Re:Facebook Snatches User’s Vanity URL And Sells It To Harma...
by Tichy on Saturday January 23, 2010 @10:10AM
(#1071895)
Don't know about the avtr case, but they also were offering junk to Mr Harman. So clearly they think somebody giving up their name is nothing.
Re:Facebook Snatches User’s Vanity URL And Sells It To Harma...
by philh on Saturday January 23, 2010 @03:02PM
(#1072317)
If that's giving up his name, then all the other Harmans on facebook had their name stolen by this particular Harman.
A more accurate statement would be "clearly they think somebody not using one particular variant of their name as a facebook vanity URL is not a big deal". I would tend to agree.
Re:Facebook Snatches User’s Vanity URL And Sells It To Harma...
by Tichy on Sunday January 24, 2010 @08:33AM
(#1073276)
The other Harmans didn't have their name stolen - they were simply too late.
If somebody not using a particular vanity URL is not a big deal, then why does Harman Inc need the URL anyway? Why don't they just go for /harmanInc or something like that?
I am also not saying that it is that much of a big deal - not like they are supposed to odder millions. But to just offer worthless junk is offensive.
Also I think "he needs it more than you, so it should belong to him" is not a good basis for conducting business.
Further, /avtr is probably not much better than /avatar, /avatarfilm, or a number of others. When the demand is for precisely one unit, and more than one unit of supply exists, it seems natural that the price is going to be low.