But what possible argument can be made that if/when the company DOES mint billionaires and multimillionaires, it should only be the two or three founders and the investors that keep up to 95% of the haul?
Your point would be appropriate if the problem was people not joining companies at all because no one would make money off them. Not the case. A few people will make money and lots of it. It's time now for employees to demand much higher equity.
Now I know better as a software engineer to avoid immature companies like the plague unless they're willing to pay very close to market value. That stock is worth zilch with the way the VC investment game is typically played currently, and founders are fully willing to abuse the naive assumption by those in the trenches that employees will come to riches by working hard and overcoming bad executive/management decisions to save the day.
Founders need to be more honest about employee compensation and more willing to compensate more in line with the market if they want true talent. A $160k-180k offer (or typically less at many cheap startups - a YC company tried to go low with a $120k offer in SF within the past year) with uncertain value of stock doesn't really compare favorably to $250k base + performance bonuses + stock options at a Google or Facebook (or $375k cash/immediately vested stock from Netflix, or in one case I turned down, $170k base + various bonuses for typically $350k-400k compensation). The terms are very unfavorable to employees currently, especially the highly skilled ones, who are also more likely to be savvy.
Cost of living must be completely astronomical, or people have really expensive tastes. That kind of salary would be enough, after taxes, for me to work five years, buy a home, cash on the barrelhead, invest the rest, and retire to live off the dividends the rest of my life.
I ended up taking an offer less than half as much as the top end, but mostly for non-monetary reasons. I came to the conclusion that money wasn't vitally important to me beyond a healthy amount to live comfortably & pay off my debts, and I wanted the flexibility to leave work early, not live in constant pressure to have stories done yesterday, and in general live a more normal life with actual vacation I could take without guilt. It also gave me more freedom to explore software development at my own desire, as there is always more to learn and improve on.
I may start a company in the future, or enter the grind again, but for now I'm happier spending time with friends and enjoying the fruits of my labor. I'm a bit wary of immature startups now though, since many of them are their own brand of mental torture due to large oversights in managing people capital.
I could live like a king on $150k per year. I don't know what I would spend that kind of money on.
5x$4-$15 for commuting during the week 2x$15 per weekend for transportation on the weekend ---- $200 for communting per month
$3000 rent per month $150 cell phone bill per month $150 cable/internet bill per month $50 electric/gas bill per month ---- $3350+ per month in housing/utilities
=
$4750 per month in living expenses...not including entertainment, car/insurance, and a host of other things. If you're young you probably split the housing costs, so it comes down a little, but you're probably spending at least $3k a month just to live and get to work around SF.
> and you'll be doing your start-up coworkers a favor by leaving
So people fighting for what they are worth is detrimental to coworkers now? Maybe you and your coworkers need a reality check if you feel resentment towards one of your coworkers fighting for fair compensation.
Teachers certainly don't do their work for money, but then again if their school has a couple of really good years their school superintendent doesn't walk away with half a billion dollars while the teacher still gets shitty pay and maybe a $500 Christmas bonus.
If you really want to change the world for the better volunteer, do charity work, if you want a big say in direction of a project then work with friends on side projects or contribute to important open source projects.
But working for people who stand to get (even more) wealthy from your well-below-market-rate work while you're unlikely to recoup basic opportunity costs is just being a sucker. There's nothing noble in that.
You argue for the value of passion, but you're also inadvertently siding with people who have done nothing to contribute to the product aside from spreading risk by investing in it.
After the founder who went a year getting paid negative money, the investor putting $1m in their dream and valuing it at $5m-$10m is taking the next highest amount of risk, and I have no problem with the reward they get in exchange.
It sounds like Box dude from the story had a very cool experience building a company from 50 people to 1,000. I'm sorry all he thinks he got out of it are his stock options.
But what are you going to do with that experience you have gained. To go back to the romance option, if you can't get someone else into the bed, romance can become very sour.
I too see that the Box guy got more value than just the earnings on the options. But that more value is largely theoretical unless he can turn around and put what he learned into practice (and get compensated for it).
An interesting example is Kingston, a memory company. In 1996, after the bulk of the company was bought by SoftBank, Kingston's founders gave $100m in bonuses to the 550 employees. It's a shame that doesn't happen more.
And this was as a RN at a hospital with a strong union presence. Hospitals today do everything they can to hire as few RNs as possible, because they draw a higher salary than LPNs and medical assistants. And the better nursing programs out there are extremely expensive, resulting in the same kind of debt load that other professional careers have started having recently.
The same ought to be true of start-ups. Sure, you can make more expected money working at Facebook redesigning their like button, or whatever. But, at a start-up, you can have a huge hand in building something much bigger than yourself from scratch. You get to be a jack-of-all-trades, learning a bit of everything, making something hundreds of thousands of people will use go 0 to 1. You get to be incredibly important to the company and have a say in just about every decision if you want it. That role is still romantic to me, and that's why I've worked and continue to work at start-ups. I know I can make more money somewhere else. I don't care. And I want to work with other people who don't care either. If your motivation is just money, there are plenty of big faceless companies doing fun stuff like ad-tech that will be happy to pay you, and you'll be doing your start-up coworkers a favor by leaving.