Maybe for some genes, but for thousands of others, the signal is definitely there. Intelligence is highly heritable –as much as height. Just like height, it's spread across thousands of genes. Yet GWASes have found hundreds (soon to be thousands) of genes for height.[1] If researchers had a quarter of a million pairs of IQs and genomes, they'd find a similar number of genes for cognitive abilities.
> If you just optimise[sic] for one trait, the chances you'll even end up with a viable embryo after a dozen iterations are pretty slim.
That seems highly unlikely. We've done far worse with domesticated animals and they've been quite viable. Some breeds of dog are predisposed to genetic diseases such as hip dysplasia, but that's because we didn't have the ability to screen for genetic defects. (Or more cynically: breeders cared more about looks than diseases.)
When domesticating animals, breeders often found rare traits and exaggerated them. But for human cognitive abilities, the best alleles are already prevalent in the population. It's just that nobody has lucked into all of them at once. And unlike height, there's no square-cube law to disadvantage more cognitive horsepower.
> There's a lot of selective pressure on cognitive abilities; so there must be reasons why we aren't smarter than we are. These reasons will probably kill your experimental embryo.
Humans have definitely been selected for intelligence, but we were also selected for other things such as famine resistance. The tradeoffs are different today, and we can do a much better job than nature. We can fix a lot of mutation load. Really, we're not nearly as smart as we could be. In the words of Nick Bostrom:
> Far from being the smartest possible biological species, we are probably better thought of as the stupidest possible biological species capable of starting a technological civilization—a niche we filled because we got there first, not because we are in any sense optimally adapted to it.
1. http://www.nature.com/ng/journal/v46/n11/full/ng.3097.html
Concerning your comparison with breeding: you seem to misunderstand me. I don't think that breeding per se doesn't work. Breeding by looking at phenotypes works wonderful.
But what you suggest is to just iterate to optimise [according to my spellchecker that is how you spell it] according to a model. You are missing the step where those embryos grow (or fail to grow) into adults. Without this step, your optimisation procedure will drift randomly on every axis that your model doesn't measure.
Are you sure? http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20150413-the-downsides-of-be...
I have a pet theory that while a modest intelligence advantage is likely to be genuinely beneficial, social animals like humans quickly run into trouble if they stray more than a couple of standard deviations from the average. Imagine living all your life surrounded by idiots (parents, teachers and superiors included), having to explain the stupidest thing in painstaking detail (and regularly being scorned as the one who doesn't get it), and of course having no palatable romantic partners. Down that road lies bitterness, voluntary solitude and maybe substance abuse. Something like http://nautil.us/issue/21/information/the-man-who-tried-to-r...
I think this is the most accurate description I've ever seen of my pre-university life.
The paper you link is pretty handwavy regarding that point; Bostrom seems tho think that if we just had more data we will be able to find a model that links genotypes and phenotypes. However, this is far from certain. There are too many degrees of freedom in our genome, and there are too many factors that contribute to something generic like "cognitive ability". Each individual contribution is so tiny that the effect is lost in noise, even if we sampled all humans.
And even if someone comes up with a novel statistical method and finds a reasonable model, optimising that model would be pretty dangerous. If you just optimise for one trait, the chances you'll even end up with a viable embryo after a dozen iterations are pretty slim.
There's a lot of selective pressure on cognitive abilities; so there must be reasons why we aren't smarter than we are. These reasons will probably kill your experimental embryo.