News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Building solar farms above the clouds by sevensor on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @03:44PM (#10740335)
How are these things supposed to stay aloft? They need to lift:

1) Themselves

2) The solar panels

3) Fuel cells

4) 20km of tether and cable

The idea seems really neat, but I'm an engineer and I want to see the math.

Edit: And how about that tether? What's the wind load going to be like? How is it moored? What is it made of?

Re:Building solar farms above the clouds by undersuit on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @03:54PM (#10740402)
They are energy collectors, I would assume you use some of that energy to heat the air in their balloons.

I'm more interested in how you optimally position the solar cells, would a sphere really be the best or would a pontoon dragging in the wind give a better chance for the solar panels to receive optimal light? You probably don't want that 20km tether to be twisted too many times either.

Re:Building solar farms above the clouds by sevensor on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @04:16PM (#10740534)
Interesting point about placement --- seems like a dense array of these would be at risk of getting tangled. And then there's the risk of the tether / cabling becoming a conduit for electrostatic discharge. Of all the engineering issues here, I think tethering is the most problematic.
Re:Building solar farms above the clouds by notahacker on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @05:00PM (#10740806)
I can't imagine many people wanting to live near 20km electrically charged cables, never mind pilots flying between them in a high wind.

Having to build a long way from urban areas rather reduces the advantages of such a system over solar farms in the desert.

Re:Building solar farms above the clouds by Jedd on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @05:26PM (#10740940)
> I can't imagine many people wanting to live near 20km electrically charged cables, never mind pilots flying between them in a high wind.

Not being able to imagine something, and other people not being able to do it, are not functionally equivalent.

Lots of people live within 20km of much more dangerous structures already. But there are plenty of places that people live > 20km away from because they're considered a high risk. So, take your pick on that one.

Pilots already have experience at not flying in certain places - environmental reserves, war zones, hurricanes, mountains, etc - they're pretty good at reading maps.

> Having to build a long way from urban areas rather reduces the advantages of such a system over solar farms in the desert.

I'd suggest you refer to the article again for the proposed benefits of having these things above cloud level, rather than on the ground.

Currently (npi) most power generation occurs much more than 20km from the primary urban areas that they provide power to.

Re:Building solar farms above the clouds by kijin on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @07:27PM (#10741527)
Put some propellers on the balloons, and a computer to control them.

If we can get drones to avoid trees while flying through a forest at high speed, we can make balloons maintain a safe distance from one another at an altitude way above most storms.

Re:Building solar farms above the clouds by kaybe on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @08:14PM (#10741718)
An idea is to use rotating cylinders as balloons which generate lift (Magnus effect). It helps a little.
Re:Building solar farms above the clouds by djKianoosh on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @04:48PM (#10740727)
why tether? why not let the balloon charge a battery, and have drones carry the battery back to earth when full, and vice versa...
Re:Building solar farms above the clouds by Jedd on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @05:28PM (#10740955)
Good question. The winds up there are really strong.

Tethering also lets you wind the appliance back to the ground even when (especially when) it's faulty.

Tethering also lets you obtain power throughout the 12+ hours of power generation per day.

Re:Building solar farms above the clouds by djKianoosh on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @05:45PM (#10741058)
Maybe the balloons could be autonomous as well, rising/falling depending on conditions, and also falling to an acceptable elevation for the drones to reach them efficiently :)
Re:Building solar farms above the clouds by shkkmo on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @08:53PM (#10741853)
Batteries are heavy, lifting them with aircraft is significantly inefficient.