News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by rockdoe on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @04:01AM (#10619811)
>AMD has better open source drivers than Nvidia.

Yes, but Nvidia has working proprietary drivers that put anything AMD to shame on Linux. The difference is so big its outright ludicrous, and it gets worse the higher end the card. I have no idea where the "ridiculously unstable" comes from, must be Ubuntu bugs. Or were you talking about AMD's proprietary driver, fglrx? I agree that's garbage.

>At the top

The top is the GTX980 Ti, for which AMD has no answer. Also if you say "competitive at price point" this means totally disregarding power consumption, of course, where again AMD is so far behind its ludicrous.

Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by fulafel on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @04:47AM (#10619938)
NVidia proprietary drivers are slightly less terrible than AMD's but basically unusable on laptops. Desktop is a far smaller niche. There is nobody that is getting these bugs fixed in distros in a timely fashion, because NVidia doesn't care about laptops and distros don't care about proprietary drivers. See eg this 2+ year old unfixed bug in Ubuntu: https://bugs.launchpad.net/xorg-server/+bug/1220426 (hundreds of comments and subscriptions)

AMD open source drivers are on the other hand are pretty stable and work quite well for things like WebGL, light gaming etc.

Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by tyfon on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @11:12AM (#10621541)
I have a laptop with optimus and it works like a charm even in steam using primusrun. For non gaming stuff it is using the intel gpu.

All I had to do was install 2-3 packages in arch linux and that was that. I haven't had any crashes in linux due to nvidia in many years either so I'd say that the proprietary drivers they have are stellar. I'm a big open source advocator, however I will use what works and for me nvidia is light years ahead of amd when it comes to linux, sad as it is.

Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by Scramblejams on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @01:56PM (#10622714)
Funny, Nvidia's binary drivers have given me the only consistently good experience I've had on Linux laptops. AMD's binary drivers have been absolutely atrocious and the open source drivers (until recent years?) didn't have enough features and enough power savings to sway me.
Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by creshal on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @04:02PM (#10623661)
Compared to AMD's drivers, Nvidia's are good.

Compared to Intel's, both are so horrible it doesn't really matter.

Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by rockdoe on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @08:28AM (#10620538)
Good point about laptops, I didn't consider the Optimus mess. That said, when we're talking about gaming cards I'm not sure that desktop is a niche compared to laptops.
Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by onli on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @04:18AM (#10619868)
If one let it count there still is the R9 295X2, which beats the GTX 980 Ti.

Edit: Source http://anandtech.com/bench/product/1437?vs=1496, because this got downvoted (??)

Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by dogma1138 on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @04:33AM (#10619910)
295x2 is a dual GPU card that requires a nuclear reactor to power. It will beat the 980ti in games that will gain 50% when using 2-way crossfire. Considering the usually disadvantages of using crossfire/SLI it's really not worth it.
Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by onli on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @04:45AM (#10619930)
Yeah I know, the card uses a lot of energy, and the potential crossfire issues are not nice. Still, it is an answer to the 980 Ti (or rather, the 980 Ti was an answer to the 295X2).
Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by dogma1138 on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @05:00AM (#10619969)
980ti wasn't an answer to 295x2, more like the nail in the coffin, it came out couple of weeks before the Fury at a lower price and at about 1000 times more availability and just pulled the rug under AMD's feet.

NVIDIA was smart enough not to get into the fight with dual GPU cards it's a loose loose situation.

Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by girvo on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @05:14AM (#10620011)
> NVIDIA was smart enough not to get into the fight with dual GPU cards it's a loose loose situation

Uhhh... well, look, I don't know much about video cards these days, but that's not quite true: http://www.t3.com/news/nvidia-is-about-to-launch-a-new-monst...

Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by dogma1138 on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @07:27AM (#10620322)
It is quite very true, that dual GPU card if it ever comes out will be a replacement for the TitanZ a niche card not a flag ship. NVIDIA leaned not to repeat that misstake from the 690 which was and be all accounts would be the last time they release a flagship consumer GTX line dual GPU card. When you have a flagship card that can lose in benchmarks to cards 1/4th it's price because SLI/Xfire fails, and when you can't enable all the bells and whistles like Adaptive VSync (GSync/ASync), Temporal AA, DSR, and any other new "tech" that you boast about for 6 months before release because of SLI/Xfire you are going to fail and fail badly. AMD had to release the X2 cards because they could not compete against the GTX780/780ti and the 980 was around the corner, by the time the 295x2 actually was available in the market at any decent amounts the 980 was already out, and while the 295x2 beat it in certain cases it was too little too late, especially considering that the 295x2 couldn't fit in many cases (same issue that the 690 had) needed a 350$ power supply to run which most people don't have (same as the 690), and produced enough hit to start fusion (not that far from the 690). So no NVIDIA isn't fighting in the dual GPU arena anymore, they aren't releasing flagships, and they are smart enough to wait for the very end of their refresh cycle to release a "look how much money I got to spend on the latest Titan" card that will never be produced in any large amounts, will not be needed to beat the competition as far as single card performance goes.
Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by girvo on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @06:24PM (#10624312)
Everywhere I can find is calling the new dual-GPU card Nvidia's "flagship", though. Call it a "niche card" as much as you like, but you're moving the goalposts here.
Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by dogma1138 on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @11:13AM (#10627861)
Their previous Dual GPU card was priced at 3000$ this isn't a consumer card, that's double the launch price of the 295x2 which was priced at 1400$ and received a 40% price cut within 3 months (considering that it was pretty much unavailable on the market until July/Aug where it already has been cut to below Titan Black prices you can say it's actual launch price was ~950$). The normal GTX Titan cards which launch at 1000$ can barely be considered a consumer flagship cards, the Titan X was the "1st" one which was some what financially successful because like with the Titan Black they've dropped the "workstation/professional" features from the Core and released it as a premium Ti placeholder to appease early adopters until the yields are good enough that they do not have to cherry pick cores. As far as GPU market goes there are 2 "flagship" products that the market actually cares about the 350-400$ enthusiast card, and the 600-700$ "flagship", both of them however sell several orders of magnitude less than the entry level 200-250$ gaming cards like the 750/760/850/860 or the 270/370 and 280/380. If you still don't understand the difference then the 295x2 was released and positioned to be a competitive option against 700-900$ cards, just like the old NVIDIA 690 which was a 1000$ Dual GPU card. You need to understand that the 690 was supposed to be the "top" of the line card for Nvidia at the time, and technically in some aspects it's still the most powerful single board card they've released to date (it can even beat the TitanZ in some benchmarks). This was the card that Nvidia released as the definite gaming card, this was the card that Nvidia launched the "Geforce Exprience" on top of it, and this was the card that had more issues on launch since their FX series. The card actually lost in gaming benchmarks to Nvidia's own 680 SLI in pretty much every case, it lost to the 680 which was clocked higher in games that didn't support SLI well, it could not support all of the new Geforce graphical features due to SLI compatibility and worse it lost to the 7970CF in most benchmarks. That was pretty much the point where Nvidia it self said they will focus on single core performance and ensure that the primary numerical GTX series will be the one that will focus on real-world gaming performance, 2 years later the Titan series was released which is their "look at what we can do, now give us 3000$ please". It's not about moving goal posts, its about perception and actual market presence.
Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by onli on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @05:18AM (#10620021)
You are right, the 980 Ti was probably more of an answer to the expected potential of the Fury, it had a great timing. But lower price? I can get a R9 Fury X for 635€, a R9 Fury for 564€. The GTX 980 Ti starts at 718€.

Maybe the 980 Ti was cheaper in some markets at the very beginning.

Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by dogma1138 on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @07:29AM (#10620325)
The TI was cheaper than the FuryX before the price cut, and the 980 was cheaper than the normal Fury again before the price cut.
Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by vliedel on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @04:28AM (#10619900)
On several laptops already, I got a blank screen at boot, after some updates. Looking for fixes usually gave me "purge nvidia-*". The way i see it these days is that you just have to be lucky.
Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by lqdc13 on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @04:40AM (#10619924)
Solution that works for me is to add the ppa from this page:

https://launchpad.net/~graphics-drivers/+archive/ubuntu/ppa

Everything else requires having to turn off lightdm service or having to ssh to the machine to reinstall the drivers when something goes wrong.

Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by Zagitta on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @06:28AM (#10620195)
Can't say I expected to see Nvidia fanboys on HN but the R9 Fury X exists and beats 980ti at >1080p resolutions in games not gimped by Nvidia Gameworks: http://www.anandtech.com/show/9390/the-amd-radeon-r9-fury-x-... At the same price point using only slightly more power and having nice and quite closed loop water cooling.
Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by dang on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @03:00PM (#10623217)
> Can't say I expected to see Nvidia fanboys on HN

This breaks the HN guideline against calling names in arguments. Please don't do that.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by taspeotis on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @07:12AM (#10620291)
> the R9 Fury X exists and beats 980ti at >1080p resolutions in games not gimped by Nvidia Gameworks

I skim-read for comments regarding the R9 Fury X vs. 980 Ti and in particular comments about >1080p and had to go through seven benchmarks before arriving at an admittedly mixed ray of sunshine for AMD. Quotes from the article:

> (Battlefield 4) The R9 Fury X does not take the lead at any resolution, and in fact this is one of the worse games for the card. At 4K AMD trails by 8-10%, and at 1440p that’s 16%

> (Crysis 3) Once again the card trails the GTX 980 Ti, but not by quite as much as we saw in Battlefield 4. In this case the gap is 6-7% at 4K, and 12% at 1440p

> (Shadow of Mordor) These framerates aren’t bad – the R9 Fury X is always over 30fps – but even accounting for the higher variability of minimum framerates, they’re trailing the GTX 980 Ti by 13-15% with Ultra quality settings

> (Civilization: Beyond Earth) ...can’t keep this advantage at 1440p, where they go back to trailing the GTX 980 Ti in minimum framerates by 7%.

> (Dragon Age: Inquisition) The card trails the GTX 980 Ti at all times, by anywhere between 13% and 18%. At this point AMD is straddling the line between the GTX 980 and GTX 980 Ti, and at 1440p they fall closer to the GTX 980.

> (The Talos Principle) ...AMD’s performance once again regresses at 1440p. It’s enough to retain the lead, if just barely, and tie the GTX Titan X

> (Far Cry 4) Overall what we find is that the R9 Fury X has a 9% lead at 4K Ultra, and a 4% lead at 1440p Ultra, making this one of the only games where AMD takes the lead at 1440p. However something interesting happens if we run at 4K with lower quality settings, and that lead evaporates very quickly, shifting to an NVIDIA lead by roughly the same amount.

The article concludes:

> At 2560x1440 the card loses its status as a viable alternative. AMD’s performance deficit is over 10% at this point...

I didn't look up whether those games use Gameworks or not but if six-point-five out of seven games play better on NVIDIA than AMD well ... who is going to look at AMD cards for gaming?

Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by onli on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @07:52AM (#10620392)
He did not give you a good source for his claims. There are other benchmarks and the driver situation changed after that. http://wccftech.com/amd-r9-fury-x-performance-ahead-nvidia-9... writes about the driver, http://www.computerbase.de/2015-06/amd-radeon-r9-fury-x-test... saw the Fury X in a different game selection a lot closer to the 980 Ti already after the launch. Still, the 980 Ti was ahead.

Regardless, the more interesting card price/performance wise was the Fury without the X (with the current prices that is debatable). To answer your question: AMD is seen as having the potential to beat Nvidia cards later on, with driver improvements and DirectX 12. Also, there is something to be said to favoring the smaller player in the market. Especially now, with the prices being adjusted to the performance difference.

It is not like choosing the slower card will lead to games being unplayable – never on normal resolutions, with reduced settings otherwise.

Re:AMD Open Source Driver Supports Latest GPUS by rockdoe on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @08:26AM (#10620529)
Can't say I expected to see Nvidia fanboys

There are plenty of benchmarks to support my claim, no need to resort to name calling, just show evidence that you are right. You'll see that the majority of objective evidence disagrees with you.

Who's the fanboy then?

AMD has Nvidia beat at one point: the R390 beats the GTX970, on Windows. Luckily for AMD (and hence for us, yay competition) it's a reasonably popular point.