News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the Universal Symbols for Escalators, Restrooms, and ... by WalterBright on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @01:28PM (#10746150)
The icon thing has bugged me since its appearance on the Mac:

1. Companies tend to copyright them, rendering a universal set impossible. At least these universal symbols are not copyrighted.

2. If you don't know what they mean, there's no way to find out.

Take the universal symbols (though not in that list) for on and off: | and O. I still cannot remember which is on and which is off. I can't find out, either, without googling for it. With the words "on" and "off", I know what they mean.

And more importantly, if I do not know English, I can trivially look up "on" and "off". Why is "|" as a symbol better than "on" as a symbol?

Why is "Helvetica Man" inherently better than "men" and "toilet"? Knowing English is not necessary to recognize the words "men" and "toilet" with just as much facility as having enough savvy to remember that a silhouette of a man means "mens toilet".

Back in 1985, an Apple salesman showed up at our company to sell us on Macs. Part of his spiel was passing around a sheet of paper with icons on them and asking us what the icons meant. None of us had used a gui before, and he was bitterly annoyed that we guessed wrong on nearly all of them. The one I remember most we decided represented a box of Kleenex. (That one was the 'print' icon.) The air went out of his presentation after that.

The idea there was that there was something wrong with using English words, like "print". A phonetic language really is a great advance. Words can be looked up in a dictionary. Where are icons looked up (especially if they are different on every system due to copyrights)?

Is learning a dozen standardized English words really harder for someone who knows no English than learning a dozen icons?

When I use a gui app, I still have to hover over the icon that somebody got a design award for (sarcasm!) hoping that the coder saw fit to add a tooltip so I know what it does.

Re:How the Universal Symbols for Escalators, Restrooms, and ... by datenwolf on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @01:51PM (#10746326)
> And more importantly, if I do not know English, I can trivially look up "on" and "off". Why is "|" as a symbol better than "on" as a symbol? > > Why is "Helvetica Man" inherently better than "men" and "toilet"? Knowing English is not necessary to recognize the words "men" and "toilet" with just as much facility as having enough savvy to remember that a silhouette of a man means "mens toilet".

For one simple reason: If you know them, they're far quicker to read. Take road traffic for example. Everytime I visit America I notice how much more efficient clean, distinct symbols are: Practically everything is conveyed by written out words "Speed Limit", "No Parking", "No right turn on red", "No U-Turns" and so on. Such signs require, that I read and parse them. In fact, if one understands English it's probably taking longer to recognize a sign, because several functional units in your brain try to take precedence on the interpretation.

In Europe we have very distinct symbols for each and every traffic regulation. The effect of this is that you can read them very quickly (it happens almost unconciously) and more importantly it even works if you glimpse them only in the periphery of your vision.

Re:How the Universal Symbols for Escalators, Restrooms, and ... by WalterBright on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @02:08PM (#10746442)
I agree that once you know the European traffic symbols, they require less cognitive effort.

Once you know what they are. You might think they are all obvious, having grown up with them. But they aren't. I went to Germany when I was 9, and they most assuredly are not intuitively obvious.

Ironically, I was told that the European traffic symbols came about because the Europeans could not agree on which language to use. The only exception was they adopted the U.S. "STOP" sign.

Re:How the Universal Symbols for Escalators, Restrooms, and ... by chias on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @05:38PM (#10747912)
They aren't intuitive to those of us who grew up with them either, nor are they meant to be. You learn them, though, if you want a license.

It's not easy and is super frustrating and arbitrary when you're first going through them in preparation for your test. But if you want a license, you do it. And then you know them.

Re:How the Universal Symbols for Escalators, Restrooms, and ... by chiph on Thursday December 17, 2015 @11:47AM (#10752532)
Probably the most famous sign for Autobahn fans is the "End of restrictions" sign:

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/0/03/Ze...

It's abstract in the extreme. You have to know what it means via a prior learning process, as there's no relationship with an everyday activity. For my US driver's license I had to learn maybe 50 signs, and they were easy to categorize based on shape and color (white rectangles are a restriction such as speed limits). For my European driver's test (for USAFE) it was over 200 different signs, and each had to be learned individually as they seldom had commonalities.

The "Autobahn begins" sign is fairly intuitive, though:

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/2/27/Ro...

Re:How the Universal Symbols for Escalators, Restrooms, and ... by x1798DE on Thursday December 17, 2015 @12:41AM (#10749799)
I'm not sure that anyone actually reads the "flavor text" on most standard signs in the US, you mostly go by shape or whatever once you know the shapes, so I doubt there's any real cognitive overhead associated with reading the signs. (By contrast, the lack of even units on European speed limit signs always makes me think they are route markers...)
Re:How the Universal Symbols for Escalators, Restrooms, and ... by thaumasiotes on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @01:39PM (#10746229)
> A phonetic [spelling system] really is a great advance. Words can be looked up in a dictionary. Where are icons looked up (especially if they are different on every system due to copyrights)?

Require that most icons include a recognizable component for indexing purposes, and assign an arbitrary ordering to those components. In fact, that's what we do with letters too -- it's just that the number of letters is small.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kangxi_radical#Table_of_radica...

To be fair, the chinese writing system is also phonetic. The problem isn't that phonetics aren't represented; they are. The problem is that a lot of additional information is also represented.

Re:How the Universal Symbols for Escalators, Restrooms, and ... by WalterBright on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @01:48PM (#10746303)
> it's just that the number of letters is small

And that makes all the difference. If there were 214, would you remember the order? Me neither. I don't remember the ASCII order, either, and keep a chart handy. That's only 128, and I use it often.

Re:How the Universal Symbols for Escalators, Restrooms, and ... by thaumasiotes on Thursday December 17, 2015 @01:43AM (#10749995)
It makes a huge difference. Chinese dictionaries today are invariably listed in pinyin order (or zhuyin, I guess, in Taiwan) because that is a vastly superior system. But the difference between a sequence of 4000 items and a sequence of 25 items isn't the same thing as the difference between a mostly-phonemic spelling system and some other arbitrary spelling system. If Latin had been written with unrelated abstract symbols representing the case endings, that wouldn't have posed a huge problem because there aren't very many of those (depending how you want to count, somewhere from 6 to 60).

> If there were 214, would you remember the order?

I might; remembering a fixed sequence of 214 things is certainly well within human capability. But if I did it would be as a point of pride rather than because that's something I think is reasonable to expect of everyone.

Re:How the Universal Symbols for Escalators, Restrooms, and ... by CapitalistCartr on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @01:31PM (#10746176)
The universal symbols for on and off aren't the letters "i and o", they're one and zero.
Re:How the Universal Symbols for Escalators, Restrooms, and ... by WalterBright on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @01:41PM (#10746240)
I typed the vertical bar |, not the letter I.

But this just goes to my point. I am a college educated man, and have worked in tech for 40 years. Yet I did not know those symbols were supposed to be "1" and "0" until I was told. (None that I've seen looked like "1", which I would have recognized as "one", they all looked like "|".)

Even getting past that, how would someone who is illiterate implicitly know that "1" and "0" represent an electrical engineer's view of digital circuitry?

I don't grok the thought process behind these symbols. Either that, or I'm a retard. (The Apple salesman had no explanation, either, as to why icons were better. He just thought it was trivially obvious, and was baffled that we didn't immediately "get it".)

Re:How the Universal Symbols for Escalators, Restrooms, and ... by jonsen on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @04:40PM (#10747561)
It really is pretty obvious, "O" represents a closed circuit, and "|" represents an open circuit, oh wait ...
Re:How the Universal Symbols for Escalators, Restrooms, and ... by ableal on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @04:01PM (#10747302)
> someone who is illiterate implicitly know that "1" and "0" represent

People are usually OK with small numbers. So:

1 - there is a thing.

0 - there isn't a thing.

(I know that you went with 'O' and '.' for "city" and "no-city",[and it worked nicely, thank you,] but come on ... ;-)

Re:How the Universal Symbols for Escalators, Restrooms, and ... by WalterBright on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @05:33PM (#10747888)
'C' was already taken :-)
Re:How the Universal Symbols for Escalators, Restrooms, and ... by thaumasiotes on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @01:43PM (#10746257)
So presumably there'd be no problem with using 壹 and 零 instead?
Re:How the Universal Symbols for Escalators, Restrooms, and ... by rdancer on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @01:56PM (#10746361)
How about "إيقاف/تر"?
Re:How the Universal Symbols for Escalators, Restrooms, and ... by azhenley on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @03:01PM (#10746868)
I think something can be said about the simplicity of symbols (e.g., the number of lines/curves)
Re:How the Universal Symbols for Escalators, Restrooms, and ... by ptaipale on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @04:58PM (#10747670)
Particularly when the simple symbols are so-called Hindu-Arabic i.e. European digits, which are very universal (even though Chinese and Eastern Arabic also do have own glyphs for numbers, the Hindu-Arabic numbers are ubiquitous.)
Re:How the Universal Symbols for Escalators, Restrooms, and ... by whoopdedo on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @03:59PM (#10747275)
>The air went out of his presentation after that.

The myth of the intuitive interface[1] continues to plague software design. Currently it takes the form of heatmaps which only tell you what people are familiar with and not what is actually useful. A UI should not be measured by whether it can be learned easily. Good interfaces improve efficiency when used by people who are sufficiently knowledgeable in how to use them. Using a mouse is quicker than typing alone.[2] The perception that mice are slower is because you often see less adept people using them in a hunt-and-click manner.

[1]http://www.greenend.org.uk/rjk/misc/nipple.html [2]http://plan9.bell-labs.com/wiki/plan9/Mouse_vs._Keyboard/ind...

Re:How the Universal Symbols for Escalators, Restrooms, and ... by WalterBright on Saturday December 19, 2015 @01:40AM (#10762872)