News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ideas are not cheap by marcosdumay on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @08:41AM (#10655190)
> execution is weighted higher than idea

What does "weight" means in a multiplicative combination?

(3a) b = a * (3b) = 3 a * b

Re:Ideas are not cheap by dkersten on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @10:54AM (#10656247)
I simply meant that "one point of idea quality" != one point of execution quality, but since its all made up abstract stuff anyway, I suppose all I meant is that a "good idea" has a different value than "good execution" (some people say more, some people say less).
Re:Ideas are not cheap by marcosdumay on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @11:01AM (#10656314)
I got that, I was nitpicking about the formula, but not too much. I still have a point to make (and did communicate it badly).

What I don't get is any relation between "point of idea quality" and "point of execution quality" that could survive a second of thought. This is too much like mixing different unities, that are ok to multiply but not to compare at face value.

I don't see how "execution is worth more than idea", or the other way around, or anything in between could ever make sense.

Re:Ideas are not cheap by dkersten on Tuesday December 01, 2015 @08:22PM (#10660221)
You're probably right. I haven't really thought about it that much, I'm just trying to articulate how I understand what I've heard.

I personally think that perhaps good ideas without execution have little value, but execution without good ideas probably has equally little value.

I say this because I've experienced cases where I had an idea that I thought was good, but did nothing about, only to (later) find somebody else who did the exact idea I had in exactly the way I would have. Clearly the idea had value for that person, but not for me - but the only difference is execution.