News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Happens When You Ban Affirmative Action in College A... by anigbrowl on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @06:47PM (#10707776)
Perhaps in future technology will advance tot he point that we can give you an empathy transplant, and you'll realize how glaringly obvious your rhetorical fallacies are to others. Most people would agree that 'merit' is not a scalar quality best measured by mathematical ability, notwithstanding your enjoyable position at the extreme right of that distribution.

Even in quantitative endeavors, we do not magically have access to inherently reliable objective measures. The example I use to remind myself of this is a childhood friend whom I consistently outscored over a period of several years in language, math and other subjects - but who could consistently beat me in a wide variety of pure-strategy board games. Unfortunately the standardized testing regime we grew up with was no good at measuring things like strategic ability, and so he ended up being relegated to a 'lower' academic stream and discouraged from pursuing a university education.

Had we grown up in a country where chess ability is more highly valued (as a competitive endeavor as in the US, or as a proxy for strategic ability as it is in Russia), then his academic and/or career prospects might have been very different. but in a system where strategic ability is not selected for, he was classified as below average and no doubt enjoyed fewer opportunities as a result. Between one person who is better at calculus and another that's better at chess, which is more meritorious?

Re:What Happens When You Ban Affirmative Action in College A... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @07:37PM (#10708036)
I never claimed merit = math ability, except of course perhaps for the job of math professor.

The fact that our predictor is imperfect doesn't mean that it magically becomes better when we attach racial weights to it.

Between one person who is better at calculus and another that's better at chess, which is more meritorious?

Depends on whether he's applying to a chess or physics program, no?

Re:What Happens When You Ban Affirmative Action in College A... by anigbrowl on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @09:01PM (#10708364)
Perhaps you didn't intend this, but using nuclear physics as your threshold example certainly prioritizes a particular kind of academic merit over other kinds.

Between one person who is better at calculus and another that's better at chess, which is more meritorious?

Depends on whether he's applying to a chess or physics program, no?

After I tell you that merit isn't a scalar and invite you to consider measures of merit that are somewhat orthogonal to each other, the best you can come back with is to say it depends which (orthogonal) field of endeavor they're seeking to enter? Pretend the answer is neither, they're competing for the last available place in a medical school.

My whole point here is that facility with calculus or chess both demonstrate cognitive ability, but there's no universal standard for asserting that one is better than the other - we can only talk in terms of what sort of utility it is that we wish to maximize. Likewise, absent universally agreeable standards of merit, we can't easily say one group of people is better than another while neglecting structural biases. It might be that people who are good at calculus would in fact make superior chess players if we were to invest in some remedial chess lessons to rectify the shortcomings of their strategic education, so to speak.

Re:What Happens When You Ban Affirmative Action in College A... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @10:20PM (#10708654)
If your only claim is that different fields require a different sort of merit, I agree. Obviously merit for medical school differs from merit for chess camp.

I fail to see how this supports the claim that an admission system is non-meritocratic simply because some people are unable to pass it due to bad life circumstances.