Re:Status and Signals: Why Hardcore Gamers Are Afraid Of Eas...
by grhino on Monday January 25, 2010 @05:29PM
(#1076421)
If no one knew or cared about the difficulty in climbing everest at all except those who climbed it, climbing everest would no longer have near the status that it does.
He argues that hardcore gamers don't want an easy mode because it makes completing the game more of a status signal, however, the lack of an easy mode reduces the audience that is even aware of the game.
Completing a hardcore game that nobody knows about doesn't give the gamer any status at all.
He's not making the argument that people who climb everest by riding an pressurized elevator with an oxygen supply should be able to claim they climbed everest, but the fact that there is an elevator shouldn't logically diminish the status conveyed to actual climbers of everest.
TL;DR: The logical extension of the article is that someone who watches a real-time movie of people climbing Everest has a similar experience to those actually climbing Everest, and should be allowed to claim that they too have climbed Everest. In my opinion the author does a disservice to us all by making a convincing argument of this.