Re:Earth Might Have Hairy Dark Matter
by musgravepeter on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @07:57AM
(#10626928)
A great book on good physics which did not pan out is http://www.amazon.com/Higher-Speculations-Theories-Revolutio...
Vortex theory was very cool, but not how the world worked.
Re:Earth Might Have Hairy Dark Matter
by wlievens on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @08:23AM
(#10627022)
True, but we've come to seek more than just predictive models, we want understanding and "truth".
I'd say the opposite; we've come to realise that accurate predictions are the truest benchmark and notions of understanding can often be misleading.
But supposing you're right, so what? Unless you'd prefer a more understandable but inaccurate model, there's still no better alternative to dark matter or dark energy.
Re:Earth Might Have Hairy Dark Matter
by TheOtherHobbes on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @09:54AM
(#10627454)
You need deep understanding to develop the next set of accurate models and - perhaps - turn them into useful technology.
Agreed, but I don't think going back to theories that don't explain all current observations is a fruitful path there.
Re:Earth Might Have Hairy Dark Matter
by daveguy on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @08:28AM
(#10627037)
Until you have a better predictive model there's no way to tell what you had before wasn't the "truth".
Re:Earth Might Have Hairy Dark Matter
by yxhuvud on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @09:56AM
(#10627467)
Yes there is. Models can be disproved by empiricism without needing another model.
However, even if a model doesn't work all the time, it doesn't mean it is useless for prediction. Newtons laws is still in use, for example.
Re:Earth Might Have Hairy Dark Matter
by darkmighty on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @01:47PM
(#10628778)
He means the most common definition of truth is 'The best predictive model' (in the scope of the problem). I would add the principle of parsimony, truth is 'The simplest available formulation of the best predictive model'.
In both cases you cannot know that no better predictive models exists (and hence if your truth is absolute), even if you experimental error is zero (which is essentially impossible in most sciences unless you grossly overfit), since there may be unobserved phenomena as well.
Newton's laws weren't disproved, they were just shown to be less general than originally assumed. Quantum theories usually assume Newton's laws to be true axiomatically, otherwise the quantum theory would be under-specified and practically useless.
Re:Earth Might Have Hairy Dark Matter
by bweitzman on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @12:14PM
(#10628201)
Truth is just a sufficiently correct predictive model
Re:Earth Might Have Hairy Dark Matter
by mjburgess on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @07:39AM
(#10626871)
phlogiston was actually better than the theory which immediately replaced it (oxidation, etc.) - they were close to discovering electrons ... but by involving oxygen delayed that realization for quite awhile
So yes, dark matter and dark energy are probably not the full story. But they are the best model we currently have, and it's very easy to criticize and much harder to offer a positive counterproposal.