How could you possible know enough to admonish people over this? We barely know the facts.
Perhaps the plane never entered Turkish territory. Perhaps only for a few seconds. Maybe it was fired upon when it was already over Syria. Or maybe the rocket hit over Syria.
Much more troubling if it was, indeed, shot down outside of Turkey by mistake.
And in any case, BBC is reporting that "a Turkmen brigade in Syria says [...] shot dead two pilots of the downed Russian jet as they descended with parachutes."[2]
It's concerning that both sides have taken their respective actions. It's only going to exacerbate tenuous relationships with partner nation-states around the Syrian conflict. If Russia reacts aggressively, NATO-ally countries are treaty-bound to respond in support and defense of Turkey.
I really hope both nations see how that increased stress is to no one's benefit and that Russia takes the mature and humble road of deescalation...
0: http://www.economist.com/news/europe/21677461-president-erdo...
1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turkish_general_election,_Nove...
I do not know why they are doing this i.e. do they do this from ignorance or does it come from their display of disrespect and superiority but I have seen many people to forecast that when they continue to do this with Turkey, it will end up with a shotdown.
It does not follow that I agree with Turkeys actions. I think that it was very irresponsible, but I am not overly surprised either. I just wish that it had not happened.
I think that both sides acted in a very unwise manner.
Edit: IANAL in international law of such concerns.
This just reinforces what everyone already thinks, that Turkey is helping ISIS.
Turkey is helping some of the people Russia is fighting, but the people Russia is fighting aren't just Daesh, but every entity operating in Syria that isn't Assad's regime.
I can find absolutely no evidence for that at this time. It is possible this is correct but the plane definitely came down inside Syria. A lot will ride on where it was shot down so best not to make any claims that strong without equally strong evidence.
It supposedly came down 4 km inside Syrian territory, which is a tiny distance for a supersonic plane, which the Su-24 is.
There is quite a bit of conflicting information about this, some sources say 4, others say 40, some use miles, some kilometers.
You mean cocky while West placing all those military bases near Russian borders ?
You mean Russian neighbours trying their best to prepare against growing Russian threat (by what I mean direct official threats, massive military training operations near borders, increased forces near borders)?
The West, when we talk about Western Europe, has constantly reduced their military by dismantling their tank armies, reducing their air force and not keeping their navy up to date with the mantra that Russia is not the enemy any more while Russia has done the opposite. I think you are just not being honest here.
Edit: I do not claim that Russians are the only ones who have become too cocky, but definitely not Russian neighbours.
PS. I wish that there is no need in the world to discuss these matters here or anywhere else.
I see the western propaganda is still hard at work here. This allegedly growing threat just keeps growing every year and escalated to what ? While the wars mentioned in the article of this post was made by the west.
The Western EU armies have been reduced only by turning them into a joke - they're active nowadays as NATO forces for abowe mentioned oil wars, while outer EU states can't keep the EU border intact and are flooded by people of unknown origin - until they arrive at their destination.
I personally would hope that it would not escalate to anything but I think that your trying to ridicule it without any base.
When there is growing threat from one side, then the opposing side (in the reasonable world) would try to counter the threat. In such way this game can continue indefinitely.
I see the western propaganda is still hard at work here.
I would like to hear your list of media sources (local and not local) that you consider to be non biased and in attempt to be honest. I am not sarcastic with this i.e. it is an actual request.
They have both been doing the exact same provocative things.
Apparently they gave the russian 10 warnings. That doesn't add up.
As in, it flew over 2km of Turkish airspace?
At 2000 km/h ground speed, that would take 3.6 seconds. Perhaps 5 times as much if it was going as slow as possible.
"In line with the military rules of engagement, the Turkish authorities repeatedly warned an unidentified aircraft that they were 15 kilometers or less away from the border"
This isn't the first time either, they shot down plenty SyAF fighters and helicopters over Syria, it's just that nobody in the West cares.
Russians got cocky.
Besides, it's never about "rights", it's about having and willing to use the force necessary to enforce no fly zones.
Nothing of importance will come out of this. Russia helped down a commercial jet last year and what happened then? Noting.
The second difference is that the pilots were killed by ground forces on Syrian territory - this is equal to the killing of POWs. The rescue copter was also shot at.
Of course one could argue that the plane was just taking a shortcut over the small part of Turkey territory. The problem with this is that Turkey has warned Russians on many occasions to not do that. But in my opinion it does not look like there was any threat to Turkey.
In principle the Russians have become very cocky near all NATO borders, and Turks are the least PC NATO member, so one can say that Russians had it coming and it looks like they finally found their equally crazy nemesis. Anyway, the situation is alarming and it is not yet clear how the following actions would unroll.
The first reaction from Putin does not make it look like Russia would admit their fault, but I think that he is rather reserved.
My condolences go to the parents and relatives of the killed pilot.
Edit: Changed two paragraphs, added one more paragraph.
Edit2: It looks like Russians flew over Turkey territory towards their target zone (see the map provided in this thread) and then began to fly in circles over Turkey territory. They were shot at the second entry.
I do not know why Russians choose this route as it does not seem to be the most optimal one.
The length over Turkey territory is about 1500-1600 meters, SU-24 flies up to 360 m/s so it was about minimum 5 seconds flight, but as it was a second entry, I guess it does not matter that much.
Anyway, I think that both sides acted in a very unwise manner.