News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chemicals linked with severe respiratory disease found in... by madeofpalk on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @08:12PM (#10701183)
Well I mean, there's a threshold - it's not OK to sell an arsenic laced Apple just because it has a warning on it.
Re:Chemicals linked with severe respiratory disease found in... by jMyles on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @08:27PM (#10701255)
In theory - why not?
Re:Chemicals linked with severe respiratory disease found in... by anigbrowl on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @09:13PM (#10701448)
Because there's an implicit assumption that anything offered for sale to the public without restrictions is of merchantable quality. Arsenic-laced apples don't serve a useful purpose whose benefit is sufficient to offset the cost of being poisonous, unlike cleaning materials that may nevertheless be toxic if misused or other potentially dangerous merchandise.
Re:Chemicals linked with severe respiratory disease found in... by jMyles on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @09:17PM (#10701470)
> there's an implicit assumption that anything offered for sale to the public without restrictions is of merchantable quality

You gloss over this as if it weren't kind of a huge deal.

This assumption is breaking a lot of systems in society.

Re:Chemicals linked with severe respiratory disease found in... by anigbrowl on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @09:55PM (#10701629)
So you claim, but it is the sort of thing people would like to be able to rely on and the sort of task they opt to delegate to government. It's nice to fantasize about a libertarian society where markets are unrestricted and consumers have total freedom to buy and sell whatever, but in practice it ends up with people dying because they unknowingly bought shitty products, and demands for effective regulation to ensure some quality control. You can see that happening in china right now with increasing demands for accountability to do with quality-of-life issues rather than just maximizing economic growth.

If you think this assumption leads to bad outcomes, pick up a tort law book and read the details of historical cases from when an 'anything goes' mentality was predominant.

Re:Chemicals linked with severe respiratory disease found in... by jMyles on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @03:58AM (#10702647)
> If you think this assumption leads to bad outcomes, pick up a tort law book and read the details of historical cases from when an 'anything goes' mentality was predominant.

I studied this to a non-trivial degree in college during undergrad, though of course not on the level of graduate economic theory or anything. My understanding is that the major markers (such as drug overdose) were at record lows following the Pure Food and Drug Act, a relatively non-intrusive measure that required labeling and some rudimentary testing and inspection, but preceding the FDA and drug prohibition and all the rest.

This seems to comport with the world I watch around me.

Am I wrong about this?

Re:Chemicals linked with severe respiratory disease found in... by logicallee on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @08:51PM (#10701350)
And why require the label, right? The free market means that companies that sell arsenic-laced apples will lose market share as people stop buying from them /s
Re:Chemicals linked with severe respiratory disease found in... by jMyles on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @09:16PM (#10701463)
I don't understand exactly - are you mocking me?

I think most people who have this sort of free-market disposition are moderate enough to think that labeling an arsenic apple is reasonable.

Re:Chemicals linked with severe respiratory disease found in... by logicallee on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @11:39PM (#10701943)
Of course I'm mocking you. You just said "In theory - why not?" to "it's not OK to sell an arsenic laced Apple just because it has a warning on it." You cannot be serious.
Re:Chemicals linked with severe respiratory disease found in... by jMyles on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @11:51PM (#10701975)
Of course I can. If it's labeled, why not? Maybe somebody wants an arsenic apple; I don't know. I don't judge people that way.

Moreover, and far more importantly, it seems evident that, once government starts making these sorts of decisions, it quickly makes them only for its own interests.

Re:Chemicals linked with severe respiratory disease found in... by logicallee on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @01:28AM (#10702244)
what are the government's "own interests"? why do you think they are currently okay with me going to a grocery store and buying some chips with 200% of my recommended sodium intake, but not some chips with a warning that it might contain arsenic and not to eat it under any circumstances, then I eat it and then I die? do you seriously think the latter would be OK if, say, it makes the company more than it loses in sales? that the free market will just 'sort it out'? and if you think that, then why wouldn't you think it would magically solve the labelling problem? (no labelling required, since consumers would just boycott companies that aren't in the habit of properly labeling its lead-, mercury- and arsenic-laced potato chips)...

I'm not asking tricky questions here, your position is like saying the Earth is flat. I mean, due to the example we're using, apple with arsenic in them but labelled with this information, it's like a very extreme position. Normally it would be a straw man - nobody would seriously suggest that this is okay.

Re:Chemicals linked with severe respiratory disease found in... by jMyles on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @03:52AM (#10702633)
I was going to put some thought into a response, but I read your reply again and it's just too full of vitriol and angst for me to know where to begin.

Comparing a reasonably widely-held, studied, and written-about economic model to the flat earth society? You give me nothing to go on here. Perhaps you're young and haven't read much yet - I don't know. I suggest a history of economics course in college.

As for your very first question: the government's interests aren't terribly hard to identify, especially in the case of the USA, where the government is a hegemonic empire. It seeks to enrich its corporate sponsors, expand its capacity to exact violence against its detractors, and find equilibrium in its body politic via panem et circenses. It's reasonably transparent I think.

As for your slippery slope bit about being able to sell unlabeled arsenic: I like what works. The current system clearly isn't working for most people for most purposes. My understanding is that drug overdoses were at record lows during the period after the Pure Food and Drug Act but before drug prohibition. I take this, and other data like it, as evidence that this configuration is a decent balance.

Re:Chemicals linked with severe respiratory disease found in... by logicallee on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @01:11PM (#10705521)
jMyles, the whole current discussion is only about selling apples that are laced with arsenic and will kill you, as long as they're labelled properly. that's what we're talking about. that's the only thing under discussion. we're discussing a straw man, except that you actually brought it up, so it's not a straw man.

obviously no one wants the status quo to change to that. (not even you, even though you aren't sure.) like, literally nobody. (even people who say they do, don't actually want to have to start reading labels on their fruit to make sure they won't die.)

there's almost nothing to go on in this discussion, we're talking - only - about such an extreme viewpoint.

Anyway what interests of the "hegemonic empire" does the fact that I can eat an apple without reading its label and not die, serve? You can't say "oh that's easy - the hegemonic empire doesn't want its stormtroopers - that would be its population - to die, because they can't fight for hte hegemonic empire or pay their taxes" because if that were the case it would ALSO be in the interests of the "hegemonic empire" to ban grossly unhealthy foods so people don't die of heart disease - the U.S. has the lowest life expectancy among rich countries in part for this reason: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_life_expe... But they don't do that, or many other things.

there's just no answer to why my grocery store isn't allowed to sell arsenic-laced apples as long as they're labelled, except the COMPLETELY OBVIOUS one that the government does its basic job and protects people from this thing. there's just no other answer. the mental contortions you would have to go through to believe that they're "seeking to enrich their corporate sponsors" and that's why you can't sell arsenic-laced apples is just - I mean, come on.

The reason you would have to put "some thought" into answering my questoins - even though they're super simple - is the same as why a flat-earther would have to put "some thought" into answering the question of why someone can broadcat an image of a spinning, round, Earth, from space. This requires some explanation, because the idea that the Earth is actually flat is so obviously untenable.

I was on the debate team in high school, out of these two statements: "Resolved: the Earth is a flat disc, not a round sphere-like object in space" and "Resolved: it ought to be legal to sell apples that are or might be arsenic-laced and deadly to consumers as long as a label is affixed to them informing consumers of this fact" it is absolutely easier to argue the affirmative of the former. It's just sooo easy, all you have to explain is a few images from space, everything else people don't have any personal experience with. Even the bible is on your side. There are people who believe this http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Flat_Earth - on the other hand, everyone has purchased apples. You won't find anyone who would have been okay with them being arsenic-laced, as long as there is a label on them. It's just not something anyone can actually argue - which is why you go off on this totally irrelevant tangent about enriching corporate sponsors.

this entire thread with me discusses nothing but why the government shouldn't deregulate selling poisoned food. That's it. it's obvious. completely obvious.

Excuse me if there is some vitriol, but I'm not okay with someone arguing a position that I have to start reading labels on my fruits to make sure I don't die. It's not a position you can take. It's why you had originally gotten downvoted when you asked "in theory, why not". me dying of fruit is not a small price to pay for your right to test some alternative economic theory. you're arguing for my death. (or massive, massive personal inconvenience.)

you know, you can just admit you're wrong. Why not just reply and say: "You're right, it's obvious to me why labeling fruit shouldn't let you lace them with poison. I was really just thinking about other cases, my apologies." in other cases, sure you could be right.

Re:Chemicals linked with severe respiratory disease found in... by jMyles on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:27AM (#10709359)
Now that you are being somewhat civil, I'm wishing I had more time to engage.

Just a couple quick things and then I really have to dip from this thread, at least for now:

* You are using the word "strawman," but I don't think you actually mean strawman. I think you are trying to describe a slippery slope. Strawman is a fallacy wherein one debater misrepresents the position of another, and then uses this weaker misrepresentation as the basis for a response. In fact, it's exactly what you are doing when you say "oh that's easy - the hegemonic empire doesn't want its stormtroopers - that would be its population - to die, because they can't fight for hte hegemonic empire or pay their taxes" - this is a position I didn't take, don't hold, and which weakens your position to argue against. You are talking to a wall.

* You say:

> I'm not okay with someone arguing a position that I have to start reading labels on my fruits to make sure I don't die.

...and I'm just given pause because it's almost like you aren't living in the same world as the rest of us.

You do need to read labels. There are poisons in food. People do die from food - quick, sickening deaths like from e-coli in fast food and, in much greater numbers, slow, miserable deaths from obesity and diabecity. Do you not realize that these are the main causes of death in our society? I mean... is it possible that this just hasn't occurred to you? You made direct reference to it in your comment, but the points seems to have been lost on you.

So, on one hand, the FDA has failed to stop toxic food from becoming the biggest cause of premature death in society.

On the other hand, the FDA, along with its state counterparts, have stopped low-cost, healthy food from entering the food supply and threatening the quasi-monopolies held by a few small, giant corporate agriculture sponsors.

To pull out just one example - but you can find more every day across the country - just down the road from where I sit in Michigan: the Michigan Dept. of Agriculture actually forced a farm co-op to dump hundreds of gallons of milk and to destroy over a thousand free-range eggs because they were deemed for 'sale' instead the property of the co-op:

http://www.wnem.com/story/26116053/farmers-forced-to-dump-pr...

I want to give you the benefit of the doubt here; maybe you just didn't realize these things were happening. But it's bad. The food is bad, and it's mostly various arms of the government that are making it so.

And please, bottle the acid with your stormtroopers bit. It's much simpler than that, of course: it's about money. There's no complex shroud of intent here. Huge agricultural companies pay the government to make their products the only game in town. It's really not much more complicated than that.

This is par for the course; there is no example in history of government making the food supply safer, and even less so in the center of empire. As a habit, empires push unhealthy food and drugs on their own populous and that of their colonies. This is the basic dynamic of the opium war, of alcohol prohibition, and of drug prohibition today.

At the end of the day, I prefer that it be legal for people to sell ridiculous, snake-oily products, even unto properly labeled arsenic apples, then to have to choose between subsidized poison and scarce real food.

Arsenic apples are not a threat to food security. Nobody will even try to sell them. And if they do, nobody will buy them. Hill High Dairy being shut down is a threat to food security.

These are not hypotheticals; these are the actual choices we have to make about the role, if any, for government to play in assisting adults in securing healthy food.

Re:Chemicals linked with severe respiratory disease found in... by logicallee on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:47AM (#10709634)
can you please reread this thread from the top, to see how we got here?

you've written a lot just now - but it completely moves the goalposts. You think we're discussing something more, or different, than what we're discussing. We're discussing selling arsenic-laced apples. You're discussing something different now, but here's why I said you were acting like a living, breathing, moving straw man upthread:

Let's say I were debating government regulation of food with someone, and I said: "There are people who say '"it's OK to sell an arsenic laced Apple as long as it has a warning on it.", writing "Of course I can. If it's labeled, why not? Maybe somebody wants an arsenic apple; I don't know.". I would now like to address this point...."

Then my opponent would interrupt me: "Objection! Wait! Nooooo, that is a straw man! Nobody on Earth seriously believes it's okay to sell arsenic appples as long as they're labelled. I didn't say this! Nobody said this! This is not a position anyone has. You are arguing against a straw man! You're arguing against a wall."

Yet, here we are. I quoted you stating that position. That's what we're discussing. Whether it's okay to sell arsenic-laced apples "as long as they're labelled."

--> Perhaps we're agreed that it's not okay, and that this shouldn't suddenly be legal?

You've raised interesting points about e coli, about unhealthy foods that cause a slow death. Personally, I haven't said anything in this thread about regulation and labeling of these things, except perhaps that the government isn't currently doing it. (not a normative statement.)