The intention of the question is to find out if the child has understood the concept of place values, and I think the ambiguity of the question is there so that you can accept either answer that demonstrates that the child understands that the value of a digit changes based on its location, and that the location of the 5 in 582 notates a 'hundred' multiplier.
While I think the structure of the question might be off putting, asking about place values makes plenty of sense to me. I recall being taught place values in the mid to late 90s up here in Ontario, so it's not exactly a new fangled thing.
edit: used less broken sentences.
To me it's confusing as anything, because it implies that symbol values aren't really constant.
Isn't it easier to learn that symbol values are constant, but they're modified by position?
So the 5 in 582 is 5 X 100.
It's not "500", because conceptually that implies a different unique symbol.
One way emphasises a limited set of consistent symbols, and a small pool of symbolic operations. The other way suggests there's an infinite pool of symbols of varying values, and you're supposed to think of them as separate numbers when they're in different place groups.
The real point of math is generalisation and symbolic and functional economy. So I think the latter obscures what's happening instead of simplifying it.
Symbols defined using only references to themselves are notoriously difficult to understand.
When the student answers, "it's in the hundreds place", that tells me a lot. It really says, "I think I know the concept you are trying to test, and I would like to prove that I have mastered it, but the question you asked does not allow me to do so, as it is ambiguous as to whether you are testing my knowledge of the invariant symbol value of '5', the positional value of the third digit from the right in a decimal number, or the embedded multiplication inherent in decimal notation. As the value of '5' is the least complex of those three concepts, I have purposefully left it out of my answer, and I hedged the other two senses by explicitly saying the second and implying the third." Or in shorter terms, "I'm not sure exactly why you are asking me that, so I'm not sure whether to tell you five or five hundred."
As a result, I would say that answer is correct, but given in a form that exposes the inherent weakness of the question.
The symbol '5' has value five no matter where it appears. The radix-exponent-2 position has the same value no matter which numeral symbol appears in it. The student can best demonstrate knowledge of this generalization by performing radix conversions.
The '5' in hexadecimal number 0x582 is still worth five, but it is multiplied by position value sixteen exponent two rather than ten exponent two. The '5' is in the twohundredfiftysixes place rather than the hundreds place. So the symbol has net value five touhunnerfittysixes rather than five hundreds.
If you don't emphasize the separation between symbol value and positional value, you're actually encouraging a regression to the mental-math roadblocks of Roman numerals, where I, V, X, L, C, D, and M have distinct invariant values.
This is standard 1 (4.NBT.A.1)
https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=RvpzCQAAQBAJ&pg=PT160&lp...
Bobby has made a true statement that is related to the question, but hasn't completely answered the question. The correct is that the value of 5 in 582 is 500, and an even better answer would be "the value of 5 in 582 is 500 because the 5 is in the hundreds place".
This distinction is something that many teachers overlook. There is an excellent handbook for teachers called "Teach Like A Champion" [1] which emphasises that "Right is Right" - here is an excerpt:
---------------------------------
Right Is Right is about the difference between partially right and all-the-way right—between pretty good and 100 percent. The job of the teacher is to set a high standard for correctness: 100 percent. The likelihood is strong that students will stop striving when they hear the word right (or yes or some other proxy), so there's a real risk to naming as right that which is not truly and completely right. When you sign off and tell a student she is right, she must not be betrayed into thinking she can do something that she Cannot.
Many teachers respond to almost-correct answers their students give in class by rounding up. That is they'll affirm the student's answer and repeat it, adding some detail of their own to make it fully correct even though the student didn't provide (and may not recognize) the differentiating factor. Imagine a student who's asked at the beginning of Romeo and Juliet how the Capulets and Montagues get along. “They don't like each other,” the student might say, in an answer that most teachers would, I hope, want some elaboration on before they called it fully correct. “Right,” the teacher might reply. “They don't like each other, and they have been feuding for generations.” But of course the student hadn't included the additional detail. That's the “rounding up.” Sometimes the teacher will even give the student credit for the rounding up as if the student said what he did not and what she merely wished he'd said, as in, “Right, what Kiley said was that they don't like each other and have been feuding. Good work, Kiley.” Either way, the teacher has set a low standard for correctness and explicitly told the class that they can be right even when they are not. Just as important, she has crowded out students' own thinking, doing cognitive work that students could do themselves (e.g., “So, is this a recent thing? A temporary thing? Who can build on Kiley's answer?”).
When answers are almost correct, it's important to tell students that they're almost there, that you like what they've done so far, that they're closing in on the right answer, that they've done some good work or made a great start. You can repeat a student's answer back to him so he can listen for what's missing and further correct—for example, “You said the Capulets and the Montagues didn't get along.” Or you can wait or prod or encourage or cajole in other ways to tell students what still needs doing, ask who can help get the class all the way there until you get students all the way to a version of right that's rigorous enough to be college prep: “Kiley, you said the Capulets and the Montagues didn't get along. Does that really capture their relationship? Does that sound like what they'd say about each other?”
In holding out for right, you set the expectation that the questions you ask and their answers truly matter. You show that you believe your students are capable of getting answers as right as students anywhere else. You show the difference between the facile and the scholarly. This faith in the quality of a right answer sends a powerful message to your students that will guide them long after they have left your classroom.
----------------------------------------
Spending time on the difference between the phrases “a 5 in the hundreds place” vs “5 hundred”, when both the student and the teacher understand them to mean the same thing is a waste of people’s focus. Instead the student could be doing something much more interesting, such as examining what the digits would mean in a base twelve system, discussing how a number is transformed when multiplying/dividing by ten, learning what happens to the digits in higher places when working with modular arithmetic, learning how to use an abacus to keep track of the place values, or developing an algorithm to transform back and forth between explicit counters like pebbles in a dish and their written decimal representations, etc. etc.
On the other hand, the question asked of droopybuns’s daughter is sort of interesting from a philosophy/sociology/pedagogy point of view. There’s not really much math content in it, but getting students to think about the ways the social context shapes expectations about right answers and effective ways to navigate a society full of bureaucrats with sticks up their asses is definitely worthy of discussion.
Finaly spoke with the teacher:
Bobby is wrong.
The "value" of the 5 is 500. They are learning number placement right now: 582 = 500 + 80 + 2
So the thing she is supposed to say is that the 5 is in the hundreds place, so it should be equal to 500.
I loathe that they assign the word "value" when the concept is contextual. The value of 5 is axiomatic, as is the value 582. When I explained this, the teacher's only response was to argue that this standard is almost verbatim outlined by the school district. <s> It must be right then! </s>
This teaching risks proving that 5=500.
Markmcc has an excellent counterpoint to my frustration, and I plan to use it to explain the objective of the question to my daughter.
“What quantity does the symbol ‘5’ in the decimal number ‘582’ represent?”
Then the answer is unambiguously ‘five hundreds’.
If the question is "how do the Capulets and Montagues get along," the answer "they don't like each other" is not partially right, it is right. It is not detailed or sophisticated, but the question didn't ask for detail or sophistication.
If we're going to call an answer "partially right" because it misses some nuance that could be explored in greater depth, than we could play that game all day long with anything that has ever been written. For example let's take your answer:
> The correct is that the value of 5 in 582 is 500, and an even better answer would be "the value of 5 in 582 is 500 because the 5 is in the hundreds place.
Ok let's play this game. "Partially correct," I say. "First of all, the fact that a 'hundreds place' exists at all is thanks to the relatively recent invention of Arabic numerals around 500 A.D. and its innovation of a numeral for zero, which previous number systems such as Roman numerals lacked. Secondly, the reason the third digit represents hundreds is because we use base 10 numbers by convention, which likely traces back to our hands and their 10 fingers. Other bases are used in different contexts, most notably hexidecimal in software engineering, in which case the '5' would be in the 256's place, representing 1280. Thirdly, the convention of writing digits is most-to-least significant order appears arbitrary -- it is hard to argue that it is linked to the order of text directionality, since the same order is used in both left-to-right (eg. Latin) and right-to-left (eg. Arabic) writing systems."
Solid B+ answer though. Don't worry, I have faith in your ability to produce a truly correct answer someday.
> the teacher has set a low standard for correctness and explicitly told the class that they can be right even when they are not.
That "explicitly" word strongly suggests to me the author doesn't know what he's talking about.
Bobby's teacher asked him what the value of the 5 in 582 is.
He answered that it was in the hundreds place. Did he answer the teachers question? If yes explain why. If no what is the right answer?
Bonus points if you can explain the intention of asking the value of a numeral in a larger integer.