News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by crdoconnor on Saturday November 21, 2015 @10:02AM (#10606941)
John Arnold made money trading - a zero sum game by definition. All of that $4 billion is wealth that was extracted from somebody else.

Probably some of it from pension funds.

He is now using that money to lobby politicians to strip wealth from the working classes. He is paying PR companies to burnish his image for doing so (this article did not come out of nowhere).

What. a. hero.

>Or perhaps we can imagine that every single state or municipal pension system can make up the shortfall by taking money from all the billionaires they have lying around.

Yes, god forbid we should consider raising taxes on the 0.01% and using it to pay pensions for the working classes after they had so much of their money stolen by rapacious oligarchs like him.

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by jensen123 on Saturday November 21, 2015 @10:26AM (#10606981)
Have you actually tried to calculate how much money you could raise if you increased taxes on the richest 0.01%? And have you checked how much money is necessary to pay out pensions in the future?
Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by crdoconnor on Saturday November 21, 2015 @10:52AM (#10607048)
The top 0.1% have as much as the bottom 90% (which includes housing wealth as well as pension wealth).

So you could raise rather a lot more than you needed, actually.

Raising those taxes will also significantly drag down the cost of property (and consequently rents) which is the main outgoing for lower and middle class families.

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by fennecfoxen on Saturday November 21, 2015 @11:52AM (#10607227)
> The top 0.1% have as much as the bottom 90% (which includes housing wealth as well as pension wealth).

Even assuming tapping billionaires' wealth is a zero-impact answer, that doesn't necessarily help you if you're in a random municipality which has overpromised on its pension plan. As one example, take San Jose, which is Bay Area but not prime Bay Area (and beginning to see pension problems) and could easily see its richest citizens moving a few cities away to somewhere like Cupertino or Mountain View if it means a 5% savings on income tax. And what of cities like Stockton, CA, which was already bankrupted by its pensions and doesn't exactly have a bevy of billionaires to tap?

I guess you could hope for the day that the federal government decides to send a bunch of its money to your own local government, but the rest of the nation is likely to resent that so they might not approve of the measure.

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by crdoconnor on Saturday November 21, 2015 @02:31PM (#10607746)
>could easily see its richest citizens moving a few cities away

The richest citzens always make this threat but they don't actually follow through on it:

http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2011/04/29/135813061/studi...

Apparently if you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it.

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by fennecfoxen on Saturday November 21, 2015 @05:23PM (#10608278)
That's an article about high-tax states like California and NYC. In the case of San Jose you can move literally five miles, work the same job, have the same friends, even shop at the same places that you did before, but have a different tax regime.

And that still doesn't help Stockton.

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by harryh on Saturday November 21, 2015 @11:32AM (#10607152)
> The top 0.1% have as much as the bottom 90%

False.

Some claim that the top 1% have as much as the bottom 90% but even that claim is disputed.

http://www.vanityfair.com/news/2011/05/top-one-percent-20110...

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by dahart on Saturday November 21, 2015 @11:57AM (#10607249)
This might be the misquoted source for the claim you're refuting: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/24/opinion/nicholas-kristof-i...

That article is discussing wealth (net worth) versus the article you cited which discusses income. No surprise that the lines between rich and poor differ when you measure it different ways.

I found that via: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_inequality_in_the_Uni...

One question: aside from arguing the specific numbers, it is irrefutably true that a small minority hold the majority of the money, and it is widely reported that the gap is currently growing, not shrinking. Is this a good thing? Do the specific numbers change the outcome or what our course of action should be? Even that Vanity Fair article concludes the situation is bad.

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by harryh on Saturday November 21, 2015 @12:02PM (#10607261)
A line from the article I linked:

"In terms of wealth rather than income, the top 1 percent control 40 percent."

> Do the specific numbers change the outcome or what our course of action should be?

Of course the data matters! Especially when (as crdoconnor did) you report data that is incorrect by an order of magnitude!

Jesus.

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by dllthomas on Saturday November 21, 2015 @02:24PM (#10607722)
"In terms of wealth rather than income, the top 1 percent control 40 percent."

That doesn't seem to contradict anything said up-thread.

If the top 0.1% control 20% of the wealth, the next 0.9% control another 20% of the wealth, and the bottom 90% control 20% of the wealth, then the claim you objected to is true. That would mean the remaining 9%, between the top 1% and the bottom 90%, control the wealth that remains - 40%. I don't think these amounts violate any of the ordering constraints, given the relative size of the groups; in reality there will be variation within the individual groups, but if we assume there isn't the math checks out fine: 20/0.1 > 20/0.9 > 40/9 > 20/90

I'm not saying the original claim was correct - I don't know. Just that what you quoted doesn't refute it.

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by harryh on Saturday November 21, 2015 @02:38PM (#10607768)
And that's really the most interesting thing to talk about here. Not what's right and wrong but the degree to which I've properly quoted evidence to support my pov.

Really?

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by dllthomas on Saturday November 21, 2015 @02:58PM (#10607826)
Your position that is data matters, as long as we don't pay attention to what it actually means?

You accused someone of being wrong "by an order of magnitude" and the "evidence" you produced did not even demonstrate that it was likely that they were wrong. If the data matters, fucking understand the data.

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by harryh on Saturday November 21, 2015 @03:08PM (#10607863)
I do understand the data. And I'm not wrong.

I'm just not really interested in doing the legwork to provide you with perfectly cited sources. This is Hacker News not the US Congress. You know how to use Google.

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by dllthomas on Saturday November 21, 2015 @03:43PM (#10607956)
In general, evidence provided in discussion is more useful if it's likely to be called out when it is invalid or irrelevant, so I called it out - giving my reasoning.

You might not be wrong. You manifestly don't understand the data. Observe that, learn from it, update your confidence.

"I'm just not really interested in doing the legwork to provide you with perfectly cited sources."

I was not disputing the citations of your sources, and I wasn't demanding perfection. I was demanding that what was provided as evidence that someone was wrong "by an order of magnitude" actually be evidence they were wrong at all.

"This is Hacker News not the US Congress."

Exactly! So we're agreed that we should expect at least a modicum of decency, and respect for argument and informed discussion?

"You know how to use Google."

I do, and I know that it doesn't do a very good job answering these kinds of questions.

I engaged more deeply with your evidence (including the article you drew it from) precisely because I hoped it would inform me in the ways you'd indicated that it should. I was left disappointed.

Unfortunately, you seem quite a bit more interested in rhetoric and posturing than in actually engaging intellectually, so unless your replies are inordinately better than those above I won't be responding further.

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by dahart on Saturday November 21, 2015 @12:17PM (#10607313)
I don't disagree with your numbers, or with the notion that accuracy is important. But just for fun, what, exactly, is the difference in course of action you would take given his numbers versus Vanity Fairs'?

To make my point more clearly, you (and vanity fair, and Wikipedia) say the top 1% is two orders of magnitude larger than its relative size (40x). Some claim, and Vanity Fair doesn't exactly refute that the top 1% are two orders of magnitude larger than its relative size (90x). Crdoconnor appears to have misquoted by one order of magnitude, saying that the unfairness ratio is three orders of magnitude (900x).

So, ignoring crdconnors accidental misquote, and playing devils advocate for a moment, what substantive policy decisions should differ across the line between two orders of magnitude inequality versus three?

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by harryh on Saturday November 21, 2015 @12:24PM (#10607346)
The breadth of the tax base necessary to support the pension plans in question (or, for that matter, broad swaths of other social policies on the liberal agenda) is much wider than is implied by misreporting of the degree of inequality.

Put more simply: Just taxing the rich more isn't enough to pay for everything.

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by jayvanguard on Saturday November 21, 2015 @11:41AM (#10607191)
The article you reference doesn't actually provide any evidence that the claim is false.
Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by xiaoma on Saturday November 21, 2015 @11:41AM (#10607185)
Setting the numbers aside for a moment, a wealth tax would definitely have a large effect.

It's a somewhat extreme measure by the standards of modern tax schemes though, and it would cause a much higher number of super wealthy people to expatriate than just raising income and capital gains taxes would.

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by minot on Saturday November 21, 2015 @11:18AM (#10607124)
I honestly doubt we can raise the marginal tax on income (even just income over $1M a year) to over 50%. Not in the foreseeable future at least as far as the US is concerned.
Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by harryh on Saturday November 21, 2015 @12:31PM (#10607366)
It's already over 50% in CA (as well as various other places).

39.6% (Fed) + 12.3% (CA) = 51.9%

There are city taxes as well in some places, for example add an additional 1.5% to that if you live in SF.

Thinking about this, I suppose that the fact that you can deduct state taxes on your fed taxes brings this down a bit so maybe it does dip below 50? Not sure about the math. Real close though.

Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by gergles on Saturday November 21, 2015 @02:57PM (#10607824)
The deduction you can make on your federal taxes for state taxes paid vanishes once you're in AMT land which you almost certainly are if you're in the 39.6% tax bracket.
Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes by harryh on Saturday November 21, 2015 @03:05PM (#10607852)
If you're paying the AMT the 39.6% doesn't apply. The top AMT rate is 28%.

Whether you pay the AMT or not isn't really based on how much money you make. It's based on how many deductions not allowed under the AMT you take (deductibility of state taxes being the biggest one).