Re:When Do Extraordinary Claims Give Extraordinary Evidence?...
by andrewflnr on Sunday December 06, 2015 @01:08PM
(#10685951)
That may be the ideal usage, but I'm not sure I've ever seen it used that way. If the phrase is about contradicting existing evidence, we should just say that instead.
Re:When Do Extraordinary Claims Give Extraordinary Evidence?...
by nickpsecurity on Sunday December 06, 2015 @01:14PM
(#10685980)
My point exactly. "Extraordinary evidence" just seems made up. I only require more and/or better evidence to back up an extraordinary claim versus claims contradicting it.
Re:When Do Extraordinary Claims Give Extraordinary Evidence?...
by GFK_of_xmaspast on Monday December 07, 2015 @11:58AM
(#10690685)
> more and/or better evidence
So, in other words, evidence that is beyond the ordinary. If only there were a prefix that could be applied here.
Re:When Do Extraordinary Claims Give Extraordinary Evidence?...
by nickpsecurity on Monday December 07, 2015 @12:41PM
(#10691047)
No, ordinary evidence or models that fit the observed data better or make more accurate predictions. I leave out the extraordinary part except for when praising scientists for talented observations or methods.
Re:When Do Extraordinary Claims Give Extraordinary Evidence?...
by paulddraper on Monday December 07, 2015 @09:44PM
(#10694439)
Okay. Well, here extraordinary is supposed to mean better/more then ordinary.
But if it means talented or praiseworthy or something similar, then I whole-heatedly agree.
For example, if someone finds a way to create mass/energy, that would be extraordinary. All existing evidence suggests mass/energy is conserved. Even if no one has tried XYZ before, the evidence of XYZ creating energy has to be weighed against the evidence of thousands of (other) processes not doing that. It's possible someone made a mistake, or the results are being interpreted incorrectly.
While there is an ideal, the reality is that "evidence" is of varying types and qualities, and that perfect evidence is not always feasible.
In the US, criminal convictions ("extraordinary" claims) require proof beyond reasonable doubt. But civil convictions ("ordinary" claims) require only a preponderance of the evidence.