The reasons it matters to me:
- The government shouldn't have the right to wire-tap all citizens at once. We already established that for analog telephones, but digital has become an excuse to undo the annoying requirement of establishing probable cause. If they have the right to listen to you through mass means, no encryption will help you.
- They are spending our tax dollars doing this. The money matters, and they basically taking our money and using it against us. At best it's a waste of that money.
- If they establish the right to curb strong encryption, you may be right in the sense that it doesn't matter to the criminals who use illegal and strong encryption. But it does matter to the vast majority of the law abiding world who get stuck with "encryption" that is readily readable by anyone who expresses an interest, and allows the govt to keep collecting mass surveillance unhindered.
Banning encryption is like banning breathing. Yeah, they can, but we all still have to do it.
To borrow a cliche, if encryption is outlawed, only outlaws will have encryption.
I don't think encryption can be outlawed, but it can be hamstrung by weakened implementations and requirements to decrypt for "lawful requests".
That may well be the real objective. I wouldn't be terribly surprised if big players are lobbying behind the scenes for the government to mandate a new kind of FIPS for all consumer crypto, which would lock smaller players out of the market and of course make us all safer from 'terr (right?). Remember how SOPA was lobbied for by GoDaddy so they could sell a new expensive premium class of domain registration?
Using bloody crimes and tragedies to lobby for unfair market advantage. It's how business is done in Washington (and probably other capitols too).
They can try, and they can make your life hell for using it. It won't work, of course, but that has never stopped frightened people or those with an agenda.
This is why it is incredibly important that we not only use encryption pervasively, but that we also educate[1] the general public about encryption. Unless encryption is normalized into the popular culture, it will always be possible to harass "those troublemakers" that use encryption and the general public won't care. This crap will end only after people understand that "banning encryption" is as stupid as "banning envelopes/locks".
> This kind of thing doesn't matter.
Encryption doesn't protect you from traffic analysis. It is important to remember that so-called metadata is often more revealing[2] than the content, especially when you 0wn3d the backbone and can map[3] who everybody you talk to.
[1] specifically, we need to educate people to a similar level that people understand physical locks: "what is does" and "when/how it should be used" are key; the details can be left to professionals (i.e. like locksmiths).
[2] http://labs.rs/en/metadata/
[3] https://www.washingtonpost.com/apps/g/page/world/how-the-nsa...
In any case, the strategy lately has been to force consumer ISPs to keep logs of who is connecting where (The UK government wants ISPs to log the URI of every plaintext page you visit, and will no doubt eventually want DNS logs and TLS SNI and TCP connection logs for other kinds of connectivity).
The best you can do today is ensure your TLS deployment is A+ rated at SSL Labs[0] and offer a Tor hidden service for your visitors. That said, if governments and ISPs legislate/cooperate to do active MITM attacks, then there's nothing we can really do to help Joe Public that wouldn't constitute a crime or get you put on a watchlist yourself.
1. a sufficiently clever and malicious person can implement broken encryption in a virtually-undetectable, and perhaps even deniable way 2. the government has the capability of exerting enormous pressure on app manufacturers and service providers
Given 1 & 2, it's reasonable to assume that an unknown and possibly great number of encrypted chat and encrypted email and encrypted etc are all subverted.
Try spending couple of hours being beaten by government thugs just because you encrypted something (they won't even bother asking you decrypt) and you will sing another tune.
Lets assume that the relative physical safety that a person enjoys in the west in the hands of the LEO is the exception and not the norm worldwide.
Governments can stop anything they want if they are strong or desperate enough.