Re:A billionaire targeting contrarian, underappreciated causes
by harryh on Saturday November 21, 2015 @12:24PM
(#10607346)
The breadth of the tax base necessary to support the pension plans in question (or, for that matter, broad swaths of other social policies on the liberal agenda) is much wider than is implied by misreporting of the degree of inequality.
Put more simply: Just taxing the rich more isn't enough to pay for everything.
To make my point more clearly, you (and vanity fair, and Wikipedia) say the top 1% is two orders of magnitude larger than its relative size (40x). Some claim, and Vanity Fair doesn't exactly refute that the top 1% are two orders of magnitude larger than its relative size (90x). Crdoconnor appears to have misquoted by one order of magnitude, saying that the unfairness ratio is three orders of magnitude (900x).
So, ignoring crdconnors accidental misquote, and playing devils advocate for a moment, what substantive policy decisions should differ across the line between two orders of magnitude inequality versus three?