This is the attitude American oligarchs have been trying to inculcate among the young. This was notably the goal of Pete Peterson's "the can kicks back" astroturfing campaign as well as Stan Druckenmiller's college campus campaigns, and even this neat piece of astroturf: http://www.quickmeme.com/Baby-Boomer-Dad/?upcoming
The idea is to keep young and old divided so that they will not form a cohesive political bloc that will not fight for each other's interests. The young will be complicit in strip-mining the pensions of the old. The old will be complicit in the absurd ramp up of student debt and the removal of pension rights from the young.
Embrace reason.
You're delusional. Where did I ever recommend reading Atlas Shrugged? Ayn Rand is nuts.
Personal attacks are not allowed on Hacker News, regardless of how off-base someone else may be.
I'm young-ish, I have no pension, I work for myself, and I'm definitely not well-off by any stretch. I have no horse in the pension game, except that I'm largely in the same boat as you (I'm guessing).
The difference is, I look at the people with pensions and I don't think, "oh those pension-holding fat cats". I look at them and think, what happened to the rest of us?
Why is it only the people whose decent standard of living was locked in by law or extensive contracts, why are they the only ones who definitely get to retire now?
There is a big con going on here, but it's not those folks with pensions, it's that the rest of us are now reduced to fighting over scraps.
You're right: that is rather impolite.
> what happened to the rest of us?
Pensions are a fundamentally stupid system. You shouldn't be depending on an employer to fulfill a defined benefit. Even if everything works perfectly (ie. the employer remains solvent and doesn't raid its pension fund), it provides a HUGE disincentive against pursuing job opportunities or entrepreneurship.
The solution is that everyone should be saving for themselves. I fail to see the "con" in people saving for their own retirement.
The con is that pensioners can use the threat of violence to force me to simultaneously save for my own retirement and pay for theirs when they never saved a penny.
Even if defined benefit pensions still existed, I would never get one as I have precisely 0 interest in working for the same employer 10+ years. I don't see why I should be forced to pay for people who are lifers.
You're right, people shouldn't have to depend on an employer for retirement (or health care)--that should be up to our government to provide us.
As for "violence," I have no idea what you're talking about, unless you're actually suggesting that the pensioners are wheeling their walkers up to you and shaking you down. Remember, taxation isn't violence.
Most of the private economy switched to individual retirement accounts (401Ks/IRAs) so that you don't have to depend on the ability of a private company that may or may not exists 40 years from now (when you retire) and you can instead depend on yourself.
Save some money. It's simple. You'll be fine.
Except, it obviously isn't working out in practice. People can't save enough, and it's not just down to a personal failing--it's systemic.
People can't save enough because our wages have been separated from our productivity--and kept down--for the last four decades. That's bigger than the individualistic "every man for himself" type of advice that "save some money" sounds like.
Besides, the realistic view suggests that something bigger is wrong, and something better should be done, when simplistic advice like that isn't working.
I was talking about you. Personally. Frondo.
http://calcoastnews.com/2014/12/slo-countys-six-figure-pensi...
I am not rich, but I am young. And I despise the fact that I'm paying for retirement programs and pensions for people who just happened to be born at the right time with the right job.
It's fundamentally unjust that we're forced, by law, to pay for benefits we will never receive.