News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Happens When You Ban Affirmative Action in College A... by dghf on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @03:58PM (#10706701)
> The article claims minority (presumably non-Asian) enrollment drops 23% when AA is banned. The converse of this is that 23% of non-Asian minorities are only there due to affirmative action, and would not be there under a meritocratic system.

That assumes that without AA the system would be meritocratic, and not biased in favour of people from particular backgrounds.

Re:What Happens When You Ban Affirmative Action in College A... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @04:05PM (#10706744)
Yes, that's because building systems like this is pretty easy. Just use a point system based entirely on grades/extracurriculars/SAT/etc.

For example, google the old U-Mich point system - it was entirely meritocratic except for the +1.0 boost to GPA given to non-Asian minorities, a much smaller alumni preference and some "women in engineering" boost.

Re:What Happens When You Ban Affirmative Action in College A... by tomp on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @06:30PM (#10707666)
The problem is that colleges don't rely only on SAT/grades (at least the elite colleges). Extracurriculars are, obviously, very non-meritocratic - doing extracurricular activities is not really correlated with how good you are at them (or at anything else), but rather with how much time you have and how much your parents can afford to pay for your activities.
Re:What Happens When You Ban Affirmative Action in College A... by taco_emoji on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @04:20PM (#10706834)
Is that what meritocracy looks like to you? Kids whose circumstances are highly negatively correlated with grades and test scores get shafted?
Re:What Happens When You Ban Affirmative Action in College A... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @04:26PM (#10706870)
Yes, "meritocracy" and "no one has a hard life" are different concepts. A person having bad parents and therefore having bad grades has less merit than a person with good parents and good grades.

It sucks that some people have bad parents (or whatever the specific issue is), but that's a different problem than lack of meritocracy.

Re:What Happens When You Ban Affirmative Action in College A... by dghf on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @04:42PM (#10706975)
Well, that kind of depends on how you define merit. One could argue that someone who gets reasonable but not stellar grades in spite of bad parents, a deprived background, etc. displays more merit than someone from a privileged background with every advantage who attains perfect grades.
Re:What Happens When You Ban Affirmative Action in College A... by SamReidHughes on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:55AM (#10709441)
If you have that information, you can factor that into your admissions criteria using feedback from previous students. For example, you could rank incoming students and tweak a racial parameter to equalize the 6-year graduation rate of the bottom decile in each race. Doing so will (by construction) improve the outcome of your 6-year graduation rate. Pick whatever is a good proxy for whatever your goals are.

That's more meritocratic than ignoring that information.

There is a different sense of meritocracy though, in which the goals themselves are unmeritocratic. For example, "educating lots of left-handed people" (to the exclusion of right-handers) is a rather unmeritocratic goal. The real argument being had is in this respect -- for one, whether educating should be done for students' benefit or for the sum of others' benefit. And also, in the subcategory of "for others' benefit," whether making maximally good scientists, historians, and the like, should be the goal, or whether and to what extent there's benefit in trying to infiltrate minority communities with a more education-valuing culture.

Re:What Happens When You Ban Affirmative Action in College A... by anigbrowl on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @05:28PM (#10707235)
A person having bad parents and therefore having bad grades has less merit than a person with good parents and good grades.

So your basic position is that lucky people are better than unlucky people (since nobody gets to select their parents) so that social outcomes are largely a matter of predestination.

Well, at least this saves me the bother of even temporarily taking you seriously in any topic in the future. No doubt this will mean missing out on some correct insights, but I figure that on any important topic I'll hear about it from someone else sooner or later, meanwhile saving myself the effort of seeking good-faith interpretations of what turns out to be self-serving bullshit from your end.

[dead]
Re:What Happens When You Ban Affirmative Action in College A... by anigbrowl on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @06:47PM (#10707776)
Perhaps in future technology will advance tot he point that we can give you an empathy transplant, and you'll realize how glaringly obvious your rhetorical fallacies are to others. Most people would agree that 'merit' is not a scalar quality best measured by mathematical ability, notwithstanding your enjoyable position at the extreme right of that distribution.

Even in quantitative endeavors, we do not magically have access to inherently reliable objective measures. The example I use to remind myself of this is a childhood friend whom I consistently outscored over a period of several years in language, math and other subjects - but who could consistently beat me in a wide variety of pure-strategy board games. Unfortunately the standardized testing regime we grew up with was no good at measuring things like strategic ability, and so he ended up being relegated to a 'lower' academic stream and discouraged from pursuing a university education.

Had we grown up in a country where chess ability is more highly valued (as a competitive endeavor as in the US, or as a proxy for strategic ability as it is in Russia), then his academic and/or career prospects might have been very different. but in a system where strategic ability is not selected for, he was classified as below average and no doubt enjoyed fewer opportunities as a result. Between one person who is better at calculus and another that's better at chess, which is more meritorious?

Re:What Happens When You Ban Affirmative Action in College A... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @07:37PM (#10708036)
I never claimed merit = math ability, except of course perhaps for the job of math professor.

The fact that our predictor is imperfect doesn't mean that it magically becomes better when we attach racial weights to it.

Between one person who is better at calculus and another that's better at chess, which is more meritorious?

Depends on whether he's applying to a chess or physics program, no?

Re:What Happens When You Ban Affirmative Action in College A... by anigbrowl on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @09:01PM (#10708364)
Perhaps you didn't intend this, but using nuclear physics as your threshold example certainly prioritizes a particular kind of academic merit over other kinds.

Between one person who is better at calculus and another that's better at chess, which is more meritorious?

Depends on whether he's applying to a chess or physics program, no?

After I tell you that merit isn't a scalar and invite you to consider measures of merit that are somewhat orthogonal to each other, the best you can come back with is to say it depends which (orthogonal) field of endeavor they're seeking to enter? Pretend the answer is neither, they're competing for the last available place in a medical school.

My whole point here is that facility with calculus or chess both demonstrate cognitive ability, but there's no universal standard for asserting that one is better than the other - we can only talk in terms of what sort of utility it is that we wish to maximize. Likewise, absent universally agreeable standards of merit, we can't easily say one group of people is better than another while neglecting structural biases. It might be that people who are good at calculus would in fact make superior chess players if we were to invest in some remedial chess lessons to rectify the shortcomings of their strategic education, so to speak.

Re:What Happens When You Ban Affirmative Action in College A... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @10:20PM (#10708654)
If your only claim is that different fields require a different sort of merit, I agree. Obviously merit for medical school differs from merit for chess camp.

I fail to see how this supports the claim that an admission system is non-meritocratic simply because some people are unable to pass it due to bad life circumstances.

Re:What Happens When You Ban Affirmative Action in College A... by rmxt on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @06:43PM (#10707754)
It's even sadder that you need to draw an absurd comparison to the imaginary instance of retarded people attempting break into nuclear physics in order to frame a discussion about the very real implications of race, socioeconomic status, affirmative action and educational achievement.

Is it your implication that society shouldn't care about performance gaps between segments of the population because those other segments are incorrigible? Much like retards trying to perform nuclear physics, right?

Re:What Happens When You Ban Affirmative Action in College A... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @10:22PM (#10708660)
My sole implication is that a system can fail to solve all your pet problems, but still be meritocratic.

Similarly, a meritocratic college admission system doesn't cure cancer.