News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ideas are not cheap by chippy on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @06:23AM (#10654621)
If the vast majority of ideas are bad and only a few ideas are good - this leads us to think about a market of ideas. Generally then the market is awash with ideas - this makes ideas cheap as there is plentiful supply. The only way to determine the value of the idea is to enact, to invest in the idea - but before this, when the ideas are on their own, they are cheap and plentiful and most will be lemons.

This is why I still believe that not telling anyone about your idea is likely to be a bad thing - stealth mode in general is not wise at the early stage before enactment. Why? Because most times these ideas are not worth much and you would benefit from the feedback from seeing how that idea fares in the public domain. This doesn't invalidate the authors very good summary of how to find a good idea - and I don't think the article was necessarily saying that ideas should be kept secret all the time either - it's just a related thought!

Re:Ideas are not cheap by ThomPete on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @08:57AM (#10655290)
I would like to offer a different perspective to this.

Instead of thinking of ideas as cheap, think of them as fragile. Most ideas wont stand up to even preliminary scrutiny.

Great ideas aren't Eureka moments that come from nothing and suddenly appear in front of us.

Most of them are vague intuitions, about some potential for something to be created and then over time grow to manifest themselves. Over time they become stronger as they are nourished and cared for and defended until they are what we call great ideas.

But here is the thing. You never know which idea has the potential to become something big. So the trick IMO is to care for ideas early on, to protect them and see if they can survive the ever present scrutiny from the reality they need to exist in by protecting them.

Ideas aren't cheap they are the most important thing humans have and we should learn how to nourish the good ones and dispel of the bad ones. Just like we do with our children.

Re:Ideas are not cheap by bsbechtel on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @11:14AM (#10656457)
>>Great ideas aren't Eureka moments that come from nothing and suddenly appear in front of us.

Furthermore, many great companies (and one great idea) aren't Eureka moments, but the accumulation of hundreds of smaller, good ideas, brought about by great people, combining to become what appears to be one simple, grand idea to outsiders.

Re:Ideas are not cheap by ThomPete on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @11:25AM (#10656571)
Exactly. Even Pixar movies follow this approach.

And so the trick is to not just throw an idea out because it doesn't stand up to some immediate scrutiny, but to try and defend it just a little bit more than you would normally do.

Most great ideas start out as really bad ones.

Re:Ideas are not cheap by danieltillett on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @04:14PM (#10658825)
I wouldn't say most good ideas start out bad, but most do start out with major weaknesses or gaps. This is why I emphasise in my essay the importance of writing down your ideas and thinking about them often. It may take years and lots of evolution before an idea becomes really good.
Re:Ideas are not cheap by ThomPete on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @04:46PM (#10659062)
What I mean is that good ideas don't look like good ideas. The checklist you provide is a good way of validating them but even getting to the point were you want to validate them is a whole book worth.

That is why I am never afraid of sharing mine with anyone. If they are really good most people (including myself) wont see it and I would probably have to shovel it down their throats for them to even take them a little bit serious.

Great essay btw!

Re:Ideas are not cheap by danieltillett on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @05:37PM (#10659423)
Thanks.

Yes there is so much more that could be written about this topic, but you have to stop somewhere.

As I mention in the essay I have never had an idea stolen, only the credit once proven. The only issue I have with telling people my ideas is that nobody is interested [1] - it is viewed as similar to talking about your children - nobody cares how smart/talented/funny/charming your children are and they most certainly don’t want to hear about them from you.

1. If anyone has any ideas that hit 10 or more on my list I am very interested in hearing about it, but I won’t promise to not steal it from you :)

Re:Ideas are not cheap by bsbechtel on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @08:05AM (#10654986)
Many investors, including YC, have a number of companies that operate in stealth mode until launch. It would be an interesting exercise to map the success of startups that operate in stealth mode pre-launch vs those that don't.
Re:Ideas are not cheap by danieltillett on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @08:09AM (#10655013)
It certainly would. The mere fact that stealth mode exists is an indication that serious people value good ideas.
Re:Ideas are not cheap by FiatLuxDave on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @12:08PM (#10656976)
Former stealth moder here.

I really liked your essay and I appreciate that someone is pushing back against the 'ideas are cheap' meme. I think you were really smart to make the first item be that an idea which you cannot execute is a bad idea for a startup.

However, I think that your essay left out one really important thing: what people mean when they say 'idea'. It's helpful to unwrap what we mean when we say 'idea' so that we can distinguish between the two different cases of value: 'it's only an idea' vs. 'an idea that can change the world'. I think that the disconnect between the 'ideas are cheap' crowd and the 'ideas are valuable' crowd is that they don't mean exactly the same thing when they say 'idea'. And knowing the difference not only means that you can speak someone else's language, it also means that you can see how to add value to your ideas.

Whether it is a business idea, product idea, or invention idea, the level of vagueness affects how much value it has. There is a difference between 1) an idea for a product, 2) an idea for the basis of how it works, and 3) a complete set of code or blueprints for making one. 'Execution' is largely what we call going from step 2 to 3, but both step 1 and step 2 get called ideas. Even step 2.5, where something is not fully executed but the details have been worked out, gets called an idea.

I'd love to see more about how adding specificity adds value, but only if it is correct. Taking a great idea (say, the diesel engine) and making a poor implementation of it (building a really crappy diesel engine) doesn't take value away from the earlier steps of the idea (someone else can build a better one). So, ideas start with little value, but get more value as more correct specificity is added.

Re:Ideas are not cheap by danieltillett on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @04:07PM (#10658767)
Thanks.

I did avoid getting into a definition of what I think an idea is mainly because I wanted the essay to be a catalyst for people to think about their own ideas, not just be another rant.

I like to think of ideas and execution as potential and kinetic energy. A great idea is a bolder at the top of a hill, while a bad idea is a bolder at the bottom. Execution is the process of keeping the bolder moving.

Re:Ideas are not cheap by skewart on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @09:09AM (#10655383)
Perhaps. Although, stealth mode isn't necessarily driven by a fear of copycats. In many cases it's about hiding the fact that a company doesn't entirely know what they're doing while they try to figure things out. This seems to be especially common in B2B markets where there are a relatively small number of potential customers (though each one might pay a lot for the statup's product), and almost all of these customers are likely to learn about the startup very quickly.

The stealth mode startup isn't really keeping their ideas secret from potential competitors but rather from potential customers. They want to avoid customers getting confused, being turned off, or losing trust if they were too transparent about what they're working on - and how much its changing - before they're ready to launch.

Re:Ideas are not cheap by jacquesm on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @09:17AM (#10655427)
Stealth mode is a way to to focus on what's important: get the product finished, rather than to have to deal with the outside world. It rarely if ever has to do with keeping the idea secret. First mover advantage is worth protecting too, as well as a change of direction in case your great idea does not work out after more time is invested in implementing it or if you realize there are even greener pastures.

Stealth mode - and secrecy in general - is a tool, but the day you open the doors to your first users the competition will be able to look at what you've made and then the clock to locking up the market is ticking.

This is extra important when it comes to ideas that have network effects.

Re:Ideas are not cheap by danieltillett on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @09:41AM (#10655623)
Isn't what you are protecting in this case the idea? If you just want to focus on building the product you don't need to be in stealth mode. It is only if you are worried about some exploiting your idea do you keep quiet.
Re:Ideas are not cheap by jacquesm on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @09:46AM (#10655647)
It is fairly safe to assume that if you have an idea, so do others. But idea+validation: that's already another step. So you try to protect that combination to stave off the inevitable Samwer brothers clone. And even then, the first three weeks out of the gate had better be longer than it takes to get a clone MVP up and running.
Re:Ideas are not cheap by danieltillett on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @10:04AM (#10655789)
A product that can be cloned in three weeks is not a great product. I thought the samwer brothers just cloned successful companies that already proven in the market?
Re:Ideas are not cheap by jacquesm on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @10:12AM (#10655854)
> I thought the samwer brothers just cloned successful companies that already proven in the market?

Yes, because those are the valuable ideas. From their point of view spending time on unproven ideas is a waste, it is much easier to copy a successful company for a niche market than it is to come up with an entirely new concept for a much broader one.

Re:Ideas are not cheap by pc86 on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @09:12AM (#10655396)
It is an indication that they value first mover advantage. It has nothing to do with the value of ideas.
Re:Ideas are not cheap by danieltillett on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @09:37AM (#10655599)
Aren't they valuing the idea in this case? If they thought there was no risk of someone stealing the idea then why keep it quiet?
Re:Ideas are not cheap by pc86 on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @10:18AM (#10655909)
> If they thought there was no risk of someone stealing the idea

I didn't say that. In fact, I said the opposite - they acknowledge there is a risk in someone stealing the advantage of being first to market, irrespective of the idea itself.

Being first to market on a mediocre idea with good execution is an order of magnitude better than being fifth to market on a great idea with good execution.

Re:Ideas are not cheap by danieltillett on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @04:21PM (#10658872)
I am not so sure being first with a mediocre idea is better than coming to market latter with a great idea. Mediocre ideas increase the chance of failure, but more importanty no idea that is being executed on by four others before you is a truely good idea.
Re:Ideas are not cheap by danieltillett on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @06:33AM (#10654633)
Yes the market is awash with idea - ideas that are just OK or so-so - very few are a really, really good. The problem is as always telling the truly good ideas from the just good. Having a good checklist is one way I think.

I am most defiantly not saying that truly good ideas should be kept secret, but I am saying they have true intrinsic value. Sometimes this value can be best utilised by sharing widely and sometime is best utilised by keeping quiet. The important thing is knowing when it is best to stay quiet and best to talk.

Re:Ideas are not cheap by dkersten on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @06:57AM (#10654707)
A lot of fantastically great ideas seemed like terrible ideas until they were executed. That is why a lot of people say that ideas are cheap, execution is what has value.
Re:Ideas are not cheap by eitally on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @07:41AM (#10654880)
And honestly, a lot of ideas were terrible until they were executed. It was only through the process of exploration & execution that a practical use or market emerged & evolved from the original spark.
Re:Ideas are not cheap by danieltillett on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @07:57AM (#10654940)
This is not such a great approach to take if you have limited resources. Sure you might get lucky and find a great idea (ala AirBnB) even though your first idea is not great, but it is not the optimal way to proceed. I would much rather start with a good idea that I try to make better, than a terrible idea I have to figure out how to pivot into a good idea.
Re:Ideas are not cheap by jamesrcole on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @08:05AM (#10654993)
I think there is a massive difference between your own judgement of an idea and others' judgement of it.

The latter has to go through difficulties in expressing the idea and the justification of it, and in the understanding, by a different person, of those details.

I think the "ideas are cheap" / "good ideas seemed terrible" thing is mostly from the perspective of other people.

If that's true then individuals shouldn't take it too seriously when it comes to their own ideas.

Re:Ideas are not cheap by danieltillett on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @07:09AM (#10654752)
This is true, the key is seeming like a terrible idea, not actually being a terrible idea.

A good idea does not have to appear to be good after 15 seconds, in fact, it is probably a warning sign if everyone thinks your idea is good straight away as then it is likely that someone else has had it and is working on it, or there is some fundamental flaw that you have missed.

Execution most defiantly is critical, but the quality of the idea make execution much easier. The purpose of my post was not to downplay the importance of execution, but to touch on the value of truly good ideas and more importantly how you might find them and recognise them.

Re:Ideas are not cheap by shubhamjain on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @08:05AM (#10654992)
> A good idea does not have to appear to be good after 15 seconds, in fact, it is probably a warning sign if everyone thinks your idea is good straight away as then it is likely that someone else has had it and is working on it, or there is some fundamental flaw that you have missed.

Have you ever been in a class where you feel lucky when someone asked a question which you felt too embarrassed to ask? There is a class of products, which would feel immediately useful but no one feels like building them.

For eg, Errorception[1] was probably the first Javascript error tracking product made. I could guess people before this tested manually on all browsers or had a custom front-end tracking solution. As a product, it felt immediately useful, one more headache resolved but it took till 2011 for the product to get made although the problem was always there.

Of course, products like these won't make billion dollar companies but definitely be useful to large number of people.

[1]: https://errorception.com

Re:Ideas are not cheap by mattlutze on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @07:23AM (#10654797)
Except that one of the hallmarks of a really good or great idea is that almost anyone you tell it to says "oh, of course, it's so simple."

But you need a big enough sample size to know it's not friendship-bias from your trusted confidants and some crazy guy with money one of your college buddies knows.

Leading us back to execution...

Re:Ideas are not cheap by danieltillett on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @07:29AM (#10654827)
I do address this in my post. One of the hallmarks of a good idea is one that is simple to explain, but hard to think of for the first time. These idea have the advantage of removing competition, but lowering the barrier to acceptance. They are of course rare.
Re:Ideas are not cheap by mattlutze on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @07:40AM (#10654877)
I was responding particularly to:

> it is probably a warning sign if everyone thinks your idea is good straight away as then it is likely that someone else has had it and is working on it, or there is some fundamental flaw that you have missed.

I can't get to the original at the moment so my comment is specific to this comment thread's context.

I'll just leave my favorite economics joke:

Two economists were walking down the sidewalk discussing their recent research when one looks down and sees a $20 bill.

"Look, a $20!" says one, slowing to bend down and retrieve it.

"Impossible," replied the second, stopping the first mid-bend, "if there was a $20 bill on the ground, someone would have already found it and picked it up."

Re:Ideas are not cheap by danieltillett on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @08:05AM (#10654988)
It is just a warning sign that you should be careful - I have picked up many a $20 bill off the street by being aware - both literately and metaphorically.

On this topic I found a wallet once with over $1000 in cash in it which I gave back to the owner. He could not believe that I would do such a thing, but the personal value it gave me doing this was worth much more than any monetary value I could have got from spending the money. Maybe I am an idiot :)

Re:Ideas are not cheap by dkersten on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @07:25AM (#10654813)
Sure, I agree with you. I think PG said that how good the idea is, is a value multiplier. I think the problem is when people believe that ideas, on their own, have inherent value.

But (100 idea) * (0 execution) is still = 0

The reverse is also true, however: (0 idea) * (100 execution) is also 0

I think maybe what I believe (and many people believe) is that execution is weighted higher than idea, but that doesn't mean that idea has no value at all - just not so much that it is usually more important to execute well than worry about the perfect idea. Also, most people have many ideas, so if one fails or turns out to be bad, its not such a big deal and can be fixed.

Finally, we have the "ideas people" who bring little to the table but the idea. I would argue that these ideas have close to no value unless the person can augment it with something else of value too.

Re:Ideas are not cheap by danieltillett on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @07:34AM (#10654846)
Yes the quality of an idea is a multiplier - I like to the think of execution as the multiplier of the idea given good ideas are rarer than good execution, but this is just personal preference.

Good ideas do have intrinsic value, because if you tell me a truly good idea I will steal it from you. If you have any idea that ticks 10 or more points from my list please send me an email telling me all about it :)

Re:Ideas are not cheap by dkersten on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @07:41AM (#10654881)
Hmm. Maybe. (re: execution being the multiplier) I'm not completely convinced either way, I guess.

if you tell me a truly good idea I will steal it from you

I think perhaps most people don't have a list, like you do (even unofficially in their heads). Most people are too busy with their own ideas to bother with others, even if they really are great. I suppose if you have a criteria for measuring the quality of the idea, as you do, then you can make objective decisions about an idea based on its actual merits (as defined by your criteria) rather than gut feeling or wanting to work on your own stuff.

I suppose what I'm saying is that most ideas are cheap because most people don't have a good way of objectively measuring their value beyond executing and seeing how it goes.

Note though that I've usually heard it as "ideas are cheap", not "ideas have no value" -- despite what I might have said in my previous comments :D

Re:Ideas are not cheap by danieltillett on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @08:00AM (#10654953)
Yes I think if I have anything of value to contribute to this topic it is not my criteria of what is a good idea or not, but the idea of having some sort of objective list of your own. I would encourage everyone to put together their own list as just the process of doing this is highly valuable. In doing so you start to question your own assumptions and work out what is important to you.
Re:Ideas are not cheap by marcosdumay on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @08:41AM (#10655190)
> execution is weighted higher than idea

What does "weight" means in a multiplicative combination?

(3a) b = a * (3b) = 3 a * b

Re:Ideas are not cheap by dkersten on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @10:54AM (#10656247)
I simply meant that "one point of idea quality" != one point of execution quality, but since its all made up abstract stuff anyway, I suppose all I meant is that a "good idea" has a different value than "good execution" (some people say more, some people say less).
Re:Ideas are not cheap by marcosdumay on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @11:01AM (#10656314)
I got that, I was nitpicking about the formula, but not too much. I still have a point to make (and did communicate it badly).

What I don't get is any relation between "point of idea quality" and "point of execution quality" that could survive a second of thought. This is too much like mixing different unities, that are ok to multiply but not to compare at face value.

I don't see how "execution is worth more than idea", or the other way around, or anything in between could ever make sense.

Re:Ideas are not cheap by dkersten on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @08:22PM (#10660221)
You're probably right. I haven't really thought about it that much, I'm just trying to articulate how I understand what I've heard.

I personally think that perhaps good ideas without execution have little value, but execution without good ideas probably has equally little value.

I say this because I've experienced cases where I had an idea that I thought was good, but did nothing about, only to (later) find somebody else who did the exact idea I had in exactly the way I would have. Clearly the idea had value for that person, but not for me - but the only difference is execution.

Re:Ideas are not cheap by mattlutze on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @07:28AM (#10654826)
Good Ideas that get tested will make money and mature with feedback.

Truly Great Ideas hidden away rely on you (and your confidants) alone to mature, grow, and test.

Perhaps part of that intrinsic value in a Truly Great Idea is the debt you start to incur working the Great Idea before it's ever given a chance to prove itself.

There's a bunch of discussion about this [0][1][2][3], but it comes down to the cost of opportunity and the drive to spend that effort and resources. You've had your idea, already bought into it, and have the history around the idea that will drive implementation and innovation.

Probably no one else you tell it to has that. And anyone else that wants to work on some awesome new startup is already circling their own fantastic(TM) idea.

So share! Get feedback from smart people who will help shortcut the path to takeoff for your idea. Because if someone has a good idea in the same vein as your great idea and executes, how long until your great idea is yet another "that could have been me"?

0: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4732684

1: https://beacon.wharton.upenn.edu/entrepreneurship/2015/02/no...

2: https://open.buffer.com/one-will-steal-startup-idea/

3: https://www.google.com/search?q=no+one+is+going+to+steal+you...

Re:Ideas are not cheap by marklgr on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @07:01AM (#10654717)
> The problem is as always telling the truly good ideas from the just good.

Not only telling the difference, but defining it. The difficulty is avoiding post hoc evaluation, ie. the idea that looks very good in hindsight because it succeeded and the great implementation makes it look compelling.

Re:Ideas are not cheap by danieltillett on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @07:12AM (#10654765)
This is why it is great to have some sort of checklist of your own on which to judge the quality of your ideas.

Just putting together such a checklist has enormous value as you start to question all your assumptions about what a good idea must have - it is not “this sounds cool lets go”.