He then went on to point out that Ferguson black-and-white "us" and "them" was a childish crayon drawing of reality, which is a fair point, and it's not PC to point out someone massively simplifying.
He followed this up with pointing out that another source Ferguson cited, but butchered, offered observations that cut the legs out from under Ferguson.
He didn't need to point out the specific details of 5th c. Rome to point out the problems in Ferguson's article, Ferguson wasn't even writing at a point where one could say he was wrong on the topic.
May I ask what in particular is seen as wrong (factually?) with Gibbon's view of Rome by today's historians? Did new information come to light since he wrote his books that makes him unsuitable for a serious historian to cite?
Modern historians still do look to those historians, but are much more critical about vetting their reliability on topics, have more texts to work with (largely in thanks to the Oxyrhynchus discoveries - Oxyrhynchus was basically an ancient garbage dump in Egypt which thanks to the arid climate preserved a huge trove of texts.) Historians also have a lot of other material to work with - archaeology, epigraphy, numismatics that either weren't available or weren't really considered in Gibbon's time. Many of these offer more objective data about the goings on of the empire and can tell us a lot about things happening all over the empire and show how unreliable the texts discussing events can be.
Modern historiography tries to approach history from as objective and critical a stance as can be managed, rather than seeing history as a kind of tapestry to weave a preconceived narrative from. Gibbon's historiographical approach was to weave a history from the documents that while for the most part was roughly accurate in many details, was all about building a grand narrative of how the Late Empire fell due to Christianity effectively ruining everything it touched, miring the empire in "superstition," and "enthusiasms." Today historians recognize that we are better off focusing on building as reliable an account as we can while a historian should (at least attempt to) leave the moralizing and grand narratives out.
This is to say nothing about Europe's interests in preventing an influx of refugees, just that likening the West's conflict with Islamic extremists to the circumstances surrounding the fall of Rome is nonsense.
Not entirely nonsense. Halfway maybe. Europe, like Rome, has been in decline for almost a century by now. Now opportunists are taking advantage.
Of course, Roman Empire was not being pushed, to accept anyone. Europe is under intense pressure from the US and the global trade elites who believe in 'Open Borders', as a way to keep profits and power.
far easier to practice electoral 'divide and conquer' in ethnically non-homogenous populations..
This fb post doesn't belong on HN.
I'm not debating his position, which I respect, but his argument. If an argument is nothing more than talking about how angry one is and then attacking those who hold the opposing position, it's noise at best and a rallying cry to a mob at worst.
* Ferguson knows very little about the 5th Century, by his own admission
* Ferguson cites Edward Gibbon, who is a poor source by modern standards. Gibbon himself felt that he his conclusions were invalid.
* Ferguson grossly oversimplifies his other source, because that source tries to say the exact opposite of what Ferguson concludes.
I feel like you skimmed the post, found some PC-like arguments, and concluded that its weak.
Your feelings have lead you astray in this case. I read every word.
I read Humphries' claims of his own expertise in 5th century history, his claims of Ferguson's ignorance and claims and over-simplification of the same and his outright personal attack at the end and I was not impressed with either his critique or his methods. Rather than attacking the person (or even his sources), why not address the actual fallacies in his historical analogies?
What is good for a political talk show blowhard seeking ratings is not the same as what is good for a constructive discussion.
As far as I can see, PC just replaces one form of prejudice with another - I would never encourage PC from anyone. However, tolerance of the tolerant and equal respect regardless of differences (which is NOT PC) is something I promote. Simply call him racist - pure and simple. Segregating one ethnicity/religion/gender is nothing short of prejudice (eg. the woman that runs she++ falls in the same boat ... she believes genders should be treated differently, that's PC and sexist. Read her comments on Forbes - she constantly draws lines between genders with stereotypes).
>it was the barbarians who ultimately sacked Rome and not a civil war that did them in.
I would view the collapse of Rome through corruption/apathy and barbarian attacks. If Rome had the finances to support an army, the hordes would have been far less of an issue. You can read more about it here, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fall_of_the_Western_Roman_Empi...
Ie in this example the FB professor is unhappy that Fergusson considers the native European populations vs the muslim immigrants and concludes that "the majority hold views not easily reconciled with the principles of our liberal democracies, including our novel notions about sexual equality and tolerance not merely of religious diversity but of nearly all sexual proclivities".
He doesn't say - 'Wait, buddy, you're wrong. Muslim immigrants do hold views compatible with X,Y,Z". Instead he says "How dare you draw comparison between the two groups, that's not cool!"
> (From the article) But this is a straw man argument, producing a caricature of “us” that fails to account for the wide variety of opinions on matters of inclusion and tolerance to be found across Europe. In equal fashion, his construction of a Muslim “other” is a caricature devoid of nuance.
Just take the fact that many, if not most, terrorists before becoming radicalized are secular second generation immigrants. That is what makes them easy to recruit, because of their search of a sense of belonging and not already having conflicting views on religion. If you want to talk about e.g. honor killings those attitudes might be relevant, but they aren't relevant enough when talking about these recent events to be the single focus.
The PC factor is exactly this - Ferguson doesn't shy away from putting light on it while the FB professor is horrified by the construct of the 'other' that's devoid of nuance.
> It seems that the actions of the terrorists allow for a fairly easy us vs them categorization.
Why? For you?
> yet the terrorists all come from specific subset
What subset is that? Plenty of terrorism isn't based on religion.
> So there is some commonality between them [...]
And that is? Of course there's some commonality, but you actually have to specify which and why to have an argument.
> Ferguson doesn't shy away from putting light on it
What part of his writing does that? The part I've read very much paints with broad strokes and doesn't at all focus on "the commonality of a specific subset of terrorists". As you would expect from a history professor.
Sexes are different. In some areas, like strength, they almost form non-overlapping sets.
In others, like personality, there is not much overlap either.
See for example: http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal....
Why do you think you can motivate women and men by using the exact same thing? Biology has made both value different things. Discernible in voting patterns and gov't preferences. Here is a paper on how giving franchise to women impacted US government..
http://www.people.fas.harvard.edu/~iversen/PDFfiles/LottKenn...
Do you think men enjoy the same things as women? Treating everyone the same is a very good way of not getting anything done.
And as to stereotyping. It's unavoidable. The human brain is wired so it tries to abstract and save effort. Dealing with everyone as a total unknown is not we're set up.
Furthermore, stereotypes are somewhat accurate. Moreso than social science. Obviously, if they are accurate they are useful.
See for example: https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/rabble-rouser/201408/st...
But all I see is a left-wing professor unhappy with insufficient PC-ness of someone's argument (too Western-centric, not afraid to use the 'us-them' language, etc).
His one real point is that the Rome collapsed because of partly internal and partly external factors. That's certainly true - but it was the barbarians who ultimately sacked Rome and not a civil war that did them in.