News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Which of the new breed of JVM languages has the most pote... by jbellis on Sunday January 24, 2010 @10:52PM (#1074338)
Scala is too complicated.

Clojure is too slow.

I'm guessing clojure has a better chance of getting faster than scala has of getting simpler, so I voted for clojure.

Re:Which of the new breed of JVM languages has the most pote... by TrevorBurnham on Monday January 25, 2010 @11:12AM (#1075354)
You're right that Scala is very complicated, insofar as there are a huge number of features and a lot of code is unreadable if you don't know them. It's a stark contrast to the "runnable pseudocode" of Python. But I think there's a tradeoff between language complexity and project complexity.

The wide feature set of Scala wasn't just assembled at random; it's there because there are use cases in which each of those features makes a task really simple. If you've got a team of smart programmers, then overcoming the language barrier will take a lot less effort in the long run than producing and maintaining tons of bloated code in a less complicated language.

Re:Which of the new breed of JVM languages has the most pote... by ynniv on Monday January 25, 2010 @12:44AM (#1074525)
Same here. I've never seen a language get cleaner, but hot damn did JavaScript get about 30 times faster over the last couple of years.

PS: Has anyone seen a language get cleaner / simpler?

Re:Which of the new breed of JVM languages has the most pote... by cema on Monday January 25, 2010 @03:55AM (#1074731)
Not an artificial language, I do not think so (backward compatibility etc). A language could breed a simpler/cleaner language, that happens, but it is a different language.

Natural languages are a different story. English has arguably become substantially simpler over centuries (hardly cleaner, however).