The process is called tumbling, and it's primarily how bitcoin tax evaders use it now to get around the "public ledger".
>The process is called tumbling, and it's primarily how bitcoin tax evaders use it now to get around the "public" ledger.
I very briefly addressed this at the bottom of my comment.
In short order:
- Tumbling is traceable: throw a beefy server at the list of transactions, and since you know how much money arrived in someone's possession on a given date, you can now trace it backwards by crunching the numbers. Analysing long lists of transactions like this is something computers are really good at.
- But that doesn't matter, because tumbling sites can't work: they don't have enough capital in them to successfully launder more than a few play dollars at a time.
For example: 20 BTC -> $4000 -> 25000 yuan -> 4 new addresses @ 5, 10, 2, & 8 BTC
The only way to trace these is to compromise the exchange servers, get account information, and subpoena transactions from the banks. Very difficult to do given the international nature of these exchanges and banks.
I was specifically addressing tumbling services. I'm guessing that you accept those services are easy to compromise (heck, for all we know, various governments might operate the current ones) which is why you bring up currency conversion.
>For example: 20 BTC -> $4000 -> 25000 yuan -> 4 new addresses @ 5, 10, 2, & 8 BTC
Let's turn this around: you have a list of transactions, you know when they took place, you know where the money ended up, and now you're tracing the line backwards, knowing that at some point, there will be a connection (or connections) to other transactions at least as big as this one; why do you think this is so hard to analyse?
>The only way to trace these is to compromise the exchange servers, get bank account information, and get transactions from the banks. Very difficult to do given the international nature of these exchanges.
Not really, given how little is known about some exchanges' operators.
Why do you insist it isn't.
1) bitcoin to cash or cash to bitcoin is pretty hard to trace unless you catch the actual handover.
2) As for the 'connections'. Anyone who knows what they are doing would spin up a wallet per transaction making connections non existant.
Of course mistakes can and will be made, at which point using bitcoin can become a bigger liability than cash/banks because everything is public. But given perfect usage, it is extremely difficult to ascertain any information.
I hope you realize that you haven't actually described a process for tracing Bitcoin transactions. You can't just take an arbitrary problem, say "throw a computer at it", and consider it solved.
I don't mean to be abrasive, but you are clearly ignorant of the state of affairs of Bitcoin anonymity systems. Look up coinjoin, for starters. When you have highly-connected (in the graph sense), properly conducted mixing systems, you can't just "trace the transactions".
You could trace it if the person getting the outputs was dumb enough to recombine them or spend them in all the same way. I suspect most people who tumble store the coins in those addresses and only spend small amounts later.
Tumbling has been used by people being tracked and has been effective at them not being caught. Read the bitcoin forums.
Bitcoin is indeed untraceable, with care.
Someone has yet to successfully explain how you differentiate coins once they enter a single wallet. Say you know with certainty who owns a given address. That person makes a transaction sending the coins to another wallet, and the owner of that wallet makes another transaction.
You do not know who controls the second and third wallets. It could be the original owner splitting their money up. It could be a legitimate business accepting payment for services.
There's no way just looking at the blockchain to tell the difference between 'tumbling' and other perfectly normal transactions, save for very easily defeated statistical analysis
Are you sure about that? I believe most of the onion drug markets have their own tumblers running in the background, so sending money to them and then withdrawing it should get you mixed funds. I'd expect the scale of business of those sites to result in quite a large mixing pot.
So no, such mechanisms are not traceable by any reasonable metric.
You're right about the volume of plausibly tumble-able money being low, but it's at least in the five or six digits per day.
I mean, in a way, maybe this is what this story is all about: a great big advertisement saying "Come use this completely anonymous payment system," with a sly nudge and a wink because bitcoin's nothing of the sort.
Just imagine: a plot is discovered, payment details made via bitcoin stumbled upon - and now you have a long list of every transaction those people have ever made using Bitcoin!
(for the inevitable bitcoin cult members wanting to chime in about "tumbling" or "fog" services, aka bitcoin money launderers, 1. they're still traceable and 2. there's not enough money going through them to successfully launder a four-digit amount, let alone anything greater.)