News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Towns want Verizon investigated for abandoning networks t... by JustSomeNobody on Friday December 04, 2015 @12:13PM (#10677531)
Why is this getting so many down votes? What is wrong with mesh networks?

Personally, I would love to see some sort of decentralization.

Re:Towns want Verizon investigated for abandoning networks t... by elbigbad on Friday December 04, 2015 @12:34PM (#10677676)
Agreed, mesh networks are awesome and could be very interesting in this space.

I think the downvotes are because the poster basically handwaved a complex problem by saying that THE solution is mesh networks.

Re:Towns want Verizon investigated for abandoning networks t... by blakeyrat on Friday December 04, 2015 @02:28PM (#10678483)
I'd be interested in trying it, and it might be great for otherwise-expensive "last-mile" situations, but...

I play video games, and I can't imagine what the latency would be like over a mesh network. So many hops, so many pieces of questionable cheap home hardware handling my data...

Re:Towns want Verizon investigated for abandoning networks t... by jhallenworld on Friday December 04, 2015 @03:07PM (#10678781)
There is an interesting way to make this work, inspired by "skip-list" data structure. Suppose you sell network radio gear. You want your customers to have a tree network instead of a mesh network to reduce the number of hops. So sell a random distribution of stations: most customers get short-range stations. Some get longer range stations. Some lucky few get very long range high capacity stations.

You will end up with a random geographic distribution of radios with different capabilities. The number of network hops will be reduced because, as with skip lists, you find a path to high capacity station, then skip longs distances, then find the final recipient.

In practice this would be difficult to deploy (Can you legally give high power stations? What about RF safety of higher power stations?), but I think the idea is neat.

Re:Towns want Verizon investigated for abandoning networks t... by iamsohungry on Saturday December 05, 2015 @03:06PM (#10683094)
> I play video games, and I can't imagine what the latency would be like over a mesh network.

1. Neither can anyone, because we don't have examples of large-scale usage of mesh networks, and the amount of research that has gone into mesh networks is nowhere near as extensive as exists with ISPs. There's no reason to assume that mesh networks will always have higher latency, especially in places where i.e. Comcast is choking connections.

2. The small-scale mesh networks which already exist are demonstrably adequate for many, many use-cases. Mesh networks which handle text and image web browsing, email, instant messaging, are still extremely useful even if they have trouble handling streaming video and video games.