News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by pbhjpbhj on Saturday December 19, 2015 @08:49AM (#10763541)
To use your analogy TPB are literally only providing a taxi service though, they don't know or care if you're going to the bank and if you're making a deposit, recovering stolen property or robbing it.

In USA format shifting is allowed, downloading a format shifted copy of media is logically equivalent and morally probably slightly superior (less time/energy waste?). Don't know if that line of reasoning had been tested yet? There are countries where it is not a tort to download nor upload what would otherwise be considered copyright material.

In short TPB does nothing in terms of contributory infringement that other indexing sites (Google, Bing, etc) don't do.

There behaviour is the same no matter your intent; do you have a more convincing argument that accounts for common carrier protections and explains why of I get a work using a link from Google it's not infringing but getting one from TPB makes it tortuous?

Re:Thepiratebay.com domain has been suspended by vinceguidry on Saturday December 19, 2015 @09:20AM (#10763614)
> In short TPB does nothing in terms of contributory infringement that other indexing sites (Google, Bing, etc) don't do.

That is an argument that you are making, not a foregone conclusion. First off, the branding matters when it comes to intent. The name, "The Pirate Bay" leaves it pretty clear what they're expecting you to do with the site.

Also, there's the fact that Google and other search engines are responsive to DMCA requests, TPB is not. Finally, there's the political positions of the organization running the site.

Their service is much closer to cperciva's analogy than it is to a normal search engine.