News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Complete Notes to Good Calories, Bad Calories by Gary Tau... by jerf on Thursday January 21, 2010 @10:28AM (#1067439)
Look, you just spouted the dietary dogma in the face of a book that has dozens upon dozens of references to scientific literature. The only thing stopping me saying "hundreds" is I'm not quite sure if it gets up to 200, though I bet it does. (I don't have it in front of me to check.) Even if you're completely right (which I do not believe despite being raised on that theory), simply re-spouting it is not an adequate response to this book.

That theory simply doesn't explain all the observations, and you need to catch up to modern science. Salt especially; current science strongly indicates that salt is not a problem for a normal person, it only matters if you already have a blood pressure problem (and I still think it may yet be revealed that it actually has no effect at all and it's all sugar). This isn't even from Taubes' book, this is simply the current state of the science.

Running on the dietary theories of the 1960s leaves you defenseless in the face of our current food environment, and when you get in trouble it doesn't give you a way out. Check this new stuff out. Check out the sugar video lionhearted referenced, it's free and the source is unimpeachable, and unlike reading the book which has the step of obtaining a book, that video is as easy to watch as any other video on YouTube. It has biochemistry in it. It's pretty good.

Re:Complete Notes to Good Calories, Bad Calories by Gary Tau... by Psyonic on Thursday January 21, 2010 @01:58PM (#1068001)
The funny thing is that Taubes book basically recommends you do away with those things anyway: who likes burgers without the bun? fries are out, shakes are out, tacos without the shell? no thanks, etc, etc.

Where he differs, he has a lot more science to back it up.

Re:Complete Notes to Good Calories, Bad Calories by Gary Tau... by lacrossegm on Thursday January 21, 2010 @03:53PM (#1068294)
I'm not so sure about the science.

This quote is taken from the wiki article on Gary Taubes

"Although Taubes has no formal training in nutrition or medicine, his book was praised as "raising interesting and valuable points" by Dr. Andrew Weil, while Dr. Mehmet Oz and trainer Jillian Michaels who appeared on the same program disagreed with Taubes on many questions. [6]"

I think we have to question the science when he states that exercise is an inefficient tool for weight loss.

Taubes is against refined carbs (OK, that does make sense) but is a bit of a nutter on other causes and solutions to obesity.

Re:Complete Notes to Good Calories, Bad Calories by Gary Tau... by nova on Friday January 22, 2010 @08:07AM (#1069601)
I think we have to question the science when he states that exercise is an inefficient tool for weight loss.

The science of the book is sound. And he is right about exercise: it's good for fitness (as in muscle) and other health reasons, but for weight loss is almost useless by itself. The reason is insulin, which signal the body to store, not use, energy.

Of course you could calorie-count people on a high carb diet and whip them to exercise and they will probably lose weight. But you will also destroy their health and they will regain all of its former weight (and then some) later. This is documented and is all in the book too.

Re:Complete Notes to Good Calories, Bad Calories by Gary Tau... by Psyonic on Friday January 22, 2010 @12:50AM (#1069199)
Perhaps you're right. I'm definitely not qualified to say for certain, but it's something I'll look into.
Re:Complete Notes to Good Calories, Bad Calories by Gary Tau... by lacrossegm on Thursday January 21, 2010 @01:53PM (#1067988)
I was referring to concepts presented in "The End of Overeating: Taking Control of the Insatiable American Appetite" by David Kessler.

Of course, I wouldn't expect a lot of people on HN to agree, thus the down-votes.

A lot of the food industry is based on pumping the salt, sugar and fat so that we eat/buy more. So people focused on making money are more likely to side with Taubes (even if he's wrong) than with Kessler.

If I could down vote this thread, I would.