News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by jaxomlotus on Monday November 23, 2015 @09:20PM (#10618781)
Sorry, that seems opportunistic. I felt bad for him, but no way he was scarred to the tune of $15 million. Even the bad experience had a major upside - he was offered an internship to Twitter and an invitation to the White House. Schools are budget-deprived enough without adding frivolous lawsuits to the mix.

In this case everyone involved in suspending him should have been seriously reprimanded and an apology given (and I'm surprised one wasn't). But a $15 million lawsuit isn't the answer.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by jonlucc on Monday November 23, 2015 @09:22PM (#10618789)
I think this is how you get schools to care and avoid doing the same in the future.
Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by toomuchtodo on Monday November 23, 2015 @09:43PM (#10618846)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punitive_damages

> Punitive damages or exemplary damages are damages intended to reform or deter the defendant and others from engaging in conduct similar to that which formed the basis of the lawsuit. Although the purpose of punitive damages is not to compensate the plaintiff, the plaintiff will receive all or some portion of the punitive damage award.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by shubhamjain on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @06:53AM (#10620247)
Is there anything seriously wrong in how school reacted? Quoting New York Times,

> He said he took it to school on Monday to show an engineering teacher, who said it was nice but then told him he should not show the invention to other teachers. Later, Ahmed’s clock beeped during an English class, and after he revealed the device to the teacher, school officials notified the police, and Ahmed was interrogated by officers.

> Ahmed wasn’t accused of making a bomb – he was accused of making a look-alike, a hoax. And be honest with yourself, a big red digital display with a bunch of loose wires in a brief-case looking box is awful like a Hollywood-style representation of a bomb. [1]

[1]: http://blogs.artvoice.com/techvoice/2015/09/17/reverse-engin...

Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by unprepare on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @08:01AM (#10620421)
I think this is how you create poor educational outcomes for the students in an entire district.

Losing 15 million dollars is not a loss most school districts will be able to withstand - that would likely mean the closing of schools, consolidation, larger class sizes, teacher pay decreases, etc.

But yeah, costing a community of people 15 million dollars sure will teach the four or five people actually involved a valuable lesson.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by jaxomlotus on Monday November 23, 2015 @10:20PM (#10618958)
Should schools really not take security seriously though? Do we really want people second guessing themselves when it comes to safety? That precedent is asking for trouble.
Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by dllthomas on Monday November 23, 2015 @10:30PM (#10618984)
How does safety enter into it? Everyone knew it wasn't a bomb. Some people thought it was pretending to be a bomb, other people contend that it wasn't pretending to be a bomb. How are you worried about people second guessing themselves, in that context?

Schools have procedures for when there's a suspected bomb. They don't look like what was done, here. There was never a suspected bomb - only a suspected hoax.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by ltorresv on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @12:59AM (#10619355)
Everyone knew it wasn't a bomb? Really? AFAIK he was asked what it was and he was uncooperative although we won't ever know since his family refused the public release of the police records.

Anyways, if we're going with hearsay then we should mention the boy's sister was suspended for making a bomb threat so I'd doubt the average teacher would just brush this off as "definitely not a bomb".

Now, seems like in your mind it would've been better for the school to send a SWAT team after him. I'm sure that wouldn't be seen as a negative thing by anyone.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by dllthomas on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @01:55AM (#10619500)
Better? No. More consistent with "we thought it was a bomb"? Yes. At which point, the discussion of what should be done when you think there's a bomb becomes germane. So far as I understand it, no one involved is claiming that they thought it was a bomb.

Far more conspicuous than relative lack of force (which, depending on particulars, might possibly have been a fine reaction to an actual bomb) is the apparent lack of any move to evacuate other students.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by swang on Monday November 23, 2015 @11:03PM (#10619079)
I am really confused by the negative reactions because it seems like Ahmed's family is following the American Way by suing for $15 million.

But seriously, isn't this how it always has been with incidents like this? If they want to sue they don't want to sue for $2 million because the school will probably tryo to settle for ~$500K. If you set it at $15 million, it anchors the price point higher and they may get $3 million to make it go away.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by Ollinson on Monday November 23, 2015 @11:37PM (#10619146)
I think Ahmed and his family forfeit their right to the "American way" when they decided to move to Qatar after receiving an outpouring of support from the American public (including meeting Obama).
Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by DrScump on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @04:53AM (#10619954)
A cynic would say it's a case of the carnival folding up the tents and leaving town before the locals figure out that the midway games were fixed.
Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by DrScump on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @04:52AM (#10619953)
Public agencies face a different process. One can't just sue such an agency for damages directly; one makes a financial claim against the agency instead. Then, if the claim is denied and not settled, then one can sue.
Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by TeMPOraL on Monday November 23, 2015 @11:57PM (#10619188)
Just because it's a stereotypical "American Way", doesn't mean it's right. The negative reactions may come from the fact that rent-seeking is harmful to society. Moreover, this particular case is an abuse of public goodwill, and many of the commenters expressing negative sentiments probably fell for the hoax and were supporting this kid publicly.
Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by swang on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @12:25AM (#10619260)
The "American Way" part was a joke.

But it wasn't a hoax dude. It actually happened. He got arrested for pretty much _no_ reason whatsoever.

There are two separate events

1. Ahmed was arrested for a pretty dumb thing and most likely because he was a brown kid it made it easier for them to assume it was a bomb or hoax bomb. Whatever they want to call it. I'd have to see how often "hoax bombs" were actually used to arrest someone before I say they racially profiled him for sure, but my gut feeling is that there isn't a high incidence of hoax bomb arrests.

2. Ahmed's family is suing for $15 million. Not Ahmed, who probably has little choice in the matter.

I am sure suing for so much money has brought bad publicity for them, but at the same time that issue is separate from the incident of him being arrested, which happened.

Using the term rent-seeking is a bit over the top unless you really believe this entire thing was staged.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by TeMPOraL on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @05:28AM (#10620046)
> Using the term rent-seeking is a bit over the top unless you really believe this entire thing was staged.

I'm currently inclining to believe that, but that's beside the point. The whole nation stood in their defense, they got so high up the chain that even POTUS got interested personally, and now they're suing for $15 million?! Rent-seeking is a little light word for that IMO.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by swang on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @12:23PM (#10622108)
It is rent-seeking I guess if you think they will actually get $15 million, and don't think they deserve a dime.

I think there should be some kinda of punitive damage for the school because of their actions. I don't think it's $15 million. I also don't think a jury will award $15 million. And more likely the case may be thrown out or the school district will just settle to make it go away.

People in this thread are acting as though they were already awarded $15 million. I always assumed a jury ends up deciding the damages, if any, in civil cases like this. It's not an automatic $15 million if they prove their case just because that's what they asked for in compensation.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by TeMPOraL on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @11:02PM (#10625264)
> People in this thread are acting as though they were already awarded $15 million.

I don't think so. Personally, if they got awarded $15 million, I would be pissed off at the jury. I'm angry at the kid's family for having the chutzpah to ask for that much money.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by DrScump on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @04:28AM (#10619896)
"But it wasn't a hoax dude. It actually happened. He got arrested for pretty much _no_ reason whatsoever."

The whole "homemade clock" claim is what was a hoax, regardless of any subsequent panic about its application. (If you aren't clear on the backstory, look it up. It's just a mass-production A/C-powered clock taken out of its case. For example, see: http://www.ebay.com/itm/MICRONTA-Large-Red-Display-Digital-A...)

Regarding the reaction: hindsight is a handy thing, but we live in an era where schools routinely go into complete lockdown if some kid or staffer thinks he might have spotted a weapon.

When you read the article carefully, some things pop out:

1) BBC makes no mention here of the whole "homebuilt" concept itself being a hoax, e.g. a "homemade" clock (why the suitcase?) that was really just a disassembled, mass-production A/C-powered clock).

2) Lawyer letter stating, "Irving Police officials immediately determined that the clock was harmless" is false. Beat cops aren't qualified to make any such analysis; even things as innocuous as an unattended backpack get further analysis by specifically trained personnel.

3) "Ahmed's father ... once stood as a presidential candidate against (Sudanese President) Bashir." That's a pretty strong theoretical motive for a publicity stunt.

In any case, they leveraged the fauxtrage into a full scholarship to The Qatar Foundation for Education, Science and Community... so, mission accomplished.

Another article, however, claims the following: "(Teacher) did escort Ahmed to the office, where the letter alleges that five police officers, the principal and the assistant principal performed an "interrogation." During that time, he was allegedly not permitted to contact his parents and was forced to sign a letter of confession under the threat of expulsion." Now, if that is true, that warrants investigation and corrective action on its own, completely unrelated to religion, national origin, or who "made" the item, or why.

Meanwhile, this article says that his older sister claims to have been suspended 5-6 years earlier over alleged threats to blow up her school:

'The sister claimed after the arrest that she had been suspended from a school for several days. “I got suspended from school for three days from this stupid same district, from this girl saying I wanted to blow up the school, something I had nothing to do with,” she said, without providing evidence or proof.

The episode occurred around 2009, she said. The scare happened in “my first year of attempting middle school in America. I knew English, but the culture was different, the people were different,” Eyman said.

“I got suspended and I didn’t do anything about it,” she said.'

http://www.breitbart.com/big-government/2015/09/23/ahmeds-si...

If true, that's an interesting pattern.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by swang on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @12:09PM (#10622007)
If the things you stated are true: that Ahmed did not make the clock, that Ahmed's father is a politician (I guess your implication is that politicians will throw their children under the bus for publicity?), and that the sister was also suspended 6 years prior, I still don't see an implication that the dad set it up.

If you combine those facts to believe Ahmed's father completely set this up, then you can also just combine these facts to determine that people in that school district of Texas are probably just racists (the sister didn't do anything and got suspended, the brother did something that may have been grounds for suspension, but got arrested). People are willing to crucify Ahmed (who again I doubt had much choice if he was set up to do this) for the former, but no one cares about the possibility of the latter. I'm guessing the truth lies between these two extremes.

But again, if Ahmed's father set him up for this, then there should have been an investigation. And if he had been found guilty of forcing his son to stage some fake clock/bomb thing, well I'll go and sharpen my pitchfork for it. But as far as I can tell, kid was _arrested_ for what amounts to a clock he didn't make.

> 2) Lawyer letter stating, "Irving Police officials immediately determined that the clock was harmless" is false. Beat cops aren't qualified to make any such analysis; even things as innocuous as an unattended backpack get further analysis by specifically trained personnel.

If they did think it was a bomb, or didn't think it was but had no authority/knowledge to assess that it was a bomb, then it is even worse because it means there was a possible bomb on campus and they failed to evacuate the school. I think that was part of the anger that people felt about this case. Were they really thinking about the welfare of the rest of the children on campus or did they know it wasn't a bomb so were just kinda harassing Ahmed because they wanted to?

Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by serge2k on Monday November 23, 2015 @09:46PM (#10618863)
> Schools are budget-deprived enough without adding frivolous lawsuits to the mix.

I'm sorry, in what way is this frivolous?

Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by unprepare on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @08:18AM (#10620480)
In that it removes 5 million dollars from a school district's budget.

A school district that serves thousands of children, primarily minorities.

I am shocked that there is anyone saying that those children deserve poorer educational outcomes because of this incident.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by fleitz on Monday November 23, 2015 @09:57PM (#10618902)
In that getting called into the office for your homemade 'clock' is not a big deal, and certainly not a $15m big deal.
Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by smileysteve on Monday November 23, 2015 @10:14PM (#10618947)
If by 'called into the office' you mean handcuffed, told that you are being expelled, and catching the news cycle. Not to mention being the topic of a national debate with some pointing out your race and guessing as to whether or not you are a terrorist.
Re:Ahmed Mohamed: 'Clock boy' seeks $15m from city and school by fleitz on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @12:54AM (#10619344)
He's not the only kid to get in trouble with the police at school. I dunno man, I'm from Canada, and this is like $100K tops, obviously we don't have the same legal climate as the US but $15m seems a little steep, I do realize it's the opening offer.