I avoid debt like the plague it is but I can see people that are less financially aware fall in to these traps very easily.
All the debt collecting agencies have to do to avoid this particular trap is to comply with the law. All the time.
No need for them to be sued or to sue in the first place.
I sincerely hope he gives them hell, they've given enough people down on their luck hell themselves.
But this guy went out and borrowed $100k to put directly into risky investments. He also bought four houses at zero down, maximizing his risk of default. He wasn't suckered into this, it was a calculated move to try and get rich quick. Then it blew up in his face, and while that is not his fault directly, he's clearly smart enough to have known the risks. Now that his (not so) little bet has gone against him, he doesn't want to pay it back?
I call bullshit.
I'd say the opposite: he was too smart for his own good.
He was an Economics major(like me). He was likely taught economic theory based on rational behavior.
During those years, credit card companies sent absurd numbers of 0% offers to everyone over 18. If he didn't borrow money at 0% and reinvest it, that would have been irrational and gone against everything he was being taught in school.
I'm assuming he had a few things working against him:
- Limited knowledge of the world and no first hand experience of a recession.
- Dangerous knowledge from Economics class that teaches you people act rationally, without emotion, according to a simple utility maximizing function.
- Employees in the financial industry who earned their incentives based purely on the amount of money being borrowed in the short term, with no consequences if the debts turned out to be bad.
- Very limited understand of probability and statistics. I've met very few people in my life who have adequate schooling in these subjects.
I had a similar experience(though luckily on a smaller scale) my senior year of college. I was given a $50,000 line of credit from Bank of America, despite the fact that I'd never held more than a summer job or made more than $8,000 in a single year.
If I had walked into my local bank and asked for that kind of loan, my banker would have laughed in my face. But Bank of America gave it to me just by filling out a form and making a phone call.
The system was absurd and many people were screwed. Banks should have known better. They've been around for hundreds of years while myself and many others have been around for about 20.
The lenders should have been smart enough to have known the risks.
I was also an Econ major. At no time did I become so out of touch with reality as to actually believe that people behave rationally when it comes to economic decisions. Calling that information dangerous is just disingenuous.
The banks failed at risk management, that we know. But there is individual responsibility as well. Every person who got a mortgage with a payment that was more than their take home pay is equally culpable in the subprime crisis. And people like this guy are even more to blame. I know people are bad at probability and statistics, but we shouldn't give them a pass on basic arithmetic.
The banks colluded because they too wanted to make a pile of money quickly, then when it all blew up they went after all the collateral leaving the private individuals holding the debt after the foreclosure.
Mid-bubble, I can't count how many people told me that the market can only go up, or who looked at me like I was insane when I said I was watching month-over-month sales to try to avoid getting creamed when the bubble inevitably burst.
The right incentive is for enough people to do this that the companies find it cheaper to train their phone collectors about what they're legally allowed to do.
Go this guy for pursuing open source litigation. Anyone who reads John Robb will immediately recoginze the scenario of decentralized community vs. bureacracy as 4th generation warfare.
Of course, that works both ways -- debt collection agencies frequently pile on their own fees to the original debt, which for small debts can double the amount the consumer pays back. Most people don't fight these charges because it's too much trouble to do so. This is just giving them a taste of their own medicine.
2) Plenty of people had high credit limits. Then, because some bankers screwed up the economy, were let go of their jobs. At this point they had no incoming cash, and plenty of credit. How do you propose they take care of their necessities if not the credit cards? Not saying this is every case, just proposing that sometimes debt isn't over luxuries.
I'm not sure I disagree -- "Usuary" used to be thoroughly illegal/immoral/etc didn't it?
... and "People are brainwashed to think that paying a credit card is more important than paying for the necessities of life." - Maybe if people spent more time worrying about the necessities of life and less about luxury they wouldn't be in debt in the first place.
I definitely believe credit cards are less important than basic necessities.
If someone needs money to open a business or the like, then the lender is supposed to partner/go into business with him, not just lend at interest.
You can get around the prohibition by structuring the partnership into something that acts like interest, but the intent of that is for business, it's not intended to replace charity loans.
I dont know. The more I read it it sounds like a guy who took a risk and lost big - and now is scrabbling round for "get out of jail free" cards.
With that said; I dont find much sympathy for the individual (his motives dont sync with me) but that's something worth "enduring" if he can actually help to impact the industry. shrug
I really feel like this guy, Craig, who is suing the debt collectors is a hacker for finding the information about possible violations and pursing it legally.
I am also all for punishing debt collectors for actions that abuse debtors.
However, there are several things that rub me the wrong way.
1) The fact that it is easier (less expensive) for a company to settle a case for $1K, rather than fight and win a case while costing themselves $10k gives the companies no incentive to fight back. Also, The plaintiff is already in debt and is having trouble paying, so what would a company get out of counter suing?
2) Statements like - "Katz doesn't believe that people are morally obligated to pay back their debts." and "People are brainwashed to think that paying a credit card is more important than paying for the necessities of life." - Maybe if people spent more time worrying about the necessities of life and less about luxury they wouldn't be in debt in the first place.