I can't imagine Harman Int paid facebook so much money to be noticable when it's added to their pile.
We (many of us) just assume that a corporation has a right, stronger than an individual, to a name in a medium.
If I were human Harman I would have responded to corporate Harman that, thank you very much but facebook has already stolen my name on your behalf, and cc'd the LA Times in the response.
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-684415688278839051&...
Documentary is standard movie length, but highly recommended. The readable bytes, if no time to watch:
http://www.usatoday.com/money/books/reviews/2004-03-28-corp_...
> Ok, why the poison? Maybe the owner simply wanted to do something cool.
So doing something cool means intruding on other people's rights? The threshold must be getting really low these days.
Really, people should start paying attention to the online world, and what does "property" mean in such a context.
And if your online presence on a social network is so fragile (since, after all, Facebook is a business and the users don't really have lots of implicit rights) ... than there should be national campaigns against it (after all, your online profile being mismanaged could cause some people more harm than smoking, so why the discrimination?) ... not to mention that people think of Facebook as a "common carrier" which couldn't be further from the truth.
Isn't it easier to just play nice and stop acting like a douche bag?
> It's an URL, not a wife.
It isn't just any URL, it's the link to your online profile. Your friends might have you bookmarked, Google might have you indexed by that URL.
It's like saying domain names like "sex.com" aren't worth anything. Well they do.
I think we have a misunderstanding here. First thing to clarify, I think, is whether the owner of the "avtr" name gave it up willingly. If he didn't, the discussion it closed: it was at best bullyish. But what I understood from the article is that it was mutual:
> ... but I wanted to explore opportunities to work with you to acquire the name. In the past, we have offered product in exchange for social domain names. One case in mind was for the new movie Avatar , we were able to give promotional items to the owner of twitter.com/avtr for Coke Zero.
I read this as a transaction. Now, the GP is still very very upset. Personally, I think it simply isn't GP's business what the avtr owner did with his domain. It's very much like Richard Stallman berating you rudely in public for buying commercial software. His ideals, just like GP's, should not dictate what one does with his property, time and money. If the GP thinks offering "useless plastic crap" was an offence, he's free to reject such an offer whenever it's made to him. But I do not understand why we should all align to his standards and refuse transactions we may find profitable or charitable or just the right thing to do. Not to mention that a promotional item can easily be anything from a t-shirt to a bike or a car.
Now again, if I misunderstood something I apologize. But I find the GP to be the one trying to push things here, not the big corporation.
Further, /avtr is probably not much better than /avatar, /avatarfilm, or a number of others. When the demand is for precisely one unit, and more than one unit of supply exists, it seems natural that the price is going to be low.
A more accurate statement would be "clearly they think somebody not using one particular variant of their name as a facebook vanity URL is not a big deal". I would tend to agree.
If somebody not using a particular vanity URL is not a big deal, then why does Harman Inc need the URL anyway? Why don't they just go for /harmanInc or something like that?
I am also not saying that it is that much of a big deal - not like they are supposed to odder millions. But to just offer worthless junk is offensive.
Also I think "he needs it more than you, so it should belong to him" is not a good basis for conducting business.
I know lots of people drink it every day - I admit "poisonous" puts it a bit provocatively.
Edit: just looked it on on Wikipedia, this seems to be the cited article: http://informahealthcare.com/doi/abs/10.1080/104084407015161... - That talks only about cancer and the nervous system, but not about obesity (for instance).
The nerve of some people. OK, maybe "avtr" is not all that great, but to think that they'll give you some useless plastic crap (or poisonous coke) and then proceed to make their millions. It just shows how the big corps think about the "normal" people - they are just sheep, or "consumers" as they are called these days.