News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who's Profiting from $1.2T of Federal Student Loans? by padobson on Sunday December 13, 2015 @11:52AM (#10726857)
Take notes. There'll be money to be made shorting some of these public companies when the student loan bubble bursts and/or everyone starts to realize a university education isn't the only path to prosperity.
Re:Who's Profiting from $1.2T of Federal Student Loans? by steveplace on Sunday December 13, 2015 @01:34PM (#10727263)
You are lae to the party. APOL Has gone from 90 to 7; ESI from 100 to 3; COCO is bankrupt; SLM never recovered after the 2008 crash.
Re:Who's Profiting from $1.2T of Federal Student Loans? by ap22213 on Sunday December 13, 2015 @01:38PM (#10727282)
I know a few people that can't afford college but who are relatively well motivated and have at least average intelligence. What path should they take? (They're currently making minimum wage, part-time, and I haven't been able to figure out what advice to give them.)
Re:Who's Profiting from $1.2T of Federal Student Loans? by krapht on Sunday December 13, 2015 @01:50PM (#10727348)
Work full-time and take 1-2 classes on nights and weekends at your local community college.
Re:Who's Profiting from $1.2T of Federal Student Loans? by ap22213 on Sunday December 13, 2015 @02:05PM (#10727401)
They'd love full-time; it's just not offered.

One is taking classes at the community college, but the classes are apparently very poor quality and still around $3500 a semester (her annual income is ~$9000 / year). I told her to take Computer Science classes, but is that even good advice, anymore?

Re:Who's Profiting from $1.2T of Federal Student Loans? by srtjstjsj on Sunday December 13, 2015 @04:05PM (#10727938)
The challenge with community college is that you really need to push ahead of the average student, skip intro classes to accelerate yourself, etc. community college, due to the population that attends, has two sets of courses: (1) specific courses that feed into specific jobs, like dental hygenish, and (2) remedial gen ed space-filling courses to round out the degree.

If you are looking for the equivalent of reputable liberal-arts degree (the closest you can get to a "liberal sciences" or engineering degree), you need to find the most advanced gen ed classes and skip over the remedial/basics... and then after 2-3 years transfer to another college for your BA/BS; hopefully with an academic scholarship backed by your poverty and stellar grades so far.

Re:Who's Profiting from $1.2T of Federal Student Loans? by paulpauper on Sunday December 13, 2015 @12:04PM (#10726902)
I have read this is not possible, because most of the loans are guaranteed by the federal government. For-profit colleges could make good shorts, but those stocks have already been hammered a lot.
Re:Who's Profiting from $1.2T of Federal Student Loans? by padobson on Sunday December 13, 2015 @12:24PM (#10726981)
This may be the big problem.

That said, it's possible we end up with a timing problem. What happens if Medicare, Social Security, and the Department of Education all become insolvent at the same time?

The political pressure will almost certainly leave the DOE out in the cold, meaning those loans might not be guaranteed.

Re:Who's Profiting from $1.2T of Federal Student Loans? by themartorana on Sunday December 13, 2015 @01:21PM (#10727203)
They can't be discharged in personal bankruptcy either - perhaps the most one-sided, offensive, corporate-written, f*^%#d up law I've ever seen passed.
Re:Who's Profiting from $1.2T of Federal Student Loans? by HiLo on Sunday December 13, 2015 @12:03PM (#10726898)
Can you provide evidence that it is a bubble? Can you provide evidence that it will burst, or a potential catalyst?
Re:Who's Profiting from $1.2T of Federal Student Loans? by padobson on Sunday December 13, 2015 @12:20PM (#10726966)
I thought the article did a good job:

Sofia is one of 7 million former students in default on a record $115 billion of federal loans

Education Management settled with the government in November for almost $100 million over alleged illegal student-recruitment practices without admitting wrongdoing.

Predatory lending. Sound familiar?

FMS Investment Corp., a unit of Ceannate Corp. that tried to collect from Sofia, was paid $227 million by the Education Department from October 2011 through September of this year, the most of any debt-collection company under contract in that period, according to the agency.

The biggest debt collector works for the Department of Education.

The government has disbursed about $100 billion in education loans annually since the 2009-2010 school year, according to data compiled by the College Board. Just six years before that, the amount was almost half. The total has doubled since 2007 and is expected to double again in the next decade, as students and their parents borrow for college and graduate school.

Despite the fact that defaults are on the rise, predatory lending is on the rise, lots of students who are unable to complete an education are taking out loans[1], AND a lot of people getting their degree aren't sure it's worth it[2], despite all of this, lending is going to double again.

Bubbles aren't always clear, but this one is as clear as it gets.

The only question is, who is the government going to bail out when the bubble bursts?

[1]http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/half-of-people-who-went-... [2]http://www.gallup.com/opinion/gallup/185942/gallup-purdue-in...

Re:Who's Profiting from $1.2T of Federal Student Loans? by HiLo on Sunday December 13, 2015 @12:35PM (#10727023)
No, you haven't really shown me how it's predatory, although I do know that does happen (as it does in all large lending markets).

I'm not sure what your point is about the largest debt collector having contracts with the DOE. Of course they do, that's almost a definitional thing. Pretty much the largest of anything has some kind of government contract.

Defaults are on the rise from a low base, and the securitized portfolios of these loans haven't really taken much of a hit, so it doesn't "sound familiar" because I don't see the same balance sheet risk as 2008 subprime, even though there are undoubtedly subprime elements to this. (For the sake of clarity, I'm referring to the subprime credit ratings and category, not the 2008 era).

I guess what I'm asking is, from what base is all this happening? Predatory lending is on the rise... from .5% of loans to 1%? 1% to 5%? 5% to 10%? Same with the others.

I guess what I'm trying to get out of this thread, is:

1. What novel insight is being presented here that invalidates huge amounts of sophisticated due diligence by incentivized, professional firms?

2. If none, what channel or mechanism is perpetuating something that everybody knows is a bad deal?

3. If everybody knows it's a bad deal, but there is something simply keeping it prodding along, this would not pass even the first level of risk management at these institutions, which really stresses the idea of #2.

Re:Who's Profiting from $1.2T of Federal Student Loans? by padobson on Sunday December 13, 2015 @12:48PM (#10727069)
2. If none, what channel or mechanism is perpetuating something that everybody knows is a bad deal?

This. As I said in another reply to my OP, the government is backing these loans, which makes everyone think they're golden - and that might be true. Perhaps the government will allow the bubble to inflate forever, but the government stepped in in 2008, and there were still plenty of short opportunities available.

But it's unquestionably a bubble if hundreds of billions of dollars (and rising) of loans are being made to people to buy something that A) has no collateral (making it worse than the subprime crisis) and B) the value of the service they're purchasing is, by all perceptions, dropping over time.

Re:Who's Profiting from $1.2T of Federal Student Loans? by branchless on Sunday December 13, 2015 @02:21PM (#10727492)
The whole thing is predatory. It's the classic monopoly system where you loose out if you play and if you don't. Think degrees are overpriced? Go live life as a labourer with no access to the top paying jobs. Or suck it up and hand over a large part of your labour to the gate-keeper.

Available credit sets the price. Ramp it up and watch the tribute flow in.

Re:Who's Profiting from $1.2T of Federal Student Loans? by randomname2 on Sunday December 13, 2015 @01:00PM (#10727118)
Seven million people haven't made a single student loan payment in at least a year [1] and the overall delinquency rate of loans in repayment is about 30% [2].

With the figure of student loans held by the Federal government going up exponentially as of 2008 [3] (and with tuitions soaring by 6% a year) the chart certainly looks "bubbly".

Investor Bill Ackman believes there will likely be some form of forgiveness as there is "no way students are going to pay it back":

When asked if he was concerned about bubbles forming in debt markets as central banks around the world continue to keep interest rates near zero, Ackman cited student loans as his biggest concern.

“If you think about the trillion dollars of student loans we have outstanding, there’s no way students are going to pay it back,” Ackman said. He foresees a future where debt-laden students protest government officials, leading to some form of forgiveness. [4]

[1] http://www.wsj.com/articles/about-7-million-americans-havent...

[2] https://www.stlouisfed.org/on-the-economy/2015/april/delinqu...

[3] http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2015-04-17/washington-...

[4] http://www.forbes.com/sites/antoinegara/2015/04/13/bill-ackm...

Re:Who's Profiting from $1.2T of Federal Student Loans? by cryoshon on Sunday December 13, 2015 @02:14PM (#10727456)
TBH we're well past the point where people should be in the streets protesting student loan payments. The entire economy is experiencing a lack of demand, partially as a result of young people being impoverished from a sycophantic education system.

A repayment boycott would ruin a lot of credit scores, but bring the problem into focus... consider that a huge proportion of people are already in default.

Re:Who's Profiting from $1.2T of Federal Student Loans? by branchless on Sunday December 13, 2015 @02:19PM (#10727483)
So what? It costs them nothing to create the money and if you don't pay it back they still get the economic boost.

Yes it's a sham, yes there is a huge opportunity cost but that's because our current system is mad.

Re:Who's Profiting from $1.2T of Federal Student Loans? by mbesto on Sunday December 13, 2015 @01:33PM (#10727257)
This is already happening for the for-profit education companies:

https://www.google.com/finance?q=NASDAQ%3AAPOL&fstype=ii&ei=... (lost half of it's revenues in just 2 years)

https://www.google.com/finance?q=NYSE%3ADV&fstype=ii&ei=9Llt... (stagnate, revenues declining)

Re:Who's Profiting from $1.2T of Federal Student Loans? by codingbeer on Sunday December 13, 2015 @12:05PM (#10726906)
If one could do that, it wouldn't be a bubble.
Re:Who's Profiting from $1.2T of Federal Student Loans? by HiLo on Sunday December 13, 2015 @12:09PM (#10726922)
More intellectual laziness in this thread. To start, what definition of bubble are you using? Where no plausible scenario can justify forward valuations? Where there is evidence people are doing transactions for the sole reason to flip the assets at a higher price?

Because even if you don't think it's "likely," I can think of plenty of cases where student loan data makes "sense" or is "logical," and you've provided no evidence (of which there is usually at least online anecdotal evidence, see: Dotcom Crash, Bitcoin) that people are making these loans solely to flip them. If you try to argue that the Loan-to-Originate model leads to this behavior, you may have to reconcile a lot of things in this paper: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2700179

Re:Who's Profiting from $1.2T of Federal Student Loans? by SCAQTony on Sunday December 13, 2015 @12:55PM (#10727101)
I am not debating this rather this is merely a contribution regarding tuition, room & board fees, from 1975-76 to 2014-15 adjusted for inflation: I averaged the cost out to 12.5% a year on average.

http://trends.collegeboard.org/college-pricing/figures-table...