News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Transformation at Yahoo Foiled by Its Leader’s Inability ... by iaw on Thursday December 03, 2015 @07:55AM (#10669287)
I saw the writing on the wall when she cancelled the work from home policy and forced a lot of parents to either quit or start coming into the office. While, on the flip side she had an executive package that included day care right off of her office.

I decided I would never work for a company that hired Marissa Mayer after that. I screen my employers more carefully than they screen me, and that move showed she didn't give one shit about any of hers.

Re:Transformation at Yahoo Foiled by Its Leader’s Inability ... by discardorama on Thursday December 03, 2015 @10:55AM (#10670242)
> I saw the writing on the wall when she cancelled the work from home policy

Disclaimer: I was at Yahoo when she came and implemented this policy.

It irritates me to see uninformed people making such blanket comments. You have no idea what the policy was; I do. Let me explain it, in the hope that you (and others with this mindset) may learn something about it, and maybe even change their views.

There was a group of Yahoos ( < 200 ) who had a permanent work-from-home exemption (if you can call it that; there was never much of an enforced policy earlier). They never came in to an office (except for the occasional IT issue and package pickup). There were a couple of incidents where these remote workers were found to be moonlighting. So a study was done to see how many of these remote workers actually VPNed in. After a month or two, it turned out, a good number of them were actually working part-time. So a blanket ban was issued, with the caveat that if you could make a compelling case, you would still be allowed to WFH. In fact, a colleague of mine continued to work from home after this policy change. A number of strong people continued to WFH; a few were let go; and the rest had to hoof it to office.

Now, the mistake Marissa made wasn't with this policy; but it was in how she didn't go the next step: holding the managers of the shirkers responsible.

Which brings me to my thinking about why it's so hard to turn around Yahoo: the middle management. (Please do me a favor and read PG's excellent post http://www.paulgraham.com/yahoo.html after you're done reading this). Yahoo is filled with managers whose sole contribution is survival. There is no accountability for screwing up. Fucking up products badly has never gotten anyone fired.

Did you know Yahoo went through 3 different iterations of an attempt at a "social network"? Each and every time, sane minds pointed out that the concept was bad, the UX was bad, etc.; and yet the managers prevailed and it went down in flames, as predicted.

The joke in Yahoo used to be: throw everything into version 1.0, because you never know if there will be a version 1.1.

Marissa is failing not because she's a bad CEO (having seen Yahoo CEOs like Terry Semel, I can assure you she's the best they've had in the last 10 years); it's because she has no supporting cast. She trusts people too much. One manager once said to me (about her): meh, she'll be gone in a couple of years; I'll still be around. He had been there since 2001, and had no intention of moving anywhere. Collected fat paychecks by taking credit for others' work. And he was just one of many, many in there. Over the years I encountered so many people like him, where you had no idea what actually they contributed to the company.

/rant

Re:Transformation at Yahoo Foiled by Its Leader’s Inability ... by blisterpeanuts on Thursday December 03, 2015 @11:28AM (#10670470)
Yahoo for years has seemed like a company resting on its laurels. With 400 million email users and a bunch of web properties that are relatively low maintenance or running on automatic (weather, sports, finance), they have become complacent, while smarter competitors have blown past them in search, innovative new services etc.

Their News aggregator site used to be useful to me until it turned into something akin to a tabloid/clickbait site.

Sorry to hear that the 90s Dot Com mentality is still pervasive within the corporation, but maybe that's to be expected of a company that grew so fast and probably promoted a lot of amateurs into high managerial positions.

Re:Transformation at Yahoo Foiled by Its Leader’s Inability ... by DanBC on Thursday December 03, 2015 @10:58AM (#10670268)
Were they actually shirking? Were they doing all the work expected of them, just in fewer hours?

"I want to see you in your seat at your desk, otherwise I don't think you're working" is a sign of a terrible manager.

Re:Transformation at Yahoo Foiled by Its Leader’s Inability ... by discardorama on Thursday December 03, 2015 @11:01AM (#10670288)
If they were doing the work expected of them, they would have been allowed. I know people who continued working remotely. One of them was so good, that when I found out he was working remotely, I was surprised, because in 3 years of dealing with him, I had no idea. He lived in the boonies in Arizona, IIRC.
Re:Transformation at Yahoo Foiled by Its Leader’s Inability ... by RyanZAG on Thursday December 03, 2015 @12:04PM (#10670702)
Not really the issue. As you said, this was a group of less than 200 employees. Probably most of them were doing the work as expected. She cut a hugely morale boosting policy to get rid of a few shirkers and made herself and Yahoo look terrible right across the tech news for it. It was a huge and crucial mistake at a time when it looked like Yahoo might be picking up and it cut an enormous amount of momentum.

Obviously the even bigger mistake was not doing a massive company wide re-organization and throwing out all middle management. Middle management is only an asset if it is helping the business, and as is obviously the case in Yahoo, it is not.

Re:Transformation at Yahoo Foiled by Its Leader’s Inability ... by iaw on Thursday December 03, 2015 @11:12AM (#10670354)
So why was step 1 canceling the policy and not eliminating the dead weight? I stand by my earlier statement: the WFH policy should never have been cut and it sent a horrible signal to potential employees. Why didn't she hold accountable both the shirking employees and their managers who let them get to that point?

She made a knee-jerk reaction and it was a bad call. I think all she had to do was take the actions you describe as her 'next step.' She may be better than those before her but that didn't allow her to succeed.

Re:Transformation at Yahoo Foiled by Its Leader’s Inability ... by discardorama on Friday December 04, 2015 @12:56AM (#10674921)
Just to put it in perspective: I have since moved on, and then moved on again. In both the post-Yahoo companies, the WFH policy is basically the same as that at Yahoo under Marissa. She just brought it in line with the rest of the companies in the valley.

As far as potential employees go: in my 14 years of interviewing in the Bay Area, I have never, ever been asked about the work-from-home policy. That should tell you how little an impact it has.

Re:Transformation at Yahoo Foiled by Its Leader’s Inability ... by x0x0 on Thursday December 03, 2015 @08:49PM (#10674096)
Yup.

It may be on any given day you can do your work locally on your laptop, but if you work remotely and never or rarely sign into the vpn, a manager should be empowered to ask why not. And if no reasonable answer is forthcoming, terminate you for cause.

Instead, she punished lots of people because some of them were bad employees; I think she got the rep she deserves.

Re:Transformation at Yahoo Foiled by Its Leader’s Inability ... by ekanes on Thursday December 03, 2015 @12:04PM (#10670699)
Banning working from home was still the wrong move. It showed that they weren't assessing people on performance. If they were, they'd have simply fired those folks who were underperforming (and as you point out, spoken to their managers as well.) Banning working from home without realizing also the probable PR/culture cost is yet another mistake.
Re:Transformation at Yahoo Foiled by Its Leader’s Inability ... by greyman on Thursday December 03, 2015 @08:02AM (#10669311)
But wasn't that move following her observation, that (some of those) work from home people just haven't work?
Re:Transformation at Yahoo Foiled by Its Leader’s Inability ... by humanrebar on Thursday December 03, 2015 @08:19AM (#10669380)
That might have been a machete approach to a problem more appropriate for a few dozen scalpels.

Maybe Yahoo didn't have time to sort through all those cases, but it shouldn't be surprised that:

1. Yahoo might have pushed out many people who didn't deserve it. Many of them are working parents and perhaps people with disabilities.

2. Yahoo might have pushed out "cheaters" without really telling them why, leaving them disgruntled about work-from-home policies instead of embarrassed that they were caught not doing their jobs.

3. Yahoo singled out a certain category of "cheaters" unfairly. I'll bet $5000 that there were at least twenty always-at-their-desks Yahoo employees who "wasted" a significant amount of time on HN, facebook, reddit, Yahoo video, or just talking about hobbies and sports with coworkers. Taking the ax to at-home slackers and ignoring the general slacker problem is slightly unfair. It doesn't project communication and transparency; it teaches employees to hide their routine from their bosses as much as possible.

Re:Transformation at Yahoo Foiled by Its Leader’s Inability ... by 67726e on Thursday December 03, 2015 @08:16AM (#10669369)
My old boss had a very relevant point about why the company would fire folks as they did. If you have a guy on your team who usually doesn't work enough or comes late and leaves early you can fire him, or put up aa time clock, but the second you put up that time clock you've just alienated all the other good employees who didn't need babysitting. If people abuse the system, fire them and don't punish the loyal and hardworking. Mass punishment may work in the military, but this is the private sector and I have options.
Re:Transformation at Yahoo Foiled by Its Leader’s Inability ... by ZanyProgrammer on Thursday December 03, 2015 @09:46AM (#10669789)
Mass punishment is also pretty shitty in the military.
Re:Transformation at Yahoo Foiled by Its Leader’s Inability ... by pc86 on Thursday December 03, 2015 @10:30AM (#10670057)
It's much different though in that the goal to get the group to a point where it is self-correcting (e.g. of new troops).
Re:Transformation at Yahoo Foiled by Its Leader’s Inability ... by iaw on Thursday December 03, 2015 @08:12AM (#10669355)
Yes and no. The stated objective was to improve collaboration in "hallway and cafeteria" discussions [1]. Privately, former Yahoo employees said that the policy led to "people slacking off like crazy, not being available, and spending a lot of time on non-Yahoo projects," which is a problem with the management of employees not the policy itself.

If someone is working from home and not meeting their duties they should be fired. Eliminating the policy was a band-aid, having hard conversations and getting rid of the slackers (and their managers) would have been the cure.

[1] http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/02/26/us-workplace-flexi...

Re:Transformation at Yahoo Foiled by Its Leader’s Inability ... by ryanfitz on Thursday December 03, 2015 @08:13AM (#10669361)
I bet if she scanned the work from office people she would also find people who just don't work.
Re:Transformation at Yahoo Foiled by Its Leader’s Inability ... by iaw on Thursday December 03, 2015 @08:19AM (#10669383)
At one horrible startup I worked for I would do 3 hours of work and then wait out another 6 hours because of the 9 hour face time expectation. I had high output because I'm good at what I do but they couldn't wrap their heads around not having me there constantly.

I ended up quitting because I was tired of watching my boss browse Facebook and sports blogs all day.

Re:Transformation at Yahoo Foiled by Its Leader’s Inability ... by aswanson on Thursday December 03, 2015 @10:36AM (#10670098)
Guessing they didn't get a good exit?
Re:Transformation at Yahoo Foiled by Its Leader’s Inability ... by iaw on Thursday December 03, 2015 @11:07AM (#10670323)
Before I got there they rolled the dice and walked away from a $250MM acquisition offer and ousted their original CEO. They were somehow able to acquire additional funding before I left but, based on the numbers I saw, they were using questionable models to indicate that they were more profitable than they are.

They still exist and will probably take another 18 months to wither and die. The experience taught me to look hard for red flags and to hold my company as accountable as myself.

Re:Transformation at Yahoo Foiled by Its Leader’s Inability ... by aswanson on Thursday December 03, 2015 @12:00PM (#10670676)
Absolutely, you are as much of a business as your employer.
Re:Transformation at Yahoo Foiled by Its Leader’s Inability ... by snowwrestler on Friday December 04, 2015 @12:51PM (#10677819)
I'm a parent. "Working from home," if the kids are also in the home without supplemental childcare, is bullshit. It is impossible to parent children and do good technical work at the same time.

You know how folks complain about open office plans? Because of the distracting noise and potential for interruptions? Well imagine an open office with coworkers who have no sense of social tact, cannot take care of themselves, and have a constant deep need for your attention. That's what it is like for a parent to work at home and parent their kids at the same time.

So when I hear that parents at Yahoo were using "work at home" as a substitute for childcare, I think that Yahoo did the right thing by cancelling the policy. That is pretty clear abuse of it.