News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jury Duty by madaxe_again on Friday December 04, 2015 @07:28AM (#10675916)
The thing is, "peers" has had its meaning mutated beyond recognition over the ages.

A jury of your peers used to mean exactly that - people who were familiar with you, the social circumstances that lead to your being in the dock, who had empathy both for you and for the law. Part of the tradition comes from the Frankpledge and tythings, which required you and your peers to collectively police one another, and endure collective punishment if you failed in your duty to justice. In addition, early juries were responsible for investigating the purported crime themselves, and were allowed to acquire information for themselves.

This of course all lead to a degree of corruption (in fact, significant corruption in later years), but was potentially an ultimately fairer system, less biased in favour of conviction.

Having a jury prevaricate on the outcome of a trial concerning someone who comes from a different world to them, who don't understand the nuance of the reality that faces them, who are not allowed to educate themselves about legal facts or the facts of the charges, frankly beggars belief - but it's what we have.

Re:Jury Duty by newjersey on Friday December 04, 2015 @07:47AM (#10675990)
Moreover, jury selection is a touchy subject itself.

http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/discrimination-jury-s...

> In order to show that the prosecutor’s dismissal of a juror was discriminatory, a defendant must show that it was based on race, ethnicity, or gender.

A good legal defense is already out of reach of many people.

I'd think this alone (fta) should cause a judge to throw out the prosecution from the case:

> The first thing the prosecutor did during voir dire was ask all the men of color whether we trusted cops. Every black man had a story: police harassment, spurious arrests, intimidation.

Re:Jury Duty by ckozlowski on Friday December 04, 2015 @08:11AM (#10676087)
That the defense didn't object to this, or ask the alternate ("Does anyone in here intrinsically trust the police?") perplexes me.
Re:Jury Duty by newjersey on Friday December 04, 2015 @09:16AM (#10676395)
> That the defense didn't object to this, or ask the alternate ("Does anyone in here intrinsically trust the police?") perplexes me.

Actually, it didn't occur to me. You made it sound very simple but I didn't see it as a possibility at all. So if someone says yes, we just throw them out of the jury. Now I think this should be a standard question for any case where the police is a witness.

Well, on second thought, we will probably still need a sympathetic judge if we are throwing out someone "with cause". There are only so many we can throw out without a cause.

Re:Jury Duty by mszkoda on Friday December 04, 2015 @09:42AM (#10676542)
I thought this was commonly asked, but maybe it varies by state. In my city in Pennsylvania we get a standardized form that does ask this question. It states, "Would you be more likely to believe the testimony of a police officer or any other law enforcement officer because of his or her job?" [1]

[1]http://www.pacode.com/secure/data/234/chapter6/s632.html

Re:Jury Duty by 4ad on Friday December 04, 2015 @09:52AM (#10676587)
So what kind of answer are they expecting for that question? I genuinely can't tell. It seems obvious to me that people who answer "yes" should be excluded, yet I feel the opposite is true.
Re:Jury Duty by ckozlowski on Friday December 04, 2015 @07:47AM (#10675986)
"are not allowed to educate themselves about legal facts or the facts of the charges"

Because they're not trained lawyers, and they haven't passed the bar. It's to keep them impartial and prevent them from presuming they know the law better and therefor enter with a conclusion without all of the facts.

That's why the judge (who, depending on the level, is either directly-elected or appointed by the person you elected) is there, not to determine guilt, but to be the impartial legal expert and identify the points of law to be decided on, and act as umpire to respect the rights of the plaintiff and accused. These are tasks that just cannot be given to the jury without establishing some sort of certification on them, which would remove from ordinary people the ability to determine justice.

Re:Jury Duty by ethbro on Friday December 04, 2015 @08:34AM (#10676185)
That's rebutted by the Janet Malcolm quote the author includes.

The absences of knowledge isn't impartiality: people don't render decisions from ignorance + logic.

They simply fabricate their best attempt at knowledge and apply that to the situation. So in this respect, it's not a choice between "relying on legal experts to provide legal information" and "using your own amateur legal knowledge" but rather "bastardizing legal experts' explanations to fit your own views" and "using your own amateur legal knowledge."

From that perspective, the latter seems a lot more preferable...

Re:Jury Duty by ckozlowski on Friday December 04, 2015 @08:47AM (#10676246)
I think the intent is to have people "relying on legal experts to provide legal information". What often happens is "bastardizing legal experts' explanations to fit your own views". I suspect there's a fear that trying to apply the law on one's own leads to the latter happening more. But one could argue that it happens anyways, as you point out.

I wouldn't argue the absence of bias, we seem to be in agreement there, and I think that's the real point of the article. A lot of the arguments on this thread seem to be aimed at the jury system in general. In my opinion, it's not a fault of the jury system, but a fault of people. The jury system, and the instructions given (that we're debating now) are meant to try and minimize that, but they're far from perfect.

The question then becomes, "how do we best get jurors the information they need, while preserving their impartiality?" And I think that's a hard thing to do.

Re:Jury Duty by ethbro on Friday December 04, 2015 @10:57AM (#10676997)
I think a start would be to have a truly impartial legal consultation system that jurors could avail themselves of at any point. The responses would be given with a minimum of contextual information about the case necessary to answer the question.

In practice, the judge is supposed to serve this role, no? But I think it's readily apparent from the variances in judge activism that judges are people too. In hearing all the details about the case they can't help but form an opinion and are in a position to act on that opinion to varying degrees should they so choose.

Re:Jury Duty by JoeAltmaier on Friday December 04, 2015 @10:59AM (#10677011)
Juries are weird. Supposed to inject mercy into the system, right? They are your 'peers' and supposed to know better than the lawyers about your situation. Deliberately not experts in law, and not supposed to be. I'm not sure 'impartiality' and legal information are what Juries are about.
Re:Jury Duty by Lawtonfogle on Friday December 04, 2015 @04:15PM (#10679181)
I sat on a jury once. The way the judge explained to us how we should decide which evidence to consider or not consider, especially with regards to evidence that is 'clear and convincing' was extremely convoluted. And this is from someone who works in very convoluted systems, has read significant amounts of law, worked with lawyers, and who has taken classes in law. I can only imagine how other jurors who haven't had any significant experience with legal matters felt.
Re:Jury Duty by astrafoo on Friday December 04, 2015 @08:21AM (#10676128)
So a jury being lied to by the state attorney is better than a jury which did their own research (with all the faults this includes)?
Re:Jury Duty by ckozlowski on Friday December 04, 2015 @08:36AM (#10676199)
That's the job of the defense, who's trained and has done the research. It's their job to call bullshit on the prosecution in your presence.

So you have two sides who are trained and have (hopefully!) done the research i.e, the facts of the case. Provided they have (and the judge can and will throw out cases where this hasn't been done), then the judge will instruct on the points of law being decided here, which the jury will then decide on.

It's far from perfect, because people aren't perfect. But it's a degree better than the State simply deciding your guilt.

Sometimes the parties show up with half a case, the jury can't agree, and the foreman throws up their hands and says "This is all bollocks", and everyone goes home. Which is what happened in the article.

Re:Jury Duty by astrafoo on Friday December 04, 2015 @08:47AM (#10676249)
> That's the job of the defense

Which might not exist depending on the jury's job. See a few recent of the recent cases were a jury decided to not indict police officers for killing blacks based on citations from the law given by the DA/SA which were "accidentally" wrong.

No defense involved.

Re:Jury Duty by ckozlowski on Friday December 04, 2015 @08:57AM (#10676300)
Indictments are different. There's no defense because no one's been charged. (high profile cases aside, this is to keep the potential accused from even being mentioned because no charges have been given.) So it's entirely a matter of determining if there's enough cause to go to trial. Once at that stage, then the person becomes an accused, and defense becomes involved.
Re:Jury Duty by d_t_w on Friday December 04, 2015 @07:40AM (#10675955)
Yes you make a series of perfectly good points, and I learned about the Frankpledge, so thanks for that.

I agree it is not a utopian system by any regard, but I still think a country that has trial by jury is superior to one with bench trials only. Perhaps not in each individual case, but as a means of rebalancing the power of the establishment vs the people.

I've a friend who is a prosecutors assistant in Australia, having quite a dim view of the ability of my peers I asked him just last week how he rated the performance of the trials he had watched and he said he didn't think he had ever seen a jury get it wrong.

Then again he's just a big bag of relatively well educated prejudice and blind-spots like all of us, so there is that.

Re:Jury Duty by michaelt on Friday December 04, 2015 @07:45AM (#10675978)
If an oil company CEO on trial for a crime got tried by a jury of other oil company CEOs, I agree the conviction rate would drop.

I'm not sure how much it would improve the outcomes for society, though.

Re:Jury Duty by madaxe_again on Friday December 04, 2015 @08:30AM (#10676169)
Yes, but the counterpoint is that if they let their buddy off the hook and this is later found to be the case, they all end up on a considerably pointier hook.

Speaking of, "the hook" was what you got in the Ottoman Empire instead of a jury trial. You'd be sat upon a large metal hook until you confessed or died.

Re:Jury Duty by voxic11 on Friday December 04, 2015 @12:23PM (#10677601)
Why would they? Jury nullification is legal.