The vast majority of homicides (which the DOJ data excludes) committed against whites are committed by whites, and the vast majority against blacks are committed by blacks. The number of cross-racial homicides are an order of magnitude less in either direction. Don't take my word for it, look at the diagonal at the top left of this table:
https://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/crime-in-the-u.s/2013/...
According the DOJ data you posted, 44% of the victims of white offenders are not white. Should they all be terrified of white people? Probably not.
So the situation in the data is more complicated than the white supremacists would care to admit.
But more importantly, people's perception of safety is not a direct reflection of the data, but instead, a reflection of the way the data is presented, either by the mass media, or by choose-your-own-agenda websites like the kind you linked.
It also tends to be heavily skewed for the local crime situation in which they live, rather than national crime stats.
Where did I advocate that anyone should be terrified? This is what I said about such fears: "his feelings are completely irrational and entirely his problem."
Of course, as it relates to my original post, the only relevant fact is that indeed there is something happening that a white male might have reason to feel irrational fear of. (The table shows that most crime is intra-racial, not inter-racial)
Let me remind you of the original point: various people are feeling irrationally large amounts of fear but that fear is of a real thing (either historical, as in maaku's case, or real but exaggerated things in the case I described).
I think there are fairly straightforward explanations, simply deducing from books I've read about urban crime... Most crime is intra-racial because it occurs between people who know each other or live near each other and tends to be concentrated in areas of poverty which tend to be demographically homogeneous. Overall, blacks commit crimes at higher rates than whites, which partially correlates with higher poverty rates, but it's not distributed equally because it's also highly concentrated among small numbers of urban street gangs/groups who commit enormous amounts of crime (of which there's no poor white rural counterpart). These groups are mostly surrounded by blacks, so most of their victims will be black, but there are enough whites near them that the whites who are victims of these groups contribute to the black-on-white numbers being higher. Part of the irrationality and bigotry comes from interpreting these numbers as some kind of targeting going on specifically to whites because there's no reverse equivalent instead of understanding that it actually comes from an urban dynamic that overall causes black victims to suffer even more than whites.
* statistics are often counter-intuitive,
* they are easy to manipulate or misinterpret,
* manipulation requires significant effort to discover,
* they are sometimes correct in form but the data is biased,
* bias in the data might have been mentioned by the initial data collectors but the analyzers may omit it (either intentionally or accidentally).
Government statistics may not always be perfect, but are you implying that the government is guilty of purposefully manipulating data? Why?
And detecting an arithmetic error would require significant effort. I'd have to open up ipython, copy&pasting the numbers, remove the commas and other formatting, and then press enter.
Um, ok.
If there are twice as many whites as blacks or 10 times as many whites as blacks would vastly change how your figure could be interpreted.
Note that I linked to it for the content of the first data table. My link is not an endorsement of every single viewpoint that someone at that URL might hold - I actually just spent 2 minutes googling for a fact I had seen before and pasted the first link that had the data table.
You want to compare black on white crimes to white on black crimes. Not white on white crimes.
Across all races - they primarily commit crime against their own race. But some races receive more crime than they give.
Adjusted for population (there are far more white people than black people) there should be about equal white on black crime as black on white crime per capita. That isn't the case and is precisely what the data reads.
What is important isn't to jump to conclusions but rather investigate why. Which nobody wants to do unless they get labeled as a racist.
In reality, we have no practical way of doing this. So, whenever we cite a source of data, we are implicitly saying "This is a credible source for the statement is making. You can trust that they have done the work to make sure they aren't just repeating their own biases." And in the case of some organizations and people, you actually cannot say that.
If the American milk board makes a claim about the health benefits of milk, it is not a fallacy to be skeptical of that claim.
Besides, often times the source isn't really the source. For example, if a publicly devout racist quoted FBI crime statistics, does that mean we can ignore the data because we heard it from the racist and not the FBI?
Let me introduce you to data science. First I'll read the numnbers in row 2 column 2 and row 2 column 5. Then I'll plug them into ipython:
$ ipython
...
In [4]: 4091971*0.137
Out[4]: 560600.027
Do the same for row 3 col 2 and row 3 col 4: In [6]: 955800 * 0.104
Out[6]: 99403.2
Looks like the article was right after all.Whew, that was hard. Took all the skills I learned in my math Ph.D. to finish the job. Just lucky I didn't have to break out Hadoop. If I wasn't a professional statistician I wouldn't have had a prayer.
Data science would be trying to find out why and putting it into context, especially if there are variables in play that aren't shown by a cursory look. Which a white supremacist has little interest in.
It's a self-feeding loop.
A white supremacist doing a statistical analysis isn't going to reach all that hard for stats that might contradict or weaken the conclusion they're trying for. If they find one accidentally, there's a pretty decent chance they'll "forget" to mention it.
I'm no expert in the field, but I'd wonder about things like encounter rates for the different populations, varying access to social services, things like lead paint being more prevalent in inner city housing, etc.
I claimed a white male might feel irrational fear of the disproportionately large number of black on white crimes, just as maaku claimed a black person might feel irrational fear of crimes that happened a few generations back.
I linked to a source showing that the number of black on white crimes is disproportionately large. Perhaps this white supremacist organization did make arithmetic errors when multiplying row 2 column 2 by row 2 column 5. Did they?
It's a bit surprising that with all this criticism, no one is actually claiming the number is wrong.
...(eyes roll). Anyway, on a completely different taboo topic, I wonder if you've read the Unabomber's manifesto...
https://archive.org/stream/IndustrialSocietyAndItsFuture-The...
Please, I would like to understand your logic.
I do find it a bit scary that when I google "black on white crime", only racist sites show up. Why are only white supremacists willing to discuss this data? (Or perhaps they are all just super good at SEO.)