Re:Telegram probably isn't as secure as ISIS thinks
by nickpsecurity on Friday November 20, 2015 @07:20PM
(#10604794)
Glad at least one person mentions it albeit near the bottom of the comments. I've been telling them that since before the Snowden leaks. Nice summary of required assurance activities and areas where issues pop up:
The one exception is Ottela's Tinfoil Chat. It needs a robust, low-level implementation instead of Python. Yet, he cleverly dodged much of the TCB problem by creatively applying what he learned from others plus input we gave him on Schneier's blog for high assurance security & general improvements. So, you can build on and use that* but the rest depend on what top-tier and organized crime can buy attacks for. Ridiculous....
* Again, without Python and with TCB enhancements. OpenBSD at the least for its lower 0-days.
My bet is that the real bad guys always use face2face when possible, and voice/video with codewords and visual cues when there's no other choice... and maybe an encripted sdcard carried by hand/mail when they really need to cary large volumes. They can't be stupid enough to use anything else for such high risk stuff!
I'd guess that the only people actually depending on good consumer-lever crypto are whistleblowers, anti-goverment protesters and individuals and companies that truly value their privacy for one reason or another! Are these the people we want to hurt here?!