News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Step Toward Protecting Fair Use on YouTube by pdkl95 on Thursday November 19, 2015 @10:29PM (#10599398)
> stream videos, or is file download required

And what, exactly, is the difference for a server?

The myth that there is something called "streaming" that is in any way different from a "download" needs to die.

Re:A Step Toward Protecting Fair Use on YouTube by losvedir on Thursday November 19, 2015 @10:55PM (#10599463)
> And what, exactly, is the difference for a server?

Off the top of my head:

* "Streaming" could imply a few different files of differing quality that the downloader dynamically changes between.

* Scrubbing to see previews further ahead and back, in order to jump to playback at a particular point.

* Throttling bandwidth to just that required for realtime playback. Most people don't watch the full video, so no need to download too far ahead of where playback is.

* Not downloading too much further if the video is paused.

There are definitely times that you want to download the file, but I definitely think of "streaming" as encompassing the above features. When I'm in a bandwidth constrained environment, in particular, I often prefer the streaming experience.

Re:A Step Toward Protecting Fair Use on YouTube by mikeash on Thursday November 19, 2015 @11:06PM (#10599505)
I don't think "streaming" implies any of that. I don't believe YouTube had any of these features when it first arrived.

All "streaming" really implies is that you can watch as you download. That requires the download to be linear (e.g. traditional BitTorrent downloads aren't streaming), the format to be linear (can't put vital information at the end of the file), and the download speed to be high enough to download at least one second of content for each second of download time.

Everything you describe is nice, but not necessary.

Re:A Step Toward Protecting Fair Use on YouTube by pdkl95 on Friday November 20, 2015 @12:20AM (#10599748)
All of those are features that have been supported with various file transfer tools. In the end, you're still opening a TCP socket, doing some management to request the file, and transferring that relevant data. There are numerous ways to accomplish this, but it's still a variation of (request file, receive data).

"Streaming" isn't a technical feature. It's a fiction designed to fool non-technical people (often in management, marketing, or legal). Usually this used as a euphemism for a broken client that doesn't have a "save" button.

Re:A Step Toward Protecting Fair Use on YouTube by walterbell on Thursday November 19, 2015 @11:01PM (#10599486)
At a minimum, beginning download/playback at a time offset.
Re:A Step Toward Protecting Fair Use on YouTube by pdkl95 on Friday November 20, 2015 @12:14AM (#10599730)
Downloading files starting at arbitrary offsets was supported in FTP (and probably much earlier). The tools "curl" and "wget" use this to continue broken downloads.