News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Paris Attacks and the Abuse of History by xiaoma on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @11:20PM (#10585896)
What good does responding to a laughable argument with a angry laughable argument do?

This fb post doesn't belong on HN.

Re:The Paris Attacks and the Abuse of History by rtl49 on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @11:35PM (#10585940)
One possible reason is that Ferguson's words lent credibility to a social movement the author considers destructive. Even if the remarks were absurd in the context of the available evidence, few people will read further than to see they were written by a Harvard professor.
Re:The Paris Attacks and the Abuse of History by xiaoma on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @12:36AM (#10586126)
Does lashing out against something one feels is destructive without a reasoned argument accomplish anything positive? I have my doubts that it does. It might even lend weight to the very arguments he's attacking since he's made such a weak argument.

I'm not debating his position, which I respect, but his argument. If an argument is nothing more than talking about how angry one is and then attacking those who hold the opposing position, it's noise at best and a rallying cry to a mob at worst.

Re:The Paris Attacks and the Abuse of History by nindalf on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @01:42AM (#10586355)
The argument in the facebook post appears reasoned. He points out that

* Ferguson knows very little about the 5th Century, by his own admission

* Ferguson cites Edward Gibbon, who is a poor source by modern standards. Gibbon himself felt that he his conclusions were invalid.

* Ferguson grossly oversimplifies his other source, because that source tries to say the exact opposite of what Ferguson concludes.

I feel like you skimmed the post, found some PC-like arguments, and concluded that its weak.

Re:The Paris Attacks and the Abuse of History by xiaoma on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @02:29AM (#10586472)
>I feel like you skimmed the post

Your feelings have lead you astray in this case. I read every word.

I read Humphries' claims of his own expertise in 5th century history, his claims of Ferguson's ignorance and claims and over-simplification of the same and his outright personal attack at the end and I was not impressed with either his critique or his methods. Rather than attacking the person (or even his sources), why not address the actual fallacies in his historical analogies?

What is good for a political talk show blowhard seeking ratings is not the same as what is good for a constructive discussion.