News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by cstross on Monday November 23, 2015 @06:31AM (#10613993)
I read this article as quasi-racist fearmongering, jumping on the Trump bandwagon for circulation figures. Shameful yellow journalism, in other words.

Imagine how this article would read if for "muslim" you substituted "hispanic" or "jew" or "african-american". Alarmist? Racist? Hostile? Got it in one. Now how is structuring the narrative around muslims any different?

(There's a classic saying in newsroom culture: "if it bleeds, it leads" -- which is why for the past week our news has been saturated with the muslims are coming! Be afraid! rhetoric. It doesn't sell newspapers to point out that there are around 2 billion muslims world-wide, of whom maybe 20,000 are active jihadis in AQ and Da'esh; the rest are just ordinary folks who are happy to get along, and overall they've killed vastly fewer people on American or European soil than home-grown terrorists over the past five decades.)

NB: expecting downvotes, because nothing triggers a witch-hunt like a media panic over [insert terrifying incomprehensible foreign threat here].

Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by themartorana on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:02AM (#10614103)
I'm sure I'm in the minority here (where the word "racist" is thrown around rather liberally and without any mind for "let him who is without sin...") In any case, I can understand the tension.

First and perhaps most common is just a fear of changing culture. It happens, and all is fluid, but it's not uncommon. Many people fear change, and I'm not saying it's good to restrict change because of that fear, but I understand the human nature behind it.

That said, I'd be upset if I had to hear a call to prayer 5 times a day. I am pretty anti-religion as it goes, which is my own personal bias, but I don't appreciate being forced to tolerate annoyance for someone else's religion. It's the same as people blasting music in the park 5x a day - the idea of noise pollution and disturbing the peace exists for this very reason. Allowing it to continue for what I assume are politically correct reasons is frustrating.

I also do not understand why I should be expected to tolerate Islam when it stands against many things I'm for - most egregiously is equal rights for women (not to mention other common religious touch-points like homosexuality, premarital sex, and huge swaths of science education). Islam is most oppressive to women. I hear the argument "Well what if a woman wants to be Muslim?" to which I answer that I'm sure there were conservative women against Suffrage or equal pay or any number of progressive issues for women.

Living in peace with our neighbors is fine and expected, and living in a major city as I do, there are people of all creeds and religions - but I'm still going to be annoyed when the National Guard take over the city and lock it down for the Pope (who, as progressive as he is, is still rather homophobic), or when the Nation of Islam is shouting through speakers on the streets, or when some born-again nut is shouting at me through a loud speaker/bull horn about how my whole family is going to burn in Hell.

Tolerance for Islam is the new politically correct darling. It's still oppressive to women, it's still an organized religion, and like absolutely everything and everybody in this world, it will take full advantage of the leeway given to it.

And so I understand the frustration with certain aspects of what this article touches on.

Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by cstross on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:59AM (#10614307)
I also do not understand why I should be expected to tolerate Islam when it stands against many things I'm for

You're expected to tolerate it for the same reason they are expected to tolerate your beliefs. (Or those of Christian dominionists, for that matter.) Separation of Church and State is one of the best ideas to have come out of the US constitution, bar none, and if you don't see how it benefits you, you haven't lived in a nation that doesn't have it.

(Trust me on this: I'm British and I can't go out of my front door without witnessing the long-term effects of a State religion around me -- a toothless, decrepit thing that is rapidly fading away, but a state religion nonetheless, with all the legacy of privilege that implies.)

Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by lotsofcows on Monday November 23, 2015 @11:05AM (#10615317)
"Islam is"... what? That's like saying "Christianity is..." Pick a flavour, then a sub-flavour; you'll still be making generalisms largely but at least you won't sound like a bigot.

Even better stop labelling things culturally. Do you have a problem with women's rights? Good, then fight for women's rights. Do you have a problem with the Azhan, with blasting music, with cockeral's crowing, with bloody church bells? Then your concern is public noise, not a culturally specific public noise.

Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by seivan on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:11AM (#10614126)
You're not a minority. And the irony is, many moderate muslims agree with you. Unfortunately they are usually called "native informants" by Glenn Greenwald and the loud far reaching islamic imperialist posse thus making you feel like a minority, but you're not.
Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by ps4fanboy on Monday November 23, 2015 @06:34AM (#10614008)
Imagine this same article but substituting it for startup hipsters. Jacking up the rent driving their illegal startup buses. I would argue most of the people who are for these immigrant communities are also against the kind of gentrification happening in the bay.
Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by GnwbZHiU on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:10AM (#10614123)
I don't think it's fair to say that the article is fearmongering. There are real concerns by the local residents, for example, about the noise from the call to prayer (it can be 5am in the morning). I, too, hate it, I can understand why other people hate it.
Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by jacquesm on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:12AM (#10614129)
How do you feel about church bells on Sunday morning?
Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by morgante on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:23AM (#10614172)
Churches don't ring loud bells at 5am.

Having lived with the call to prayer for several years now, I can absolutely understand resident's frustration with it.

In a secular society, it shouldn't be treated any differently than if I got on a loudspeaker and started shouting 'wake up everyone!' at 5am every morning.

Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by jacquesm on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:28AM (#10614194)
No, but some do try to ring them at 07:15 every morning really loud and really long, it took a judge to put a stop to that. Link in Dutch, no English source, sorry.

http://www.volkskrant.nl/binnenland/tilburgse-pastoor-mag-kl...

I'm all for stopping any such nonsense but then churchbells are out. All of them, they served their purpose in the times before social media and alarm clocks but nowadays there is no reason for them.

And if that is used to stop Mosques from doing their 'call to prayer' I'm all for it, but let's keep things equal.

Of course that may be a bit hard to do in a town with both a large Catholic and a large Muslim population. But either both should not take offense at what the other does or both should agree that there is no gain from any of this.

Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by GnwbZHiU on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:37AM (#10614226)
It doesn't have to be all or nothing. To be equal, we can allow churches to ding the bell once a week on sunday, and allow mosques to recite call to prayer once a week on friday.
Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by to3m on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:49AM (#10614263)
If you live in a country where Christianity is the state religion, you could just disallow the call to prayer on account of the fact it is not Christian. (One advantage of a state religion is that you can do stuff like this. Of course, you have to be careful not to take it too far - condemning unbelievers to death might be a bit much, for example.)
Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by morgante on Monday November 23, 2015 @02:36PM (#10616727)
Sounds good to me.
Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by DanBC on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @07:10AM (#10626778)
> Churches don't ring loud bells at 5am.

http://www.apnewsarchive.com/1996/Fed-Up-With-Sound-of-Churc...

> Fed up with visitors ringing the church bells in this picturesque western England town, she took an ax to the 500-year-old church door this weekend and chopped down the belfry ropes.

> Mather's family has lived in Compton Basset almost as long as St. Swithun's church _ 400 years _ and she said she felt remorse for what she did. But she also felt that, after repeated pleas to church elders over the years, she could no longer take the bells pealing 100 yards from her home.

> ``My health was suffering and it was a choice of prison or more suffering,'' she said Monday. ``I have done my utmost to sort it out but in the end I had no option.''

> Before dawn Sunday, she spent 2 1/2 hours hacking through the church door with an ax; she then cut through the belfry ropes.

> Church Warden Robert Henly told the British Broadcasting Corp. that the belfry ropes were cut too close to the bells to be repaired.

> ``They can't be spliced,'' he said. ``They have to be new.''

> The last straw for 64-year-old Mather was the two hours visitors from Oxford spent ringing the bells on Saturday.

> ``I don't mind the ringing for village services, funerals and weddings, but when it is outsiders just doing it for fun it becomes unbearable,'' she said.

Bell ringers are arseholes too, it's not just Muslims.

Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by lmm on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:20AM (#10614154)
Immensely pissed off and I wish there were a way I could do something about them. Why?
Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by jacquesm on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:21AM (#10614160)
Because to me it is exactly as irritating as the 'calls to prayer' but since we seem to accept the one I guess we have no option but to accept the other as well.

I'm trying to imagine the poor people living within earshot of both a church and a mosque.

Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by Mithaldu on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:24AM (#10614176)
Who says we accept them? Some people accept them, some people accept them in moderation, some people move away, some people look for options: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10614084
Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by jacquesm on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:35AM (#10614218)
It's super annoying but depending on the value of 'tradition' (whatever that means) the composition of the local council (which the article here actually refers to) and the laws in place already you may or may not be able to find a judge willing to put a stop to it. This can be an extremely long drawn out battle. Churches get away with lots of stuff that otherwise would not be tolerated.
Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by GnwbZHiU on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:16AM (#10614140)
In the place where I live, churches do not ring the bell. Even if they do, that's much less then 5 times a day.
Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by exodust on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:45AM (#10614252)
Church bells are not religious propaganda.

Islamic call to prayer translates roughly to "you really ought to pray right now if you want salvation. Seriously, it's time to acknowledge who is the greatest.. you know who, yeh that's right, God is greatest. And you know what? Prayer is more important than sleep, so do as I ask, just as you did yesterday, and just like you ought to do tomorrow. Get praying people".

Vs

A bell.

Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by jacquesm on Monday November 23, 2015 @08:33AM (#10614443)
To me they're both just annoying noises.
Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by bjourne on Monday November 23, 2015 @06:50AM (#10614064)
Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by netman21 on Monday November 23, 2015 @06:58AM (#10614088)
Completely agree. I live a few miles away from Hamtramck. We go their often for great Polish food. I don't need this kind of fear mongering.
Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by venomsnake on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:13AM (#10614131)
> Imagine how this article would read if for "muslim" you substituted "hispanic" or "jew" or "african-american". Alarmist? Racist? Hostile? Got it in one. Now how is structuring the narrative around muslims any different?

Religion is not like race. Religion is a choice that could be changed within a second with zero effort whatsoever.

Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by raverbashing on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:39AM (#10614230)
Unless you live in a Muslim country and wants to change to something else, then you are killed or at least has committed a crime.
Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by jacquesm on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:24AM (#10614181)
> Religion is a choice that could be changed within a second with zero effort whatsoever.

Race you can't change, religion you can. That we agree on, there is plenty of evidence that this is possible. However, 'race' is often in the eye of the beholder and religion, how ever easy it is to change in principle has a nasty habit of becoming an integral part of the identity of the practitioner and it can be extremely hard to get rid of it, definitely not a 'zero effort whatsoever' thing, more like an extremely invasive review of what makes up the self.

Think of it as a psychological crisis and not many people go that route head-on. If anything it is usually a very slow process stretching out over many years where disillusion plays a major role. So not quite 'changed within a second'.

Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by raverbashing on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:36AM (#10614223)
Just a small note, it's not racist if one is stating facts

Am I racist for not wanting to get a horn or some loud noise 5x a day? So be it

Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by seivan on Monday November 23, 2015 @06:56AM (#10614083)
Either you're dishonest with "maybe 20 000 active jihadists" or just unaware. But that claim is laughable given the amount of support Jihadists have. You talk about News Room culture, but you miss there are two sides to it and now you're Chamberlain. ;-)

Also I am pretty sure Jews, African-Americans and Hispanics don't got doctrine that tells them to kill apostates.

A better comparison would be Westboro Baptist Church. Except they are what, odd 20 people? Islamofascists numbers reach the millions, obviously not all are active jihadists. But many support and finance.

This isn't media panic. This is experience before the media even got attention to it.

EDIT: Yeah I saw the Wiki page just like you did. I was trying to serve a point. facepalm

Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by fwapost on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:41AM (#10614240)
> A better comparison would be Westboro Baptist Church

Not better enough considering the number to date of homosexuals ISIS has tossed off rooftops, compared with the WBC's general standing around and sign-holding.

Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by jacquesm on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:16AM (#10614141)
> Either you're dishonest with "maybe 20 000 active jihadists" or just unaware.

> Except they are what, odd 20 people?

If you're off by a factor of 2 on the Westboro Baptist Church, which you can verify in just about 2 seconds it's kind of weird to see you complain about how many active jihadists there are, it's not like they have a registry.

Does that make you dishonest, or just unaware?

There must be a better way to make your argument.

Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by fwapost on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:13AM (#10614133)
> I read this article as quasi-racist fearmongering, jumping on the Trump bandwagon for circulation figures. Shameful yellow journalism, in other words.

The Washington Post is extremely left-leaning. In fact, they recently published an editorial all but equating the US with Nazi Germany should we refuse to admit Syrian refugees.

The article reads to me like a typical "changing neighborhood" piece, albeit one where the author perhaps failed to toe the party line sufficiently to your liking. If you really believe the Post is "jumping on the Trump bandwagon," you clearly haven't read them enough.

> It doesn't sell newspapers to point out that there are around 2 billion muslims world-wide, of whom maybe 20,000 are active jihadis in AQ and Da'esh; the rest are just ordinary folks who are happy to get along

Just ordinary folks who are happy to get along--and who broadly support the death penalty for apostasy, the stoning of adulterers, and making Sharia the binding law of the land:

http://www.pewforum.org/2013/04/30/the-worlds-muslims-religi...

> NB: expecting downvotes

Really? Expecting downvotes on HN for criticizing an article on Muslims that wasn't a complete whitewash? I'm quite confident my comments will end up subzero long before yours.

And by the way, don't you have some critical comments to moderate on your echo chamber of a blog? Must keep those "safe spaces" safe, after all.

Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by jacquesm on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:20AM (#10614156)
Typical changing neighborhood piece?

"In many ways, Hamtramck is a microcosm of the fears gripping parts of the country since the Islamic State’s attacks on Paris: The influx of Muslims here has profoundly unsettled some residents of the town long known for its love of dancing, beer, paczki pastries and the pope."

Fearmongering, pure and simple. Won't somebody think of the dancing, the beer, the pastries and the pope.

How about waiting to see what that majority Muslim council gets up to before condemning them? If they do something about the kielbasa then maybe it's time to start articles like these.

Re:In the first majority-Muslim U.S. city, residents tense a... by fwapost on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:25AM (#10614186)
Typical in that these articles often cover the ethnic, religious, or other tensions that result from demographic shifts within a community. Look at any article on the gentrification of some historically black neighborhood.