rahimnathwani on Saturday December 19, 2015 @09:49AM (#10763686)
Even if the top 100 moat popular torrents do infringe on copyrights, the many less popular torrents (the long tail) may outnumber them in downloads etc.
Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by belorn on Saturday December 19, 2015 @01:22PM (#10764344)
Yep. If someone for example had access to amazon top 100 sold books, the information one could derive from it would be surprisingly little. You could not determine what genre is most popularly sold, what the profit margins are in the book market, or who the target audience generally are.
Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by rtpg on Saturday December 19, 2015 @01:29AM (#10762852)
Just thought of this, but isn't it conspiracy? Kind of the only way to arrest someone before doing something.
Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by andreyf on Saturday December 19, 2015 @02:13AM (#10762922)
Good question. I don't know. I realize MPAA lawyers don't agree, but a crime like "conspiracy to enable people watch movies for free" seems like it isn't exactly the best thing to spend our limited judicial resources prosecuting, especially since it's been trivial to pirate movies for ages and the industry is still making billions.
Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by mindslight on Saturday December 19, 2015 @02:55AM (#10762995)
Arresting people without them having committed a crime is generally considered a Bad Thing.
Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by rtpg on Saturday December 19, 2015 @06:24AM (#10763295)
Right, which is why planning to commit a crime is now a crime as well (think price fixing). You can stop people before harm is actually done (with harm==results of illegal action)
Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by mindslight on Saturday December 19, 2015 @01:58PM (#10764459)
Redefining "crime" to include "precrime" is generally considered a Bad Thing also. A law being on the books does not mean it is just or wise.
Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by andreyf on Saturday December 19, 2015 @02:01AM (#10762898)
Good question. It might be considered a derivative work, but I think that would be a new interpretation of that phrase. Big-picture answer is that most people who write and interpret laws do not know what SHA-1 is, so current laws might not cover TPB with respect to copyright law. It might also be that technology makes some laws silly or at least much harder to enforce, and copyright laws might be one such example.

IANAL, but here's one argument against TPB: a checksum of a "controlled file" seems to me akin to the code name of a "controlled substance". If a guy tells you that if you want heroin, you should ask around for "wombats", and then you go ask around for "wombats" and buy some heroin, did the dude that told you the code name do something illegal?

Now what if he was just a robot that repeated what he heard, and gathered reviews? "I heard heroin is called wombat, and 100 people are happy with that information". TPB does a little more than that (monitor the number of seeders / leechers, which is integral to prevent fake torrents being submitted), and makes quite a pretty penny off of their services, as well.

Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by cbd1984 on Saturday December 19, 2015 @03:44PM (#10764778)
You can't break the law through a clever loophole. Or, well, you can for a while, but eventually a judge will wake up and see what you're doing and apply the law you're breaking to you, even if you think you're strictly within its boundaries.

If you want to do something that's currently illegal, CHANGE THE LAWS.

Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by cbd1984 on Saturday December 19, 2015 @03:11AM (#10763016)
Because laws are administered by humans, who are not blind to intent.

Laws are not software. They are not run like software. This is one of the reasons why.

Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by cbd1984 on Saturday December 19, 2015 @03:45PM (#10764780)
Downvoting me doesn't change any laws.
Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by venomsnake on Saturday December 19, 2015 @03:14AM (#10763021)
Well the intent is people to share files. Not to commit copyright infringement.
Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by MattRL on Saturday December 19, 2015 @05:08AM (#10763185)
For torrenting generally, for the 'Pirate Bay'?
Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by mindslight on Saturday December 19, 2015 @01:51PM (#10764437)
You're setting up a losing battle by buying into the broken framework. "Sharing" "copyrighted" files is currently illegal throughout the empire, period.

But simultaneously, marijuana incorporation only became a thing because of a dedicated community flouting the law long enough for the disinterested majority to see the ridiculousness of it.