News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by jacquesm on Saturday November 21, 2015 @11:33AM (#10607155)
I don't see how being able to write DNA will give you the ability to grow bamboo bedframes.
Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by ilurk on Saturday November 21, 2015 @11:55AM (#10607241)
Will DNA be Turing Complete? :)

Not the same, but quite related: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2JNSpMhJLvg

Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by udp on Saturday November 21, 2015 @12:23PM (#10607343)
> Will DNA be Turing Complete? :)

Actually... quite possibly. Check out the first slide in [1]. You can basically build genetic logic gates using promoters to conditionally (i.e. depending on the presence of light, a protein, etc.) produce a protein to induce or repress another promoter, thereby increasing or decreasing the expression of another gene.

It's still pretty early stages and there are a lot of factors that make this more complicated (life isn't binary), but the ultimate goal of synthetic biology is to be able to program DNA in the same way you might program a computer.

[1] http://co.mbine.org/events/COMBINE_2015/agenda?q=system/file...

Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by dekhn on Saturday November 21, 2015 @12:31PM (#10607365)
Yes, DNA (with a combination of some enzymes) is capable of universal computation. So far, this has not turned out to be anything particularly interesting from an engineering standpoint,
Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by cge on Saturday November 21, 2015 @03:43PM (#10607958)
Yes, even without enzymes and cells. I have DNA crystallization based tiling systems that can implement essentially arbitrary 1d cellular automata and could implement Turing machines directly. People have implemented neural networks with branch-migration-based systems, and DNA gates can be used to implement systems of logic gates and a wide class of chemical reaction networks. There's a whole field of DNA and molecular computing.
Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by crusso on Saturday November 21, 2015 @02:18PM (#10607700)
Will DNA be Turing Complete?

DNA (with supporting cell machinery) create us, so...

Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by astazangasta on Saturday November 21, 2015 @12:07PM (#10607276)
DNA is code, we just don't have a compiler yet.
Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by eli_gottlieb on Saturday November 21, 2015 @12:14PM (#10607297)
Phenotype = genotype + environment + reproductive phenotype (that is, the seed shell for a plant, egg for a bird, or the uterus for a mammal). Being able to rewrite the genotype doesn't give you total customization of the resulting phenotype.
Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by mylons on Saturday November 21, 2015 @12:19PM (#10607323)
and this is just our current understanding, which is certainly going to shift as measurement becomes cheaper and more accurate. iterative science!
Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by refurb on Saturday November 21, 2015 @03:52PM (#10607981)
Exactly!

Identical twins have the same DNA, but they don't have the same fingerprints. Why? Different environment in the womb.

Could we tweak things like eye color? Sure. Things like intelligence? Much, much harder.

Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by ethbro on Saturday November 21, 2015 @03:00PM (#10607833)
Wouldn't the reproductive phenotype in this case also be genetically controlled (albeit in the previous generation's)?
Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by eli_gottlieb on Sunday November 22, 2015 @11:11AM (#10610452)
Except that it's also subject to its own environmental influences, separately from those which impact the new individual after its birth.
Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by TeMPOraL on Saturday November 21, 2015 @01:29PM (#10607559)
DNA seems to be strongly compressed code that's also used as data. But we're not even sure if it encodes everything there is about an organism. Keep in mind that organisms aren't made in a single factory, they build child organisms, which then build further organisms, etc., creating a chain. You can imagine it as being a single runtime, accumulating state. It is possible that, e.g. replication machinery gets altered in such a way that it builds altered copies - the information about this alteration may had disappeared from DNA or never be there in the first place, and yet the alteration propagates.

TL;DR: read "Reflections on Trusting Trust", the same phenomena applies to biology.

Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by bsima on Monday November 23, 2015 @02:21PM (#10616616)
I think this was written just for you: http://xkcd.com/1605/
Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by Excavator on Saturday November 21, 2015 @03:00PM (#10607834)
Define compiler? As I recall it Genome Compiler[1] allows you to define functions and then order the finished product.

1: http://www.genomecompiler.com/

Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by mylons on Saturday November 21, 2015 @12:23PM (#10607341)
this is overly simplistic
Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by udp on Saturday November 21, 2015 @12:32PM (#10607367)
Simplistic, but a good way to think of the difference between genetic engineering and synthetic biology. Genetic engineering is like reverse engineering: poking around in an executable to change bits of the assembler and see what happens. Synthetic biology is attempting to build a top-down approach for genetic designs: specification, design, implementation, testing - and in that model, the DNA is the machine code and we are indeed trying to make a compiler.
Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by jacquesm on Saturday November 21, 2015 @12:36PM (#10607377)
Sure, but that still requires you to stay within the boundaries of what is expressible in the first place. Rakes, maybe. Bedframes: not so much.
Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by udp on Saturday November 21, 2015 @12:46PM (#10607413)
Yes, I'm not saying we're going to be able to grow bedframes. I just quite like the "DNA is code and we need a compiler" analogy.
Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by jacquesm on Saturday November 21, 2015 @12:59PM (#10607450)
If only it were that simple. We're very far away from understanding how a particular DNA string relates to phenotypes. All we've found to date is a bunch of configuration bits and maybe a general idea of how things might be related to each other but not much more than that.

The gap in understanding between 'here are a bunch of bits that appear to do 'x'' and 'x' is vast, far larger than the gap between say being able to build a compiler to have an executable perform in a certain way.

If anywhere that is where the real breakthrough will be, in being able to effectively map the chain of binary bits in a genome to a certain phenotype in a mature organism without any 'leftover bits'.

Once you have that chain of causality mapped out in enough detail to clearly link all causes with their effects you can start engineering something to act in a way that is far outside what we normally find in nature.

I'm not sure if I'm expressing myself clearly about all this, maybe someone more versed in the matter can chime in but the path between DNA and organism is a lot longer and less well understood than the path between a low level language program and the resulting output of that program. Just having a 'compiler' will not change much about that understanding, though once we have that compiler we may be able to advance our understanding by a more direct approach in modifying pieces of an existing genome to observe the effects in the organism. For sure it will speed things up.

edit: if we did have that understanding it would be trivial to create a digital representation of a (simple) organism from it's sequenced DNA. The fact that we are nowhere near capable of doing this is a simple proof that merely being able to create a certain sequence of bits will not give us the capability to create organisms to order.

Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by TeMPOraL on Saturday November 21, 2015 @01:20PM (#10607522)
Depends on what type of organisms are we talking about. We do have enough understanding to target bacteria with a "compiler" approach. That's the gist of synthetic biology and the stuff that's being done around iGEM competition.

Bacteria are "simple" enough that we can just append some DNA sequences and have them develop stuff we want. It's predictable enough that people already created "standard library" of DNA blocks - so people can work with bacteria in a kind of dataflow environment, with underlying DNA representation hidden. You connect a "molecule sensor" block with an "amplifier" block, an "inverter" block and a "light up" block, and you get bacteria that start to glow in presence of some metal, etc.

But of course, once we move to the level of multicellular organisms, the complexity explodes. Here, as you say, we basically know that something in an unaltered system sorta correlates with a particular phenotype and if we change it then maybe it won't blow up.

Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by jacquesm on Saturday November 21, 2015 @01:47PM (#10607615)
Sorry, yes, I was assuming 'multi-cellular organisms' as the context because of the bamboo rake comment at the beginning, but you're absolutely right that for single cells the situation will be different. Even so, if we're going to expand the scope downward we might as well go all the way, viruses, arguably even more simple than single celled organisms are still full of surprises.
Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by udp on Saturday November 21, 2015 @03:16PM (#10607886)
Sorry, yeah, I work with bacterial genomes and pretty much skipped over the bamboo comment.
Re:Cheap DNA Sequencing Is Here – Writing DNA Is Next by anonmeow on Saturday November 21, 2015 @09:25PM (#10608822)
>Just having a 'compiler' will not change much about that understanding

The compiler is called "genetic engineering" and it's a 30 years old field. In particular genetic engineering allows you to knockout specific genes and observe the phenotype. This technique is commonly used on bacteria, plants and animals. There is an ongoing mouse knockout project, an attempt to study every mouse gene by turning it off. It is 50% complete so far. By the way, the experiments are performed mostly by hand.

>We're very far away from understanding how a particular DNA string relates to phenotypes.

This problem can be solved much faster with a large scale effort. Thousands of automated experiments can run in parallel while recording the phenotype of the animals (including results of behavioral tests) and storing it for later analysis. On this genotype->phenotype dataset one can train an ML model. Actually there is a company that is trying this approach (just ML part, without automated experiments) http://www.deepgenomics.com/

I doubt that one company will be enough, though. With serious funding there could be much more progress in this area. We could have a full knockout map of mouse genome in less than a decade if we really wanted.