I'm sorry, but you are naive if you think that NATs will go away with IPv6 or that the absence of NATs would make it safer. In fact, NATs have found a way back to IPv6 and any deployment I have seen with IPv6 that was not done by a university actually goes through a NAT.
In the IPv4 realm the term NAT is often interpreted to mean connection rules in addition to network address translation. It is the address translation that is the source and focus of much criticism of IPv4 "NAT" and it is exactly that feature that is unneeded in the IPv6 realm.
So while network address translation is superfluous in IPv6, there is still an argument to be made for network access rules.
I would be interested to here what technical arguments were being made for true network address translation in an IPv6 network.
> This doesn't sound right to me. There is no need
> to do address translation in IPv6 networks. It may
> be that there is still a firewall in place with rules
> about incoming and outgoing connections, though.
Multi-wan egress balancing (without bgp) is one usecase for NAT66 (NPTv6).There is no need, but typically desire. Which company is comfortable leaking out individual employees IP addresses if they can avoid it? There are more downsides from a security point of view than upsides.
But thank you for pointing out explicitly one of the 'reasons' that is given for IPv6 NAT.
What? Nat is always a bug with a hack piled upon hack upon hack. The amount of crap that needs done to get ip2ip communications working and other multiport protocols is stupid and introduces piles of security risks. Protocols like uPNP have produced a plethora of critical exploits allowing an attacker full access to the NAT'ed network. Firewall controlled IPv4 with a 1:1 ratio of ip to host is always much easier to control the security risks with.
Everyone else simply uses NAT because they have no other choice, there simply isn't IPs in the 4 address space to do whats needed.
So yet again we have a implementation tragedy where everyone would be better off with it working, but no one will do it, leaving us with a hulking crapsack we are used to in every aspect of our life.
Further reading: http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/