Other weeks she would get a panic attack and cry herself to sleep because she'd had to get a flat tire fixed for $20, and she knew it would all come crashing down at the end of the pay period and she'd be $20 short.
I'm not saying her poor choices didn't get her there, I'm just saying that for lots of people, $20 can run their life.
A few years back there was a case against one of the big banks over structuring transactions on the same day - the bank was doing them largest to smallest, with the end result that people were being hit with multiple overdraft fees in one day. If you had enough for 3 of 4 bills but would be $100 short on the largest, the bank would pay the big one, then the second largest, then either cover or bounce the last two while charging an overdraft fee for each. At the end of the day instead of being $100 short you were $200 sorry with extra fees.
There are two major benefits.
- more control. You can choose to delay paying a specific bill to make sure more important bills get paid on time.
- safety. You'll never find yourself trying to get money back from a company that you're having a dispute with.
I used to allow it, and I ran into the second issue. It's the reason why I made that decision years ago, and I don't regret it one bit. It takes all of 1-2 hours/month to get all my bills paid.
The first point (control) is more for the post I was responding to, however.
Those in a better financial situation could avoid the stress by jumping ship when trouble first arose (i.e. it wouldn't be jumping out of the pot and into the fire).
Which I don't completely disagree with. At certain cross-cutting cleavages, one can reasonably say that it is the people in a toxic environment who perpetuate the toxicity than most other influences (not combined)[1]
Two problems, however, with redefining social class to be based upon "thinking" is that it neglects causality of said thinking, and, worse, fabulates "just so" stories.
The first problem can be phrased as: are my poor friends bad at managing their socioeconomic lives because they don't have the same values or abilities as I, or is it because they're too exhausted by their daily drudgeries to invest the time and effort to climb the ladders of advancement? Do I have more natural talent and skills which align with market needs than my fellow? Perhaps a bit of both for the first question, and yes, probably, for the second.
The second problem with that perspective is that it essentially boils down to: "The poor think poorly therefore they are poor.", "The middle class thinks good therefore they are the middle class." and, of course, "the upper class think amazingly therefore they are upper class." One can argue that poor thinking will lead them to make unwise decisions that will sap their financial strength[2]. But not always: what goes on in the head doesn't necessarily always changes the number of zeros in a bank account. [3]
While I agree an individual ought not to be not foolish with their assets, other factors like environment must be included in analysis to know why some succeed and most flounder. Conflating class with intelligence, i.e. a way of thinking being the main criteria for class, is more or less an opinion page of the Wall Street Journal and not a good start for analyzing how to better social mobility.
[1] Pakistan is a good example of people perpetuating toxicity. Context: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9642488 and direct link: https://www.quora.com/Does-the-average-Pakistani-support-the...
[2] In a rigged system, I would say that poor thinking by an upper class person could paradoxically help them ascend to even greater heights. For example: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/on-leadership/wp/2014/03.... For a better and more topical example: http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2015/09/donald-trump-...
[3] http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/01/28/money-and-class/...
The idea that any significant percentage of poor are poor because they are not prudent does not hold.
And even if it did, it's way easier to be "prudent" when you have a basic income that covers your needs and leaves a little or a lot more to be prudent with, than when you go hand to mouth with every paycheck.
It holds pretty well.
There is no contradiction in billions of people being not prudent.
It's easily achievable with poor culture dominating in the whole society.
That's in theory -- we're talking about reality. If you think poor people in India, Asia, Africa etc. are poor because they are not "prudent" or because "poor culture" dominates the whole society you probably haven't met many in real life -- hardworking, pinching pennies and raising families on a handful of dollars a month.
It's easy for people playing life in easy-mode to condemn the poor's "lack of prudence" from a first world middle/upper class existence, where prudence means not buying a new car every 3 years.
For example, if your culture allows lies and corruption from elected politicians, you are likely to create suboptimal environment around you.
My friends in Russia make that silly choice - they support lying corrupt politicians in favor of pleasing their nationalistic feelings.
Guess what - they lowered their income ~2x just by that.
People who've been handed everything often don't prepare for the future.
People who understand the magic of compound interest are more likely to be savers.
People who've grown up with the government punishing savers, not so much. Perhaps they even think those who save are weird or outliers.
So, yes in many ways it's relative. But additionally persevering is better than succumbing to circumstance.
There are many ways to get completely fucked over even if your wealthy. Money acts as an insulating factor, but if your lucky you don't need healthcare, or tutoring etc.
The thing is when you look at the bottom 2,000,000,000 people you end up with some real outliers. If they all got 1 megga million ticket per year then in a decade you end up with 77 winners. Sure, it's a terrible use of money, but you don't learn much from looking at outliers because your selecting for lucky people. Look at the luckiest 0.1% and you have 2 million people.
Middle class varies beyond recognition depending on which culture you're looking at --- I suspect you're overgeneralising your own. (Weekly paycheques? Laundromats which are cheaper than washing clothes yourself? Neither of those are things where I come from...)
Please stop trying play mind reader. There is no evidence of that by these responses.
You don't understand what middle class is. Middle class is not a specific dollar figure. It's not owning a large TV. Middle class is when you don't have the set of anxieties that cloud your judgement and depress your day.
Middle class means you don't care if your paycheck gets delayed from Friday to Monday. Middle class is when you don't have to count how many times a week you go to the laundromat.
Sadly, middle class, as evidenced by these responses, also means that you don't see why other people would care if their paycheck gets delayed by a business day or two. It's no big deal, you are convinced. Yet, there's a woman that just started working, waiting for her first paycheck, which already had to be delayed due to starting date not aligning with payment schedules. And she has been planning to pay rent with this money, on the promised date. And yet, because some upper-middle-class manager with middle-class myopia forgot to submit everyone's timecards on time (as required by the similarly-myopic corporate policy), everyone's paychecks get delayed by a few days, including this woman's. Now she has to deal with missing paying rent. True story, in modern liberal bastion of Massachusetts.
All you have to do is understand why it's considerably more difficult for someone to improve their life, when starting from a much lower point, constantly being banged around by the ankles of the society.