1. She failed at putting Yahoo back on the map. She spent billions on acquiring businesses that bring in close to no revenue. Maybe it's a great place to work, but if there's no money coming in, it won't stay great long.
2. She failed at financial engineering; she couldn't even get a tax free spinoff through.
I would've been happy to cut her some slack if she did one of these things right, and messed up the other one. Some people aren't meant to be product people and others just aren't financial engineers. But this is basically throwing in the towel.
Don't forget, this idea of a reverse spinoff didn't come from Marissa. It came from an activist investor, who are basically, master financial engineers.
When Mayer took over, they had no ability to attract or retain any kind of tech talent. Now, they can do so at the same rate as any other ad company. That's a big change.
She didn't hit it out of the park, but she's delivered her shareholders a solid double.
She managed to keep a part of Alibaba stake. This reverse spin off will also be tax free.
The BABA stake had to be separated from Yahoo, but this is literally the worst possible way, aside from selling the shares + paying taxes, to achieve this.
That's not proof of badness, but it does suggest desperation and lack of imagination.
It's completely different. Yahoo is not splitting up its core businesses.
They're taking a non-core asset (the Alibaba stake) that they can't sell without incurring a huge tax bill, and separating it from yahoo Core so that they can hand it over to Yahoo's shareholders (presumably in the hope that someone else - e.g. Alibaba - will step up to acquire it, thus unlocking the value for the shareholders), and re-focus on Yahoo's core businesses again.
There is a separate issue that the core of Yahoo is performing poorly, and that fact may well result in Yahoo Core being split up and sold off but it's important now to conflate the two issues.
Board feels Yahoo's core business is undervalued. The spin off will help clear the picture of how much Yahoo's core business independently value.
They are not looking for buyers (unless someone has a offer they can't refuse).
http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2015-09-09/yahoo-s-ali...
So if the above is roughly accurate it's more like the loophole everybody used is closing and now they're going with a less desirable loophole.
> It's not clear to me that it actually does anything worth paying for at this point.
Few users of Google and Facebook actually "pay" for those services, they're primarily all advertising funded companies.
I didn't mean that users would pay for them; I meant that I don't see how one could use them to make money, or at least enough money that it would be worth bothering to acquire them.
News is massive.
Sports is massive and has one of the top Fantasy operations, a growing market.
Homepage is still the homepage for people who set homepages.
All are monetized through one of the most effective ad selling operations out there.
Glad to hear they still have a following. I thought GMail and Hotmail were bigger than Yahoo! Mail but what do I know!
Everyone wins here. Managers win, of course, but shareholders, who have been patient, get short-term returns and the potential for long-term ones as well. Employees will see their jobs stay, because of this repackaging.
Yes, Mayer will be gone in a year, replaced by someone with experience selling a company. But it's been a good run. She turned Yahoo from a place with mediocre engineers into a decent place to work; she resuscitated existing brands and gave them a place in the world; and now she did some reasonably clever financial engineering.