News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by erdojo on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:42AM (#10626117)
State-sponsored rape. Both the officer and the head of the program should go to jail for this.
Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by fab13n on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:59AM (#10626173)
By calling everything and anything rape, one debases the word's meaning, and the claims of actual rape victims.

Words have meaning, and rape is forcing someone to have sex with you when they don't want to have sex with you. She wanted to have sex with him, although he deceived her about some of his key features.

Is it rape when one discovers afterwards that their partner is a closet alcoholic? No it isn't. What about if they're chronically unfaithful? Neither. If a golddigger has sex with someone who made them falsely believe they were rich, the former hasn't been raped, merely deceived. Even if they're HIV+, it's not rape. It might be poisoning, or homicide attempt, it certainly is awful and punishable, but it's not rape.

Concealing that you're a cop on duty is despicable and might be (at least ought to be) illegal, but rape it isn't; pretending otherwise is unhelpful and insulting to rape victims.

Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by vacri on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:53AM (#10626342)
Concealing who you actually are can be legal rape. There was a case (in NZ, I think) where one brother of a pair of identical twins had sex with the other brother's girlfriend. She had consented to the sex itself, but had thought it was her boyfriend, and the man had wilfully misrepresented himself as his brother.

It's pointless to hang on technicalities though - regardless of whether this is legally 'rape', it is undoubtedly severe emotional trauma.

Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by fab13n on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @06:09AM (#10626586)
> It's pointless to hang on technicalities though

I don't think you'd consider it a mere technicality, if someone called it "murder", or "extortion", or "battery", although all of those are crimes, which generally entail severe emotional trauma. You can stay general and just call it a "crime", if you don't think the specifics are relevant, but it's not a rape.

This sloppy thinking, "it's an hideous deception and it's related to sex, so it must be rape", is the same kind of sloppy thinking that makes citizens accept things they shouldn't, for the sake of "homeland security" or "the war against Terror". So it does matter.

As for "Concealing who you are", if you pick an open / vague interpretation of what "who you are" means, you're creating an awful lot of legal insecurity. How many estranged spouses have you heard describing their ex as "(s)he wasn't the person I though (s)he was"? I've heard that one more than a couple of times. That is no basis for rape accusations.

Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by vacri on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @07:21AM (#10626813)
Rape, fundamentally, is a clear violation of a person's intimate life. That is what happened in the article, sponsored and directed by the state. It wasn't the "oh, they changed over time" story that you're making it out to be. In both the article and my twins comment, the bad actor premeditated the duplicity, and was intentionally dishonest from the start.

The woman in the article has had her intimate life violated, funded and directed by the state, no less. That violation is the essence of rape. Whether or not it fits the relevant legal definition (which varies wildly between jurisdictions), what has happened is functionally the same.

It's just like it doesn't actually matter to the victim who comes home to find their house ransacked, whether the law terms it 'robbery' or 'burglary'. And when the victim says "our house was robbed yesterday", the person who corrects them with "actually, you mean 'burgled'" is missing the point.

Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by YeGoblynQueenne on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:04PM (#10629681)
>> How many estranged spouses have you heard describing their ex as "(s)he wasn't the person I though (s)he was"?

But that's just a metaphor. In this case, he was literally not the person she thought he was.

Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by DanBC on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:45AM (#10626315)
> forcing

No, rape is sex without consent. Force isn't required for something to be rape.

Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by Natanael_L on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @06:14AM (#10626604)
Then this would rather be fraud, because consent was given but based on deceitful information
Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by danlindley on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @09:33AM (#10627319)
Actually, consent for sexual intercourse obtained through lies or deceipt is unequivocally considered rape in common law.
Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by fab13n on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @10:30AM (#10627635)
Can you provide a source?

I'd be surprised if, for instance, seducing someone and getting laid by pretending to be substantially wealthier than you are was considered rape. Even pretending that you aren't a convicted felon when you are one would probably not constitute rape. I'd also be surprised if a woman who lied about being a virgin (and maybe had hymenoplasty) was prosecuted as a rapist by her devout husband.

My guess would be that it's considered rape if the deception made the victim believe they had to have intercourse with the liar. If the lie merely made the liar more desirable, it's (possibly unethical) seduction.

This hypothesis would mean, to come back to the original case, that:

* telling you're not a cop when you actually are one is not rape;

* telling that you're a cop when you aren't, and hitting that a sexual favor would buy you some leniency, does constitute rape.

Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by DanBC on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:04PM (#10629289)
There's several links in this thread to a recent UK case where a woman pretended to be a man, and seduced her friend and had sex with that friend.

http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2015/nov/12/gayle-newland...

There are other coses from different places. A Jewish woman was told by a man that he was also Jewish. They had sex. He was in fact not Jewish, and he was convicted.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/middleeast/israel/...

I think the law is looking at what consent actually means.

Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by danlindley on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @09:19PM (#10630933)
There was a case in Australia where an individual consented to intercourse on the basis that their partner would agree to marry them. Afterwards, when the partner refused to get married and the case was taken to court, the court determined this was rape due to the fact consent was only obtained on the basis that they would then be married.
Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by erdojo on Thursday November 26, 2015 @01:11AM (#10631545)
I'm pretty sure I know the definition of rape at least as well as you if not more so, and I stand by the use of the word in this instance.
Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by nothrabannosir on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:53AM (#10626148)
For the life of me I can't find a link anymore, nor can I remember which western country this was in. Forgive this unsourced story.

A while ago there was a lawsuit: a woman had accused a man of raping her, when she found out he did not have magical healing powers. He had convinced her that sleeping with him would cure her of an ailment she had, and she had believed him.

The judge ruled: immoral, but not rape.

Rape is about lack of consent. Gullible people being tricked into consensual sex is bad, but it needs a new word, because rape is already taken. And it would be great if we could leave that definition alone, for the sake of everybody.

Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by jacquesm on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:00AM (#10626179)
How is she gullible? The government set up a person with a fake identity and pretty much tasked them to become involved with this person. Regardless of what word you wish to use to indicate this crime I think calling her gullible is a bit much, in fact it blames her for a part of this which I think is entirely the wrong reaction.
Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by nothrabannosir on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @09:21AM (#10627260)
Good point, Id edit and remove that if I could. I shouldn't have said that; I meant it in reference to the other case and forgot how it would look in this context.
Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by mattlutze on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:12AM (#10626223)
Lying about who you are isn't rape.

For the FBI[0], at least, rape is defined as:

“Penetration, no matter how slight, of the vagina or anus with any body part or object, or oral penetration by a sex organ of another person, without the consent of the victim."

Telling your potential partner that you're an astronaut or a surgeon does not make you a rapist. It's distasteful and immoral, but not rape.

Suggesting otherwise is dangerous to social progress in the fair legal treatment of women, children and other targeted groups.

0: https://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/recent-program-updates...

Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by DanBC on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:29AM (#10626274)
This is the UK, not the US, and there's a case already posted to this thread of someone lying about who they were and being convicted of rape.
Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by mattlutze on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @08:44AM (#10627106)
Quite right -- in English law I guess it's all about the interpretation and determination of "consent" [0]:

> 'A person consents if they agree by choice, and have the freedom and capacity to make that choice'.

An unfortunately interesting example where a small difference can have a major effect.

I think I should have made it an opinion and said "should not" instead of "does not". Thought I can understand the argument that feeling deceived can also lead to anguish, so I understand where there was logic in the way it's been written in the UK (and perhaps also interpreted in the US).

0: http://content.met.police.uk/Article/Definitions/14000084505...

Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by rmc on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @05:11AM (#10626404)
The important section is "without the consent". If the victim consents to sex with someone who is X, Y or Z, and you tell them you are that and you're not, then that can count as rape.
Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by mattlutze on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @08:46AM (#10627115)
This was down-voted somewhere but it's actually factual for at least the UK.
Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by mattlutze on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:11AM (#10626221)
Lying about who you are isn't rape.

For the FBI[0], at least, rape is defined as:

“Penetration, no matter how slight, of the vagina or anus with any body part or object, or oral penetration by a sex organ of another person, without the consent of the victim."

Telling your potential partner that you're an astronaut or a surgeon does not make you a rapist. Suggesting otherwise is dangerous to social progress in the fair legal treatment of women, children and other targeted groups.

0: https://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/recent-program-updates...

Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by erdojo on Thursday November 26, 2015 @01:14AM (#10631551)
She didn't consent to sleep with him. She was targeted and tricked by a government.

It's such a betrayal by a government who is supposed to protect us that I can't even fathom it. They stole her trust. There was no proof she herself was a criminal. There were no charges. No warrants.

Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by DaWeasel on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:48AM (#10626134)
How is that rape ?
Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by evincarofautumn on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:50AM (#10626139)
I don’t agree with this reasoning, but you could argue that she consented to a relationship with Mark Stone, and not Mark Kennedy.
Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by J-dawg on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:57AM (#10626163)
If the Gayle Newland case [1] is rape, then the Mark Stone / Mark Kennedy case should be too.

I don't know whether either should be considered as rape, I'm just amazed how inconsistent the law can be.

[1] http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-merseyside-34901925

Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by DaWeasel on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @06:45AM (#10626708)
What about witness protection then ? I lie about my identity so me having sex with anybody is a rape ? Even if they agreed to have sex with me after they've learn to know me ?
Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by YeGoblynQueenne on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:51AM (#10626142)
The man she was having sex with was not the man she consented to have sex with.
Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by emerongi on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:12AM (#10626225)
Yes it was. When he was with her, he was Mark Stone. Mark Stone might not share very many characteristics with Mark Kennedy - who lived a totally different life.

She consented to have sex with him, that's it. No, it's not right, but it's definitely not rape either. Calling it rape is just wrong and does injustice to real rape victims.

Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by YeGoblynQueenne on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:53PM (#10629612)
>> When he was with her, he was Mark Stone.

More accurately, he was Mark Kennedy pretending to be someone called Mark Stone. Saying he was Mark Stone didn't magically make him Mark Stone.

>> She consented to have sex with him, that's it.

Because she didn't know he was an undercover policeman. He obtained her consent by abusing his authority as a police officer. His superiors also abused their authority by ordering or permitting this to happen. They took away her ability to make an informed decision about whether she wanted to enter into a sexual relationship with that man.

Re:Activist tricked into 6-year relationship with undercover... by enkephalin on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:02AM (#10626187)
when i'm drunk and meet women, i'm definitely not the man they think i am, due the profound effect alcohol has on my self esteem, social anxiety, and charisma.