>And it's a prisoner's dilemma. If you try to be respectful and thoughtful and the other person screams and yells and abuses and strawmans then you will lose the 'debate' by any metric not implemented by a philosophy professor.
Absolutely, and it's one of the most frustrating things I think a lot of reasonable, polite people come up against.
Well, if you're going to advocate that everybody just believe whatever they want without facts or reason, don't be surprised if people tl;dr your comment and ignore you.
Take the high road, will ya
> Some positions are simply not worth discussing thoughtfully
Like yours? Very humble.
> there's no use respecting that view, it's far too extreme
ideals, you should know what those are
Who decides which is which? I guess you?
It's bullshit to expect that people will seriously consider all ideas out there, no matter how weird or outright stupid they sound.
This is a classic trap. Some positions are simply not worth discussing thoughtfully. Not all positions are equal. When you say "both sides" you have already lost; plenty of people use this tendancy to give both sides to every issue equal credence and carefully consider both, so they inject some absurd ridiculous view as the other side and abuse your tendancy to respect them to gain credence for it. Then the overton window is shifted and they have already won before the debate begins. If you even accept the premise that a student should be able to tell a professor what they are and are not allowed to discuss in their class you have already lost the debate, there's no use respecting that view, it's far too extreme.